FSE wiki: independent fact-check corrections: Dallas band, Ontario scope and disability profiles (written by Claude Opus 5.5) |
Wiki review: corrected 5 errors: link (5) (Claude Opus 5.5) |
||
| (2 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
Around that time, children under 5 were 74 percent more likely than the average person to die in a home fire, and adults aged 65 and older about twice as likely. The youngest and oldest groups together accounted for 53 percent of US home fire deaths in 2002, against 38.9 percent in 1980.<ref name="Gamache-5-63" /> Their higher risk has several roots: dependence on others, reduced ability to notice a fire or to escape, greater physical vulnerability to smoke and burns, and living conditions linked to poverty.<ref name="HC-3-21">Hall and Cote (2008), p. 3-21.</ref><ref name="Purser-2-90">Purser (2002), p. 2-90.</ref><ref name="Purser-2-128">Purser (2002), p. 2-128.</ref><ref name="Gamache-5-72">Gamache (2008), p. 5-72.</ref> The highest-risk groups also tend to be the hardest to reach with fire prevention programmes. Programmes therefore need to reach these groups deliberately.<ref name="HC-3-13-14">Hall and Cote (2008), pp. 3-13–3-14.</ref> | Around that time, children under 5 were 74 percent more likely than the average person to die in a home fire, and adults aged 65 and older about twice as likely. The youngest and oldest groups together accounted for 53 percent of US home fire deaths in 2002, against 38.9 percent in 1980.<ref name="Gamache-5-63" /> Their higher risk has several roots: dependence on others, reduced ability to notice a fire or to escape, greater physical vulnerability to smoke and burns, and living conditions linked to poverty.<ref name="HC-3-21">Hall and Cote (2008), p. 3-21.</ref><ref name="Purser-2-90">Purser (2002), p. 2-90.</ref><ref name="Purser-2-128">Purser (2002), p. 2-128.</ref><ref name="Gamache-5-72">Gamache (2008), p. 5-72.</ref> The highest-risk groups also tend to be the hardest to reach with fire prevention programmes. Programmes therefore need to reach these groups deliberately.<ref name="HC-3-13-14">Hall and Cote (2008), pp. 3-13–3-14.</ref> | ||
[[File:fse-high-risk-populations-v1.svg|thumb|upright=1.5|alt=Four boxes of risk factors, each listing the groups concerned, with arrows to a box labelled higher fire death and injury rates|Four groups of reasons for a higher fire risk, with the populations they mainly concern.]] | |||
== Identifying high-risk groups == | == Identifying high-risk groups == | ||
A group is called high-risk when its rate of fire deaths or injuries, relative to its size, is clearly higher than the average. Such rates come from [[ | A group is called high-risk when its rate of fire deaths or injuries, relative to its size, is clearly higher than the average. Such rates come from [[fire statistics]]; Gamache (2008) mostly expresses the [[fire death rate]] in deaths per million population per year.<ref name="Gamache-5-67">Gamache (2008), p. 5-67.</ref> Hall and Weller (2008) list national, state and local data as the means to identify high-risk populations such as toddlers, elders, people with disabilities and people affected by poverty.<ref name="HW-5-136">Hall and Weller (2008), p. 5-136.</ref> Hall and Twomey (2008) observe that the very young and older adults are the two high-risk age groups for fire deaths. Older adults are at higher risk for almost every form of fatal injury in the built environment.<ref name="HT-1-4">Hall and Twomey (2008), p. 1-4.</ref><ref name="HT-1-8">Hall and Twomey (2008), p. 1-8.</ref> | ||
The comparison is usually expressed as a relative risk. It divides the rate for the group by the rate for a reference group, such as the whole population or another group. A value above 1 means that the group is at higher risk than the reference group. Gamache (2008) uses this measure for Dallas census tracts, with the highest-income tracts as the reference.<ref name="Gamache-5-72" /> | The comparison is usually expressed as a relative risk. It divides the rate for the group by the rate for a reference group, such as the whole population or another group. A value above 1 means that the group is at higher risk than the reference group. Gamache (2008) uses this measure for Dallas census tracts, with the highest-income tracts as the reference.<ref name="Gamache-5-72" /> | ||
| Line 21: | Line 22: | ||
As a worked example, the US fire death rate for males in 1999 to 2002 was 12.1 deaths per million population, and that for females 8.8. The relative risk of males is therefore 12.1/8.8 = 1.38, which Gamache reports as 38 percent higher. At age 85 and over, the rates were 58.5 for men and 27.8 for women, a relative risk of about 2.1.<ref name="Gamache-5-67" /> A relative risk of 2 means twice the reference risk. The statement that adults aged 65 and older are twice as likely to die in a fire thus corresponds to a relative risk of about 2.<ref name="Gamache-5-63" /> | As a worked example, the US fire death rate for males in 1999 to 2002 was 12.1 deaths per million population, and that for females 8.8. The relative risk of males is therefore 12.1/8.8 = 1.38, which Gamache reports as 38 percent higher. At age 85 and over, the rates were 58.5 for men and 27.8 for women, a relative risk of about 2.1.<ref name="Gamache-5-67" /> A relative risk of 2 means twice the reference risk. The statement that adults aged 65 and older are twice as likely to die in a fire thus corresponds to a relative risk of about 2.<ref name="Gamache-5-63" /> | ||
[[File:fse-high-risk-populations-v2.svg|thumb|upright=1.5|alt=Bar chart of approximate relative risk of home fire death in the United States for children under 5 and adults aged 65, 75 and 85 and older|Approximate relative risk of dying in a home fire compared with the average US resident, around 1999 to 2002.]] | |||
Relative risks depend on the place and the period. Hall (2008) notes that young children in Japan were not a distinctively high-risk group, while in the United States preschool children had more than double the risk of everyone else. For older adults, the gap with the rest of the population was much wider in Japan than in the United States.<ref name="Hall-5-106">Hall (2008), p. 5-106.</ref> US civilian fire deaths fell from 7,395 in 1977 to 3,900 in 2004, yet the same groups continued to have disproportionate death rates.<ref name="Gamache-5-63" /> Place matters too: from 1997 to 2001, US communities with fewer than 2,500 inhabitants had 30.9 fire deaths per million population, at least twice the rate of most larger community sizes.<ref name="Ahrens-3-64">Ahrens et al. (2008), p. 3-64.</ref> | Relative risks depend on the place and the period. Hall (2008) notes that young children in Japan were not a distinctively high-risk group, while in the United States preschool children had more than double the risk of everyone else. For older adults, the gap with the rest of the population was much wider in Japan than in the United States.<ref name="Hall-5-106">Hall (2008), p. 5-106.</ref> US civilian fire deaths fell from 7,395 in 1977 to 3,900 in 2004, yet the same groups continued to have disproportionate death rates.<ref name="Gamache-5-63" /> Place matters too: from 1997 to 2001, US communities with fewer than 2,500 inhabitants had 30.9 fire deaths per million population, at least twice the rate of most larger community sizes.<ref name="Ahrens-3-64">Ahrens et al. (2008), p. 3-64.</ref> | ||
| Line 34: | Line 36: | ||
== Older adults == | == Older adults == | ||
Older adults are the only high-risk group that was growing rapidly. In 2002 the United States had | Older adults are the only high-risk group that was growing rapidly. In 2002 the United States had 35.6 million people aged 65 or older, 12.3 percent of the population, and this share was projected to reach 20 percent by 2030.<ref name="Gamache-5-66-67">Gamache (2008), pp. 5-66–5-67.</ref> Fire death risk rises with age from about age 50. People aged 65 and older had about twice the risk of dying in a home fire, those aged 75 and older almost three times and those aged 85 and older almost four times.<ref name="Gamache-5-67" /> The group is not uniform. People aged 85 and older had an injury rate 57 percent above the national average, while the home fire injury risk of those aged 65 to 74 was below the all-ages average.<ref name="Gamache-5-67" /> | ||
The principal causes of fatal fires among older adults are largely those of other adults. Smoking materials are the leading cause of their fire deaths and heating equipment the second.<ref name="Gamache-5-67" /> People aged 65 or older had the highest death rate from cigarette fires, although they were only half as likely to smoke as younger adults. By the end of 2006, six US states had passed fire-safe cigarette laws.<ref name="Gamache-5-69">Gamache (2008), p. 5-69.</ref> Men were at higher risk than women in nearly all age groups, as in the worked example above.<ref name="Gamache-5-67" /> | The principal causes of fatal fires among older adults are largely those of other adults. Smoking materials are the leading cause of their fire deaths and heating equipment the second.<ref name="Gamache-5-67" /> People aged 65 or older had the highest death rate from cigarette fires, although they were only half as likely to smoke as younger adults. By the end of 2006, six US states had passed fire-safe cigarette laws.<ref name="Gamache-5-69">Gamache (2008), p. 5-69.</ref> Men were at higher risk than women in nearly all age groups, as in the worked example above.<ref name="Gamache-5-67" /> | ||
Detection is a particular problem. Typical residential [[ | Detection is a particular problem. Typical residential [[smoke alarm]] signals have a high frequency of 3,000 to 4,000 hertz, and many older adults have high-frequency hearing loss. A study for the NFPA Research Foundation found that a mixed-frequency temporal-three signal woke sleepers better than the usual high-frequency signal in every group tested.<ref name="Gamache-5-68">Gamache (2008), p. 5-68.</ref> People older than 75 woke particularly poorly to the high-frequency signal, at a median of 65 dBA compared with 40 dBA for the mixed signal. Interconnected alarms that include one in the bedroom are likely to give more than 85 dBA at the pillow.<ref name="Gamache-5-69" /> | ||
Programmes for older adults take account of how they learn. A 2005 CPSC literature review cited by Gamache recommends good lighting, little glare, high contrast and large type, and finds hands-on practice better than presenting facts.<ref name="Gamache-5-67-68">Gamache (2008), pp. 5-67–5-68.</ref> Kirtley (2008b) advises allowing plenty of time, limiting sessions to 30 minutes and using simple handouts.<ref name="Kirtley-5-9">Kirtley (2008b), p. 5-9.</ref> | Programmes for older adults take account of how they learn. A 2005 CPSC literature review cited by Gamache recommends good lighting, little glare, high contrast and large type, and finds hands-on practice better than presenting facts.<ref name="Gamache-5-67-68">Gamache (2008), pp. 5-67–5-68.</ref> Kirtley (2008b) advises allowing plenty of time, limiting sessions to 30 minutes and using simple handouts.<ref name="Kirtley-5-9">Kirtley (2008b), p. 5-9.</ref> | ||
| Line 48: | Line 50: | ||
A study of house fires in Dallas from 1991 to 1997 shows the size of the effect. In census tracts with a median income below $20,000, there were 9.93 injuries per 100,000 population per year. In tracts with a median income of at least $80,000 there were 1.23, a relative risk of 8.1.<ref name="Gamache-5-72" /> House fires per 1,000 houses were 7.19 and 2.96 per year, a relative risk of 2.4.<ref name="Gamache-5-72" /> | A study of house fires in Dallas from 1991 to 1997 shows the size of the effect. In census tracts with a median income below $20,000, there were 9.93 injuries per 100,000 population per year. In tracts with a median income of at least $80,000 there were 1.23, a relative risk of 8.1.<ref name="Gamache-5-72" /> House fires per 1,000 houses were 7.19 and 2.96 per year, a relative risk of 2.4.<ref name="Gamache-5-72" /> | ||
[[File:fse-high-risk-populations-v3.svg|thumb|upright=1.5|alt=Bar chart of house fire injuries per 100,000 population per year in Dallas falling from 9.93 in the poorest tracts to 1.23 in the richest|House fire injuries per 100,000 population per year by median income of the census tract, Dallas, 1991 to 1997.]] | |||
Gamache lists further factors linked to poverty: unsupervised children, a lack of utilities, window bars against crime, a lack of smoke alarms and older wiring. Single-parent households have less time to supervise children and to help them escape. In the rural South, heating whole homes with space heaters designed for smaller spaces adds a further risk.<ref name="Gamache-5-72" /> A Philadelphia study of 1993 to 2001 found that older housing, low income, vacant houses and an inability to speak English each had a significant effect on fire injury rates.<ref name="Gamache-5-72" /> | Gamache lists further factors linked to poverty: unsupervised children, a lack of utilities, window bars against crime, a lack of smoke alarms and older wiring. Single-parent households have less time to supervise children and to help them escape. In the rural South, heating whole homes with space heaters designed for smaller spaces adds a further risk.<ref name="Gamache-5-72" /> A Philadelphia study of 1993 to 2001 found that older housing, low income, vacant houses and an inability to speak English each had a significant effect on fire injury rates.<ref name="Gamache-5-72" /> | ||
| Line 58: | Line 61: | ||
According to the US Census Bureau, about 18 percent of Americans (51.2 million people) reported a disability in 2002, and 12 percent a severe one. People with disabilities are much more likely to live in poverty. About 230 civilian fire deaths per year were related to physical disability, two-thirds of them among people aged 65 and older.<ref name="Gamache-5-78">Gamache (2008), p. 5-78.</ref> A disability can make escape harder, and it can make an injured person more likely to die from the injuries.<ref name="Gamache-5-78" /> People who are deaf or hard of hearing often need smoke alarms with flashing lights, which cost 5 to 10 times more than other alarms.<ref name="Gamache-5-80">Gamache (2008), p. 5-80.</ref> | According to the US Census Bureau, about 18 percent of Americans (51.2 million people) reported a disability in 2002, and 12 percent a severe one. People with disabilities are much more likely to live in poverty. About 230 civilian fire deaths per year were related to physical disability, two-thirds of them among people aged 65 and older.<ref name="Gamache-5-78">Gamache (2008), p. 5-78.</ref> A disability can make escape harder, and it can make an injured person more likely to die from the injuries.<ref name="Gamache-5-78" /> People who are deaf or hard of hearing often need smoke alarms with flashing lights, which cost 5 to 10 times more than other alarms.<ref name="Gamache-5-80">Gamache (2008), p. 5-80.</ref> | ||
Physiology also matters. In the SFPE Handbook, Purser (2002) identifies the elderly and asthmatics as subpopulations more sensitive to toxic fire gases; the elderly are particularly susceptible to asphyxiant gases such as carbon monoxide.<ref name="Purser-2-90" /> For a [[ | Physiology also matters. In the SFPE Handbook, Purser (2002) identifies the elderly and asthmatics as subpopulations more sensitive to toxic fire gases; the elderly are particularly susceptible to asphyxiant gases such as carbon monoxide.<ref name="Purser-2-90" /> For a [[burn injury]], young adults have a 50 percent chance of surviving burns over half the body surface, while the elderly have a 50 percent chance at only 20 percent of the body surface.<ref name="Purser-2-128" /> Purser adds that fire casualties include a higher proportion of young children and the elderly than the general population, and that people impaired by disability or by alcohol or drugs are more at risk.<ref name="Purser-2-135">Purser (2002), p. 2-135.</ref> Hall and Cote (2008) note that elderly, handicapped or substance-impaired people may need help to escape. Patients in health care facilities and inmates of confinement facilities present the largest problem, because they are large groups that cannot evacuate on their own.<ref name="HC-3-21" /> | ||
Escape is the third problem, treated in more detail under [[Evacuation of people with disabilities]]. Bryan (2002) cites practice evacuations of Canadian high-rise offices in which about 3 percent of occupants could not use the stairs. Twenty-seven occupants with disabilities interviewed after the 1993 explosion and fire at the World Trade Center had needed 3.34 hours on average to evacuate.<ref name="Bryan-3-335-341">Bryan (2002), pp. 3-335, 3-341.</ref> After the 2001 attacks, about 6 percent of surviving occupants of the towers, roughly 1,000 people, reported a limitation that affected their evacuation. Recent injuries and chronic illness were the most frequent, and evacuation procedures did not account for all of these occupants.<ref name="Averill-168-169">Averill et al. (2005), pp. 168–169.</ref> | Escape is the third problem, treated in more detail under [[Evacuation of people with disabilities]]. Bryan (2002) cites practice evacuations of Canadian high-rise offices in which about 3 percent of occupants could not use the stairs. Twenty-seven occupants with disabilities interviewed after the 1993 explosion and fire at the World Trade Center had needed 3.34 hours on average to evacuate.<ref name="Bryan-3-335-341">Bryan (2002), pp. 3-335, 3-341.</ref> After the 2001 attacks, about 6 percent of surviving occupants of the towers, roughly 1,000 people, reported a limitation that affected their evacuation. Recent injuries and chronic illness were the most frequent, and evacuation procedures did not account for all of these occupants.<ref name="Averill-168-169">Averill et al. (2005), pp. 168–169.</ref> | ||
| Line 77: | Line 80: | ||
As an illustration, the corridor used in the Boyce, Shields and Silcock experiments was 50 m long.<ref name="Bryan-3-336">Bryan (2002), p. 3-336.</ref> At 1.25 m/s it takes 40 s; at 0.69 m/s, the speed given for a manual wheelchair, it takes about 73 s, and at 0.58 m/s about 87 s, more than twice as long.<ref name="VR-7.4" /> Such speeds apply only to people who can move unaided: in those experiments, 16 of 28 manual wheelchair users needed assistance to complete the corridor.<ref name="Bryan-3-336" /> | As an illustration, the corridor used in the Boyce, Shields and Silcock experiments was 50 m long.<ref name="Bryan-3-336">Bryan (2002), p. 3-336.</ref> At 1.25 m/s it takes 40 s; at 0.69 m/s, the speed given for a manual wheelchair, it takes about 73 s, and at 0.58 m/s about 87 s, more than twice as long.<ref name="VR-7.4" /> Such speeds apply only to people who can move unaided: in those experiments, 16 of 28 manual wheelchair users needed assistance to complete the corridor.<ref name="Bryan-3-336" /> | ||
[[File:fse-high-risk-populations-v4.svg|thumb|upright=1.5|alt=Bar chart of time to cover 50 m, from 40 s for healthy people to 87 s for people using a walking frame or rollator|Time to cover 50 m at the mean travel speed of different groups (illustration, t = d/v).]] | |||
In Australia, Data Sheet D1 of the Fire Safety Verification Method gives separate default design profiles for severe or profound mobility, vision, hearing, cognitive and speech limitations. It says designers must assess whether the defaults apply to a particular building; occupants with disabilities may approach 100 percent in hospitals and aged care.<ref name="ABCB-D1-260-261">Australian Building Codes Board (2020a), Data Sheet D1, pp. 260–261.</ref> In a study of young adults reported there, 36 percent of waking trials at a blood alcohol concentration of 0.05 produced no response before 95 dBA. The international and Australian standards require at least 75 dBA at the bed head.<ref name="ABCB-D1-262">Australian Building Codes Board (2020a), Data Sheet D1, p. 262.</ref> The same data sheets warn that smoke alarm efficacy derived from fire statistics does not describe the waking of any particular occupant type, because waking varies with age, alcohol and drugs.<ref name="ABCB-C3-90">Australian Building Codes Board (2020a), Data Sheet C3, p. 90.</ref> | In Australia, Data Sheet D1 of the Fire Safety Verification Method gives separate default design profiles for severe or profound mobility, vision, hearing, cognitive and speech limitations. It says designers must assess whether the defaults apply to a particular building; occupants with disabilities may approach 100 percent in hospitals and aged care.<ref name="ABCB-D1-260-261">Australian Building Codes Board (2020a), Data Sheet D1, pp. 260–261.</ref> In a study of young adults reported there, 36 percent of waking trials at a blood alcohol concentration of 0.05 produced no response before 95 dBA. The international and Australian standards require at least 75 dBA at the bed head.<ref name="ABCB-D1-262">Australian Building Codes Board (2020a), Data Sheet D1, p. 262.</ref> The same data sheets warn that smoke alarm efficacy derived from fire statistics does not describe the waking of any particular occupant type, because waking varies with age, alcohol and drugs.<ref name="ABCB-C3-90">Australian Building Codes Board (2020a), Data Sheet C3, p. 90.</ref> | ||
| Line 83: | Line 87: | ||
Hall and Cote (2008) explain why high-risk groups are hard to reach. The poor may not be able to afford safer products, and small rural communities are too scattered for targeted communication. Preschool children are harder to reach with school curricula, and elderly people may resist changes in products and practices. A programme with less than national coverage is therefore likely to miss a disproportionate number of those most in need.<ref name="HC-3-13-14" /> In their words, any successful programme "must go where the fires are".<ref name="HC-3-20">Hall and Cote (2008), p. 3-20.</ref> Gamache adds that mainstream programmes do not automatically trickle down to those at greatest risk, and that normal funding tends to target away from the disadvantaged.<ref name="Gamache-5-73" /><ref name="Gamache-5-83">Gamache (2008), p. 5-83.</ref> | Hall and Cote (2008) explain why high-risk groups are hard to reach. The poor may not be able to afford safer products, and small rural communities are too scattered for targeted communication. Preschool children are harder to reach with school curricula, and elderly people may resist changes in products and practices. A programme with less than national coverage is therefore likely to miss a disproportionate number of those most in need.<ref name="HC-3-13-14" /> In their words, any successful programme "must go where the fires are".<ref name="HC-3-20">Hall and Cote (2008), p. 3-20.</ref> Gamache adds that mainstream programmes do not automatically trickle down to those at greatest risk, and that normal funding tends to target away from the disadvantaged.<ref name="Gamache-5-73" /><ref name="Gamache-5-83">Gamache (2008), p. 5-83.</ref> | ||
Several approaches recur in the handbook. A community-based model uses fire data to target the neighbourhoods with the most fires, market research to learn how residents receive information, and the active involvement of residents.<ref name="Gamache-5-74">Gamache (2008), p. 5-74.</ref> Programmes also work through others: caregivers of children, home support workers who visit older people, and organisations of people with disabilities.<ref name="Gamache-5-64" /><ref name="Gamache-5-70" /><ref name="Gamache-5-80" /> Materials for [[ | Several approaches recur in the handbook. A community-based model uses fire data to target the neighbourhoods with the most fires, market research to learn how residents receive information, and the active involvement of residents.<ref name="Gamache-5-74">Gamache (2008), p. 5-74.</ref> Programmes also work through others: caregivers of children, home support workers who visit older people, and organisations of people with disabilities.<ref name="Gamache-5-64" /><ref name="Gamache-5-70" /><ref name="Gamache-5-80" /> Materials for [[fire and life safety education]] are made accessible in Braille, audio or captioned form, use simple language and pictures, and are reviewed by experts in a variety of disabilities.<ref name="Gamache-5-79">Gamache (2008), p. 5-79.</ref> | ||
Outside North America, the Melbourne Fire Brigade in Australia worked with an adult migrant education service on a fire safety programme integrated into English-language courses.<ref name="Gamache-5-83" /> Smoke alarm programmes are central. From 1998 to 2005, programmes funded by the CDC in 18 states canvassed more than 382,000 homes and installed 275,000 smoke alarms in 157,000 high-risk homes.<ref name="Gamache-5-82">Gamache (2008), p. 5-82.</ref> | Outside North America, the Melbourne Fire Brigade in Australia worked with an adult migrant education service on a fire safety programme integrated into English-language courses.<ref name="Gamache-5-83" /> Smoke alarm programmes are central. From 1998 to 2005, programmes funded by the CDC in 18 states canvassed more than 382,000 homes and installed 275,000 smoke alarms in 157,000 high-risk homes.<ref name="Gamache-5-82">Gamache (2008), p. 5-82.</ref> | ||
Latest revision as of 00:44, 16 November 2026
High-risk populations are groups of people whose rate of death or injury from fire is well above that of the population as a whole. In the NFPA Fire Protection Handbook (2008), Gamache names preschool children, older adults and people disadvantaged by low income or little education as the groups at highest risk of fire death in the United States.[1] The same chapter also treats First Nations communities and people with disabilities as groups needing special outreach.[2] The statistics in this article describe the United States around 1999 to 2004 unless another country or year is given.
Around that time, children under 5 were 74 percent more likely than the average person to die in a home fire, and adults aged 65 and older about twice as likely. The youngest and oldest groups together accounted for 53 percent of US home fire deaths in 2002, against 38.9 percent in 1980.[1] Their higher risk has several roots: dependence on others, reduced ability to notice a fire or to escape, greater physical vulnerability to smoke and burns, and living conditions linked to poverty.[3][4][5][6] The highest-risk groups also tend to be the hardest to reach with fire prevention programmes. Programmes therefore need to reach these groups deliberately.[7]
Identifying high-risk groups
A group is called high-risk when its rate of fire deaths or injuries, relative to its size, is clearly higher than the average. Such rates come from fire statistics; Gamache (2008) mostly expresses the fire death rate in deaths per million population per year.[8] Hall and Weller (2008) list national, state and local data as the means to identify high-risk populations such as toddlers, elders, people with disabilities and people affected by poverty.[9] Hall and Twomey (2008) observe that the very young and older adults are the two high-risk age groups for fire deaths. Older adults are at higher risk for almost every form of fatal injury in the built environment.[10][11]
The comparison is usually expressed as a relative risk. It divides the rate for the group by the rate for a reference group, such as the whole population or another group. A value above 1 means that the group is at higher risk than the reference group. Gamache (2008) uses this measure for Dallas census tracts, with the highest-income tracts as the reference.[6]
| Symbol | Description | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| Relative risk of the group | dimensionless | |
| Fire death (or injury) rate of the group | deaths per million population per year | |
| Rate of the reference group | deaths per million population per year |
As a worked example, the US fire death rate for males in 1999 to 2002 was 12.1 deaths per million population, and that for females 8.8. The relative risk of males is therefore 12.1/8.8 = 1.38, which Gamache reports as 38 percent higher. At age 85 and over, the rates were 58.5 for men and 27.8 for women, a relative risk of about 2.1.[8] A relative risk of 2 means twice the reference risk. The statement that adults aged 65 and older are twice as likely to die in a fire thus corresponds to a relative risk of about 2.[1]
Relative risks depend on the place and the period. Hall (2008) notes that young children in Japan were not a distinctively high-risk group, while in the United States preschool children had more than double the risk of everyone else. For older adults, the gap with the rest of the population was much wider in Japan than in the United States.[12] US civilian fire deaths fell from 7,395 in 1977 to 3,900 in 2004, yet the same groups continued to have disproportionate death rates.[1] Place matters too: from 1997 to 2001, US communities with fewer than 2,500 inhabitants had 30.9 fire deaths per million population, at least twice the rate of most larger community sizes.[13]
Young children
Children aged 5 and younger had a fire death rate nearly twice the national average in 1999 to 2002. Until 1995, about 700 children in this age group died in home fires each year in the United States; by 2002 the toll had dropped to just under 270.[1] Preschool children are less able than older children to control their environment, depend more on adults, and are less likely to receive or understand fire safety information.[1] In a fire, small children need help to escape and, on their own, are likely to think that hiding makes them safe.[3]
Children playing with fire, usually with matches or lighters, are the leading cause of fire deaths of preschool children. This cause accounted for 36 percent of home fire deaths of children aged 4 or younger in 1994 to 1998, and for 26 percent in 1999 to 2002. Part of the decline was real and part reflected changes in incident coding.[1] NFPA's best estimate for 2002 was 13,900 structure fires started by children playing with fire, with 210 civilian deaths and 1,250 injuries. Preschool children made up 55 percent of the deaths in child-playing home fires, and they were often younger siblings or playmates of the firesetters rather than the firesetters themselves.[14]
Engineering has been aimed directly at this hazard. In 1994 the US Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) required all disposable and some novelty cigarette lighters to be child resistant. Under the rule, 85 percent of children aged 2½ to 4½ years in tests must be unable to operate them. Canada followed in 1995. For 1998, CPSC estimated 70 deaths and 480 injuries in residential fires started by children under 5 playing with lighters, against 200 deaths and 1,430 injuries without the standard.[15] A significant number of fatal fires involving young children are started with matches, however, and some children can still operate child-resistant lighters.[15][16]
Because preschool children rely on adults, programmes reach them largely through parents and caregivers, who control matches, lighters, candles and smoke alarms in the home.[15] Young children learn by seeing and doing rather than by listening. Their limited vocabulary and their difficulty with "if, then" choices restrict which safety messages can be taught.[17] The NFPA preschool programme follows the rule "Don't scare children. Teach them what to do."[15] In Portland, Oregon, the share of children referred to the juvenile firesetting intervention programme for low knowledge fell from 6.2 percent to 1.8 percent by fiscal year 1996–1997.[16] Deaths in child-set fires fell from about two a year to one every six years.[16]
Older adults
Older adults are the only high-risk group that was growing rapidly. In 2002 the United States had 35.6 million people aged 65 or older, 12.3 percent of the population, and this share was projected to reach 20 percent by 2030.[18] Fire death risk rises with age from about age 50. People aged 65 and older had about twice the risk of dying in a home fire, those aged 75 and older almost three times and those aged 85 and older almost four times.[8] The group is not uniform. People aged 85 and older had an injury rate 57 percent above the national average, while the home fire injury risk of those aged 65 to 74 was below the all-ages average.[8]
The principal causes of fatal fires among older adults are largely those of other adults. Smoking materials are the leading cause of their fire deaths and heating equipment the second.[8] People aged 65 or older had the highest death rate from cigarette fires, although they were only half as likely to smoke as younger adults. By the end of 2006, six US states had passed fire-safe cigarette laws.[19] Men were at higher risk than women in nearly all age groups, as in the worked example above.[8]
Detection is a particular problem. Typical residential smoke alarm signals have a high frequency of 3,000 to 4,000 hertz, and many older adults have high-frequency hearing loss. A study for the NFPA Research Foundation found that a mixed-frequency temporal-three signal woke sleepers better than the usual high-frequency signal in every group tested.[20] People older than 75 woke particularly poorly to the high-frequency signal, at a median of 65 dBA compared with 40 dBA for the mixed signal. Interconnected alarms that include one in the bedroom are likely to give more than 85 dBA at the pillow.[19]
Programmes for older adults take account of how they learn. A 2005 CPSC literature review cited by Gamache recommends good lighting, little glare, high contrast and large type, and finds hands-on practice better than presenting facts.[21] Kirtley (2008b) advises allowing plenty of time, limiting sessions to 30 minutes and using simple handouts.[22]
The NFPA and CDC programme Remembering When combines fire and fall prevention through group presentations, home visits and smoke alarm installation. Between 2000 and 2003 it reached nearly 500,000 older adults in five states.[23] In a Virginia evaluation, fire knowledge rose by 11.3 percent at the treatment site against 4.4 percent at the control site.[23] In Gamache's 2008 account of Ontario, municipalities were required under the Fire Protection Act to deliver public fire safety education based on local needs and circumstances. The Older and Wiser programme worked with home support workers, whom fire service personnel in some communities trained to carry out basic fire safety checks.[24]
Low-income and other disadvantaged communities
Statistical studies over at least a quarter of a century have shown that the risk of fire and fire death is higher in low-income populations. Lack of income and lack of education are the two conditions most consistently linked to high risk. When their effects are removed, neither race nor the age of housing appears to be a good predictor of high risk.[25] Fire risk is high both in large cities and in small rural communities, the two community sizes with the highest shares of people in poverty.[25]
A study of house fires in Dallas from 1991 to 1997 shows the size of the effect. In census tracts with a median income below $20,000, there were 9.93 injuries per 100,000 population per year. In tracts with a median income of at least $80,000 there were 1.23, a relative risk of 8.1.[6] House fires per 1,000 houses were 7.19 and 2.96 per year, a relative risk of 2.4.[6]
Gamache lists further factors linked to poverty: unsupervised children, a lack of utilities, window bars against crime, a lack of smoke alarms and older wiring. Single-parent households have less time to supervise children and to help them escape. In the rural South, heating whole homes with space heaters designed for smaller spaces adds a further risk.[6] A Philadelphia study of 1993 to 2001 found that older housing, low income, vacant houses and an inability to speak English each had a significant effect on fire injury rates.[6]
Smoke alarms show how a protective measure can miss the people who need it. Homes with smoke alarms have a death rate about 40 to 50 percent lower than homes without. Although a 2004 telephone survey found alarms in 96 percent of US homes, four in ten reported home fires occurred in the small share of homes without them.[26] Homes without smoke alarms also accounted for 55 percent of home fire deaths in 1999 to 2002.[13] Before new alarms were installed in a 2005 NFPA programme, alarms were present in only 33 percent of the target homes in the Navajo Nation, 43 percent in Mississippi and 63 percent in Alabama.[26] Even one battery-powered alarm may be beyond a poor family's budget.[6]
Language and culture add further barriers. In 2000 the United States had 28.4 million foreign-born residents, 10.4 percent of the population.[27] In Sioux Falls, South Dakota, seven of twelve fire deaths in ten years were immigrants, and the fire department translated its home fire safety guide into 15 languages.[26] Fire death rates among Native Americans and Alaska Natives were 2.1 times those of whites in 1997 to 1998. In Canada, the 2003 fire death rate in First Nations communities was 3.0 per 100,000 population, 2.4 times the Canadian national average for 1999.[28]
People with disabilities and other impairments
According to the US Census Bureau, about 18 percent of Americans (51.2 million people) reported a disability in 2002, and 12 percent a severe one. People with disabilities are much more likely to live in poverty. About 230 civilian fire deaths per year were related to physical disability, two-thirds of them among people aged 65 and older.[29] A disability can make escape harder, and it can make an injured person more likely to die from the injuries.[29] People who are deaf or hard of hearing often need smoke alarms with flashing lights, which cost 5 to 10 times more than other alarms.[30]
Physiology also matters. In the SFPE Handbook, Purser (2002) identifies the elderly and asthmatics as subpopulations more sensitive to toxic fire gases; the elderly are particularly susceptible to asphyxiant gases such as carbon monoxide.[4] For a burn injury, young adults have a 50 percent chance of surviving burns over half the body surface, while the elderly have a 50 percent chance at only 20 percent of the body surface.[5] Purser adds that fire casualties include a higher proportion of young children and the elderly than the general population, and that people impaired by disability or by alcohol or drugs are more at risk.[31] Hall and Cote (2008) note that elderly, handicapped or substance-impaired people may need help to escape. Patients in health care facilities and inmates of confinement facilities present the largest problem, because they are large groups that cannot evacuate on their own.[3]
Escape is the third problem, treated in more detail under Evacuation of people with disabilities. Bryan (2002) cites practice evacuations of Canadian high-rise offices in which about 3 percent of occupants could not use the stairs. Twenty-seven occupants with disabilities interviewed after the 1993 explosion and fire at the World Trade Center had needed 3.34 hours on average to evacuate.[32] After the 2001 attacks, about 6 percent of surviving occupants of the towers, roughly 1,000 people, reported a limitation that affected their evacuation. Recent injuries and chronic illness were the most frequent, and evacuation procedures did not account for all of these occupants.[33]
Engineers allow for such occupants through travel speeds and occupant profiles. Introduction to Fire Safety Engineering gives mean travel speeds, taken from the SFPE Handbook, of 1.25 m/s for healthy unhindered people and 0.58 m/s for people with a walking frame or rollator.[34] The travel time follows from
| Symbol | Description | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| Travel time | s | |
| Travel distance | m | |
| Mean travel speed | m/s |
As an illustration, the corridor used in the Boyce, Shields and Silcock experiments was 50 m long.[35] At 1.25 m/s it takes 40 s; at 0.69 m/s, the speed given for a manual wheelchair, it takes about 73 s, and at 0.58 m/s about 87 s, more than twice as long.[34] Such speeds apply only to people who can move unaided: in those experiments, 16 of 28 manual wheelchair users needed assistance to complete the corridor.[35]
In Australia, Data Sheet D1 of the Fire Safety Verification Method gives separate default design profiles for severe or profound mobility, vision, hearing, cognitive and speech limitations. It says designers must assess whether the defaults apply to a particular building; occupants with disabilities may approach 100 percent in hospitals and aged care.[36] In a study of young adults reported there, 36 percent of waking trials at a blood alcohol concentration of 0.05 produced no response before 95 dBA. The international and Australian standards require at least 75 dBA at the bed head.[37] The same data sheets warn that smoke alarm efficacy derived from fire statistics does not describe the waking of any particular occupant type, because waking varies with age, alcohol and drugs.[38]
Reaching high-risk groups
Hall and Cote (2008) explain why high-risk groups are hard to reach. The poor may not be able to afford safer products, and small rural communities are too scattered for targeted communication. Preschool children are harder to reach with school curricula, and elderly people may resist changes in products and practices. A programme with less than national coverage is therefore likely to miss a disproportionate number of those most in need.[7] In their words, any successful programme "must go where the fires are".[39] Gamache adds that mainstream programmes do not automatically trickle down to those at greatest risk, and that normal funding tends to target away from the disadvantaged.[26][40]
Several approaches recur in the handbook. A community-based model uses fire data to target the neighbourhoods with the most fires, market research to learn how residents receive information, and the active involvement of residents.[41] Programmes also work through others: caregivers of children, home support workers who visit older people, and organisations of people with disabilities.[15][23][30] Materials for fire and life safety education are made accessible in Braille, audio or captioned form, use simple language and pictures, and are reviewed by experts in a variety of disabilities.[42]
Outside North America, the Melbourne Fire Brigade in Australia worked with an adult migrant education service on a fire safety programme integrated into English-language courses.[40] Smoke alarm programmes are central. From 1998 to 2005, programmes funded by the CDC in 18 states canvassed more than 382,000 homes and installed 275,000 smoke alarms in 157,000 high-risk homes.[43]
Engineering and legislation complement education, but they also need it. Gamache notes that even a strategy based on an engineering change, such as child-resistant lighters, needs an educational counterpart for maximum advantage.[16] Actions taken for other reasons can also create new high-risk groups. Security bars on windows and doors, installed against intruders, have trapped families in fires. Several cities formed coalitions to fit such bars with emergency-release devices, and a Fort Lauderdale programme combined public education, financial assistance and enforcement.[44] Gamache also calls for more evaluation, warning that too many programmes were in use based only on the reasonableness of their design and favourable but unquantified impressions.[16]
See also
- Child-resistant lighter
- Children's sleepwear flammability
- Community risk reduction
- Juvenile firesetting
- Learn Not to Burn
- Risk Watch
Notes
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 Gamache (2008), p. 5-63.
- ↑ Gamache (2008), pp. 5-76–5-78.
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 Hall and Cote (2008), p. 3-21.
- ↑ 4.0 4.1 Purser (2002), p. 2-90.
- ↑ 5.0 5.1 Purser (2002), p. 2-128.
- ↑ 6.0 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 6.6 Gamache (2008), p. 5-72.
- ↑ 7.0 7.1 Hall and Cote (2008), pp. 3-13–3-14.
- ↑ 8.0 8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4 8.5 Gamache (2008), p. 5-67.
- ↑ Hall and Weller (2008), p. 5-136.
- ↑ Hall and Twomey (2008), p. 1-4.
- ↑ Hall and Twomey (2008), p. 1-8.
- ↑ Hall (2008), p. 5-106.
- ↑ 13.0 13.1 Ahrens et al. (2008), p. 3-64.
- ↑ Gamache (2008), pp. 5-63–5-64.
- ↑ 15.0 15.1 15.2 15.3 15.4 Gamache (2008), p. 5-64.
- ↑ 16.0 16.1 16.2 16.3 16.4 Gamache (2008), p. 5-66.
- ↑ Kirtley (2008b), pp. 5-6–5-7.
- ↑ Gamache (2008), pp. 5-66–5-67.
- ↑ 19.0 19.1 Gamache (2008), p. 5-69.
- ↑ Gamache (2008), p. 5-68.
- ↑ Gamache (2008), pp. 5-67–5-68.
- ↑ Kirtley (2008b), p. 5-9.
- ↑ 23.0 23.1 23.2 Gamache (2008), p. 5-70.
- ↑ Gamache (2008), pp. 5-69–5-70.
- ↑ 25.0 25.1 Gamache (2008), p. 5-71.
- ↑ 26.0 26.1 26.2 26.3 Gamache (2008), p. 5-73.
- ↑ Gamache (2008), pp. 5-72–5-73.
- ↑ Gamache (2008), p. 5-76.
- ↑ 29.0 29.1 Gamache (2008), p. 5-78.
- ↑ 30.0 30.1 Gamache (2008), p. 5-80.
- ↑ Purser (2002), p. 2-135.
- ↑ Bryan (2002), pp. 3-335, 3-341.
- ↑ Averill et al. (2005), pp. 168–169.
- ↑ 34.0 34.1 Van Rossum (2027), §7.4.
- ↑ 35.0 35.1 Bryan (2002), p. 3-336.
- ↑ Australian Building Codes Board (2020a), Data Sheet D1, pp. 260–261.
- ↑ Australian Building Codes Board (2020a), Data Sheet D1, p. 262.
- ↑ Australian Building Codes Board (2020a), Data Sheet C3, p. 90.
- ↑ Hall and Cote (2008), p. 3-20.
- ↑ 40.0 40.1 Gamache (2008), p. 5-83.
- ↑ Gamache (2008), p. 5-74.
- ↑ Gamache (2008), p. 5-79.
- ↑ Gamache (2008), p. 5-82.
- ↑ Gamache (2008), p. 5-81.
References
- Ahrens, M., Frazier, P., & Kelch, G. (2008). Use of fire incident data and statistics. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall, Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 3-61–3-92). National Fire Protection Association.
- Australian Building Codes Board. (2020a). Data sheets: Fire Safety Verification Method (Handbook annex, Print version 1.1).
- Averill, J. D., Mileti, D. S., Peacock, R. D., Kuligowski, E. D., Groner, N., Proulx, G., Reneke, P. A., & Nelson, H. E. (2005). Occupant behavior, egress, and emergency communications (NIST NCSTAR 1-7). National Institute of Standards and Technology.
- Bryan, J. L. (2002). Behavioral response to fire and smoke. In P. J. DiNenno, D. Drysdale, C. L. Beyler, W. D. Walton, R. L. P. Custer, J. R. Hall Jr., & J. M. Watts Jr. (Eds.), SFPE handbook of fire protection engineering (3rd ed., pp. 3-315–3-341). National Fire Protection Association; Society of Fire Protection Engineers.
- Gamache, S. (2008). Reaching high-risk groups. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall, Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 5-63–5-85). National Fire Protection Association.
- Hall, J. R., Jr. (2008). Using data for public education planning and decision making. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall, Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 5-103–5-118). National Fire Protection Association.
- Hall, J. R., Jr., & Cote, A. E. (2008). An overview of the fire problem and fire protection. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall, Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 3-3–3-30). National Fire Protection Association.
- Hall, J. R., Jr., & Twomey, E. R. (2008). Challenges to safety in the built environment. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall, Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 1-3–1-29). National Fire Protection Association.
- Hall, J. R., Jr., & Weller, M. W. (2008). Evaluation techniques for fire and life safety education. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall, Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 5-119–5-137). National Fire Protection Association.
- Kirtley, E. (2008b). Principles and techniques of fire and life safety education. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall, Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 5-3–5-20). National Fire Protection Association.
- Purser, D. A. (2002). Toxicity assessment of combustion products. In P. J. DiNenno, D. Drysdale, C. L. Beyler, W. D. Walton, R. L. P. Custer, J. R. Hall Jr., & J. M. Watts Jr. (Eds.), SFPE handbook of fire protection engineering (3rd ed., pp. 2-83–2-171). National Fire Protection Association; Society of Fire Protection Engineers.
- Van Rossum, E. (2027). Introduction to Fire Safety Engineering. Fire Safety Academy.