Contents
An alternative fuel vehicle (AFV) is a road vehicle that runs wholly or partly on a fuel other than conventional gasoline or diesel. United States clean-air and energy laws of the 1990s count alcohols, natural gas, propane, hydrogen and electricity among these fuels, while a Dutch guidance document uses the term mainly for electric vehicles.[1][2] In fire protection the vehicles of most concern carry a flammable gas on board, stored at high pressure or at very low temperature.[1]
These gaseous fuels behave differently from gasoline when they escape. Natural gas and hydrogen rise and disperse, propane and cold natural gas vapour spread along the ground, and an ignited leak from a pressurised cylinder can burn as a long flame jet.[3][4][5] Their fuel systems therefore rely on pressure relief devices, shutoff valves and tested containers, covered in the United States by NFPA 52 and NFPA 58.[6] An estimated 511,000 alternative fuel vehicles were in use in the United States in 2003, more than a third of them running on liquefied petroleum gas.[7] Fire fighters recognise them by a blue diamond-shaped label at the rear. Water spray suits natural gas and propane fires, but it speeds up the evaporation of a spilled pool of liquefied natural gas.[8]
Definitions and vehicle types
The term follows the fuel lists written into legislation. In the United States, the Clean Air Act Amendments (CAAA) of 1990 list methanol, ethanol and other alcohols, reformulated gasoline, reformulated diesel for trucks, natural gas, propane, hydrogen and electricity.[1] The Energy Policy Act (EPACT) of 1992 drops the reformulated fuels but adds fuels from biomass, liquid fuels from coal and blends with at least 85 % alcohol by volume.[1] In 2013 the European Commission named electricity, hydrogen, biofuels, natural gas and liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) as the main alternative fuels for long-term oil substitution.[9] A Dutch guidance document on indoor car parks defines alternative fuel vehicles as vehicles that run entirely or partly on non-fossil fuels, in particular electric vehicles.[2]
The chapter on these vehicles in the 20th edition of the NFPA Fire Protection Handbook (2008) limits itself to three gaseous fuels. These are Compressed natural gas (CNG), Liquefied natural gas (LNG) and Liquefied petroleum gas (LP-gas), which in vehicle use means propane.[1] The hazards of liquid alternative fuels such as alcohols were considered better known and generally accepted. Hydrogen was then the least used gaseous fuel, and most hydrogen vehicles are powered by fuel cells.[1][10] Bi-fuel conversions keep their original liquid fuel system and can run on either fuel, while dedicated vehicles run only on CNG, LNG or LP-gas.[11] Both kinds look like conventional vehicles, and their fuel components are hidden, so fire fighters usually cannot tell them apart from gasoline or diesel vehicles.[11][10]
In the United States, the number of alternative fuel vehicles grew by an average of 6.9 % per year between 1992 and 2000, reaching 0.2 % of all registered motor vehicles.[1] Federal estimates for 2003, partly based on projections, give 510,805 vehicles excluding gasoline-electric hybrids. Of these, 190,438 ran on LP-gas, 132,988 on CNG, 3,030 on LNG, 133,776 on 85 % ethanol and 45,656 on electricity.[7] Propane thus accounted for about 37 % of the fleet and the three gaseous fuels for about 64 %. The country had more than 5,000 refuelling sites for alternative fuels in 2006, including 2,771 for LP-gas, 754 for CNG and 37 for LNG.[6] In the Netherlands, about 218,000 electric vehicles were registered at the end of 2019, about 2.5 % of 8.8 million passenger cars.[2]
Fuel properties and fire hazards
Whether the hazard of a gaseous fuel becomes real depends on its properties, on time-dependent conditions and on the design, manufacture and installation of the fuel system.[3] CNG and LNG share the same Flammability limits and Autoignition temperature, because these properties of natural gas do not change between the compressed and the liquefied state.[4] LP-gas becomes flammable at lower concentrations than natural gas but has a narrower range.[4]
| Fuel | Flammability limits in air (% by volume) | Autoignition temperature (°C) | Boiling point (°C) | Released gas compared with air[3][4][5] |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gasoline | 1.4–7.6 | 257 | 27–225 | not given in the source |
| Propane (LP-gas) | 2.2–9.5 | 454–510 | −42 | heavier, about 1.5 times |
| Natural gas (CNG, LNG) | 5.3–15 | 540 | −162 | lighter (methane 0.6); cold LNG vapour heavier |
| Hydrogen | 4.1–74 | 566–582 | −253 | much lighter, 0.07 |
Released outdoors, CNG rises rapidly and disperses, so CNG vehicles offer a high degree of safety in the open. A release from a relief valve or a broken fuel line is also short, because the gas discharges at high pressure.[4] Indoors the picture changes. Methane, with a vapour density of 0.6, rises and pools under a ceiling, where light fixtures and air-handling equipment can ignite it.[4]
LNG is natural gas liquefied by cryogenic refrigeration and stored at about −162 °C (−260 °F).[3] Below about −118 °C the vapour is denser than air, so a spill first forms a white cloud that sinks to the ground until it warms and becomes buoyant.[4] LNG vapour is colourless and odourless, and only gas detectors designed for methane can set safe exclusion zones.[5] As a cryogenic liquid, LNG also causes frostbite or burns on contact with skin.[6]
LP-gas is stored as a liquid under its own vapour pressure at ambient temperature.[5] Its vapour is about 1.5 times as heavy as air, so released propane sinks and follows the contours of the ground. Under the right conditions the cloud travels downwind at flammable concentrations until it reaches an ignition source.[5][13] Since most alternative fuel vehicles on United States roads used LP-gas, fire fighters were expected to meet this fuel more often than the others.[5]
Hydrogen has a density of only 0.07 relative to air and a flammable range of about 4 % to 75 % by volume, so it ignites easily but disperses rapidly.[3] Because of its low density it is stored at much higher pressures than CNG, or as a liquid at −253 °C, which can condense oxygen out of the air when released.[3][5] A hydrogen flame is often invisible in daylight and gives off little thermal radiation, so people can walk into it unaware.[14] A further point of hydrogen safety is that escaping hydrogen gas seldom leaves a situation without fire, because it either ignites promptly or rises rapidly.[14]
All the gaseous fuels can cause asphyxiation when released into a confined space.[6] Pipeline natural gas is odorised so that a leak can be smelled at 20 % to 25 % of its lower flammable limit, and LP-gas below one-fifth of that limit. LNG has no odour, and hydrogen is normally not odorised because odorants would contaminate fuel cell catalysts.[6]
Release and fire scenarios
The handbook names three plausible situations for a release: the vehicle is being fuelled, it is involved in a crash, or it is under repair.[10] What happens next depends mainly on when the gas ignites. An event tree in the SFPE Handbook shows that immediate ignition of a release from a small opening gives a jet flame, while immediate ignition of a major spill usually gives a Fireball.[15] If ignition is delayed, the fuel disperses and accumulates and may then burn as a vapour cloud fire or a pool fire.[16]
When CNG vents from a Pressure relief device or a broken pipe, it forms a gas jet that blows out in the direction the opening faces and keeps entraining air.[4] Ignited, it becomes a Jet fire of considerable length that radiates heat to the vehicle and to people nearby.[4] Depending on the size of the leak and the gas pressure, such a flame can be 3 m to 9 m (10 ft to 30 ft) long.[17] A jet striking adjacent containers can make their relief devices operate as well, which increases the heat flux. Compressed methane releases are short, however, and the fire usually involves only the combustible materials of the vehicle itself.[4]
In Austin, Texas, in March 1993, a mechanic depressurised a CNG cylinder without electrically bonding the depressurising tool to the vehicle frame.[18] The high-pressure discharge built up static electricity, and a spark ignited a flame jet about 4.6 m (15 ft) long. Nobody was injured, but the vehicle was destroyed and a neighbouring vehicle was damaged by the heat.[18]
LP-gas can escape as vapour, when a container or fitting is damaged above the liquid level, or as liquid from below it. A liquid release produces far more vapour, because large amounts of liquid flash into vapour mixed with fine droplets.[5][13] If the plume reaches an ignition source within its flammable range, the flame can flash back to the source, and a fast flame front can produce a Vapour cloud explosion.[5] The most severe event for a liquefied fuel is a BLEVE (boiling liquid expanding vapour explosion), a major container failure into two or more pieces while the liquid is well above its normal boiling point.[5] Even a correctly working spring-loaded relief valve cannot prevent a BLEVE in a fire, because it never lowers the pressure to atmospheric.[19] Insulation helps LNG containers: in fire tests the relief valves of an uninsulated cryogenic vessel opened within 1 hour, but with insulation and vacuum intact not for several days.[5]
In a study of a partly open public parking garage, a fuel pipe leak was the most credible event and the operation of a container relief valve the worst case.[4] With the mechanical exhaust that garages need for carbon monoxide, the leak gave no flammable concentrations beyond its immediate vicinity, and the relief valve only a brief flammable puff. The study concluded that the risk of a CNG vehicle is equal to or less than that of a gasoline vehicle. A study of a hypothetical van with a failed fuel line in a tunnel found that a CNG van would produce a smaller and shorter-lived flammable region than a gasoline van.[4]
Estimating the flammable volume of a release
A simple dilution estimate shows why liquefied fuels are restricted indoors. For flammable liquids, Slye (2008) explains that a vapour-air mixture is too lean to ignite when it holds more than (100 − LFL) volumes of air per LFL volumes of vapour. Here LFL is the lower flammable limit in per cent by volume.[20] For acetone, with a lower limit of 2.6 %, this gives about 37 volumes of air for each volume of vapour.[20]
The same reasoning applies to a liquefied gas once its vapour volume is known. Each litre of liquid commercial propane yields 0.271 m³ of vapour at 15.5 °C, and its lower flammable limit is 2.15 %.[21] The vapour volume is the liquid volume multiplied by the vapour yield per litre. The minimum volume of air that keeps this vapour below the lower flammable limit then follows from the ratio of air to vapour at that limit.[20]
| Symbol | Description | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| Volume of liquid fuel released | L | |
| Volume of vapour produced per litre of liquid | m³/L | |
| Volume of fuel vapour | m³ | |
| Lower flammable limit of the fuel in air | % by volume | |
| Minimum volume of air needed to dilute the vapour below the lower flammable limit | m³ |
The estimate assumes that vapour and air mix completely and uniformly. In practice, Slye (2008) notes, a substantial excess of ventilation air is applied because the atmosphere in an enclosure is never uniform.[22] The result is therefore a lower bound on the air needed, not a safe ventilation rate. Propane vapour in particular sinks and follows surface contours, so it does not spread evenly through a space.[5]
As a worked example, NFPA 58 as summarised in the handbook limits the containers of a passenger vehicle to about 0.6 m³ (160 gal) of LP-gas in total.[23] If all 600 L were released as liquid, they would produce 600 × 0.271 = 163 m³ of vapour. At an LFL of 2.15 %, the air needed to dilute this below the limit is 163 × 97.85 / 2.15, or at least 7,400 m³.[21] Even 1 L of liquid gives 0.27 m³ of vapour, which needs more than 12 m³ of air. Natural gas, with an LFL of 5.3 %, needs nearly 18 volumes of air per volume of gas, and hydrogen, with 4.1 %, more than 23.[12] These numbers fit the handbook's advice that LP-gas vehicle fuelling should take place outdoors.[13]
Vehicle fuel systems and safety devices
CNG vehicles, from passenger cars to transit buses, store natural gas at 17.2 MPa to 27.6 MPa (2,500 psig to 4,000 psig).[11] Under the ANSI/AGA NGV2 standard, CNG containers have service pressures of 16.5 MPa to 30.0 MPa at 21 °C and a service life of 15 years. To be certified, they must pass drop, fire exposure, gunfire, gas permeation, pressure cycling and burst tests.[11] They may not be placed ahead of the front axle, and unshielded containers need at least 203 mm (8 in.) of clearance from the exhaust system.[11] In the United States, Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards 303 and 304 address CNG fuel system and container integrity, to reduce deaths and injuries from fires after fuel leakage in crashes.[24]
Pressure relief devices protect the container from catastrophic failure due to overpressure from fire exposure.[11] On CNG cylinders they can be rupture disks, which burst at a set pressure and vent the entire contents. Fusible plugs melt at a nominal 74 °C or 100 °C and do not reclose either.[18] Pressure relief valves, by contrast, reclose once the pressure has fallen. The fuel system also has three valves: one at the container, a labelled manual shutoff valve, and an automatic valve that stops the gas when the ignition is on but the engine is not running.[18]
LNG fuels medium-sized and heavy vehicles such as refuse trucks and transit vehicles, and also railway locomotives and ships.[25] Its vehicle containers commonly use a vacuum-insulated, double-walled design of the Dewar type. An important design value is the hold time, the period a vehicle can stand unused before the tank pressure rises to the venting point.[25] Most containers have a relief valve and a rupture disk that bursts at a higher pressure; if the disk of an overturned tank operates, liquid LNG discharges.[25] Where a container is installed inside the vehicle and the LNG is not odorised, a continuous methane Gas detection system must alarm at 20 % of the lower flammable limit.[25]
LP-gas vehicles store propane at about 0.83 MPa to 1.38 MPa (120 psig to 200 psig).[23] Containers on motor vehicles need a minimum design pressure of 2.15 MPa (312.5 psig) instead of 1.72 MPa (250 psig) for stationary vessels. The higher relief setting makes premature releases less likely at the higher temperatures that vehicle containers can reach.[23] Containers made after 1 January 1984 must have an overfill prevention device, and fusible plug relief devices are prohibited. The relief valve must be at the uppermost point of the vapour space, because valves at or just above the 80 % liquid level sometimes discharged liquid.[10]
Standards and regulation
As summarised in the 2008 handbook, NFPA 52, Vehicular Fuel Systems Code (2006 edition), covers CNG, LNG and hydrogen vehicle fuel systems in the United States. The former LNG vehicle standard, NFPA 57, was incorporated into it in 2005.[6] NFPA 58, Liquefied Petroleum Gas Code, covers LP-gas fuel systems on vehicles; it had been adopted by 47 states and by the Department of Transportation for interstate vehicles.[26] Under NFPA 30A, Code for Motor Fuel Dispensing Facilities and Repair Garages, LP-gas dispensers should be at least 6.1 m (20 ft) from gasoline or diesel dispensers.[27]
All three NFPA vehicle fuel standards require a weather-resistant, diamond-shaped label on the lower right rear of the vehicle, never on the bumper. CNG vehicles carry the letters "CNG", and LP-gas and LNG vehicles the words "propane" or "LNG", in white or silver on a blue background.[8] The labels are retroreflective, so they remain visible at night and in fog.[8]
In the European Union, Directive 2014/94/EU set a common framework for alternative fuels infrastructure, which the Netherlands transposed in a 2017 decree.[9] The Dutch car park guidance of 2021 deals only with lithium-ion powered passenger cars and leaves hydrogen vehicles out, because they were still rare.[9][28] It notes that the incident response risks of hydrogen cars can be as complex as those of electric vehicle fires.[28] It also lists the thermal load of hydrogen and CNG vehicle fires on car park structures as a subject for further research.[29]
Emergency response
Fire apparatus should be placed upwind, because LNG and LP-gas vapours can travel significant distances downwind, and away from the path of any flowing LNG.[8] LNG vapour eventually becomes buoyant, but LP-gas vapour always stays heavier than air. LNG is normally unodorised, while LP-gas is odorised.[8] Before the attack, the handbook advises fire fighters to walk completely around the vehicle at a safe distance and to look for the fuel label at the right rear.[8]
For CNG and LP-gas, water from hose streams can be used to control the fire and to help disperse the vapour.[8] For LNG, water greatly increases the evaporation rate of a liquid pool. The handbook therefore recommends potassium bicarbonate, ammonium phosphate or sodium bicarbonate dry chemical extinguishers until it is confirmed that the fire does not involve the fuel.[8] For hydrogen, whose flame may be invisible, a responder can hold a broom in front and throw dirt ahead; the glowing particles show the edge of the flame.[14]
At a crash the strategy is to stop the release and remove ignition sources, and stopping the flow of burning fuel, where possible, comes before other firefighting.[8] All three fuel systems can be isolated by closing the main shutoff valve at the containers, and CNG vehicles usually have a second valve on the frame rail. On LNG vehicles the liquid valve should be closed but the vent line left open, so that the tank can relieve rising pressure in a fire.[8] The liquid valve can be recognised by its coating of ice and frost, which the vent valve lacks.[8]
Limits of the guidance
Most of the detailed guidance in the source documents comes from one chapter of a 2008 United States handbook. Its statistics end with projections for 2004, and its codes are the NFPA editions of that time.[7] Its scope is limited to CNG, LNG and LP-gas, with brief remarks on hydrogen; electric vehicles appear only in its fleet statistics.[1] The setback distances of NFPA 58 are minimum requirements that reduce risk, not safe distances that remove it. Large continuous liquid leaks can cause vapour cloud, BLEVE and fragment hazards beyond the largest setbacks.[13] The garage and tunnel studies modelled selected scenarios and hypothetical vehicles, so their conclusions hold only for those cases.[4]
See also
Notes
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 Rivkin (2008b), p. 21-41.
- ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 Van der Graaf et al. (2021/2023), p. 10.
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 Rivkin (2008b), p. 21-55.
- ↑ 4.00 4.01 4.02 4.03 4.04 4.05 4.06 4.07 4.08 4.09 4.10 4.11 4.12 Rivkin (2008b), p. 21-58.
- ↑ 5.00 5.01 5.02 5.03 5.04 5.05 5.06 5.07 5.08 5.09 5.10 5.11 Rivkin (2008b), p. 21-59.
- ↑ 6.0 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 Rivkin (2008b), p. 21-60.
- ↑ 7.0 7.1 7.2 Rivkin (2008b), p. 21-42 (Table 21.4.1).
- ↑ 8.00 8.01 8.02 8.03 8.04 8.05 8.06 8.07 8.08 8.09 8.10 Rivkin (2008b), p. 21-74.
- ↑ 9.0 9.1 9.2 Van der Graaf et al. (2021/2023), p. 18.
- ↑ 10.0 10.1 10.2 10.3 Rivkin (2008b), p. 21-73.
- ↑ 11.0 11.1 11.2 11.3 11.4 11.5 Rivkin (2008b), p. 21-69.
- ↑ 12.0 12.1 Rivkin (2008b), p. 21-56 (Table 21.4.14).
- ↑ 13.0 13.1 13.2 13.3 Rivkin (2008b), p. 21-67.
- ↑ 14.0 14.1 14.2 Lemoff (2008), p. 6-182.
- ↑ Beyler (2002a), p. 3-268.
- ↑ Beyler (2002a), p. 3-269.
- ↑ Rivkin (2008b), p. 21-62.
- ↑ 18.0 18.1 18.2 18.3 Rivkin (2008b), p. 21-70.
- ↑ Lemoff (2008), p. 6-171.
- ↑ 20.0 20.1 20.2 Slye (2008), p. 6-202.
- ↑ 21.0 21.1 Lemoff (2008), p. 6-183 (Table 6.10.5).
- ↑ Slye (2008), pp. 6-202–6-203.
- ↑ 23.0 23.1 23.2 Rivkin (2008b), p. 21-72.
- ↑ Long et al. (2008), p. 21-5.
- ↑ 25.0 25.1 25.2 25.3 Rivkin (2008b), p. 21-71.
- ↑ Routhier (2008), p. 21-18.
- ↑ Rivkin (2008b), p. 21-68.
- ↑ 28.0 28.1 Van der Graaf et al. (2021/2023), p. 19.
- ↑ Van der Graaf et al. (2021/2023), p. 55.
References
- Beyler, C. L. (2002a). Fire hazard calculations for large, open hydrocarbon fires. In P. J. DiNenno, D. Drysdale, C. L. Beyler, W. D. Walton, R. L. P. Custer, J. R. Hall Jr., & J. M. Watts Jr. (Eds.), SFPE handbook of fire protection engineering (3rd ed., pp. 3-268–3-314). National Fire Protection Association; Society of Fire Protection Engineers.
- Lemoff, T. C. (2008). Gases. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 6-165–6-186). National Fire Protection Association.
- Long, R. T., Jr., Colwell, J. D., Ray, R., Grossman, H. L., Thomas, B., & Strassburger, R. (2008). Passenger vehicle fires. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 21-3–21-14). National Fire Protection Association.
- Rivkin, C. H. (2008b). Vehicle fueling using gaseous fuels. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 21-41–21-76). National Fire Protection Association.
- Routhier, B. (2008). Fire safety in commercial vehicles. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 21-15–21-27). National Fire Protection Association.
- Slye, O. M., Jr. (2008). Flammable and combustible liquids. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 6-197–6-208). National Fire Protection Association.
- Van der Graaf, J., Hessels, T., & Rosmuller, N. (2023). Fire safety of indoor car parks accommodating electrically powered vehicles. Nederlands Instituut Publieke Veiligheid. (Original work published 2021)