Contents
An irritant gas in fire smoke causes painful effects where it contacts the eyes, nose, throat or lungs. Irritants can cause tearing, coughing and breathing difficulty while a person is trying to escape.[1] A fire glossary includes acid gases and other hydrocarbon by-products that cause pain on contact or inhalation.[2] A gas-hazard classification described in the 2008 handbook uses a narrower definition: a non-corrosive chemical that causes reversible inflammation.[3]
Irritants form one of the three classes of fire gas toxicant, alongside the asphyxiants and a small group with unusual effects.[4] They matter to Fire toxicity in a different way from the asphyxiants. Sensory irritation depends mainly on the concentration present at that moment, while narcosis depends on the dose built up over time.[5] Important examples are hydrogen chloride from polyvinyl chloride and acrolein from smouldering cellulose and polyethylene.[6][1]
At lethal concentrations, irritants often cause death after exposure, through lung inflammation and oedema that appear hours later. Very high concentrations can also kill during exposure. Irritants can indirectly increase risk by slowing or stopping escape.[1][7][8] Van Rossum distinguishes irritant from toxic gases in a Dutch escape-design discussion.[9] In Gann and Bryner's model, initial sensory irritation follows the concentration encountered during escape, while asphyxiant effects follow accumulated dose.[5]
What counts as an irritant gas
In the United States, NFPA 55 as described in the 2008 edition of the Fire Protection Handbook lists irritant gas among the health hazards of gases, next to corrosive, cryogenic, toxic and highly toxic gases.[10] An irritant gas is defined there as a chemical that is not corrosive but causes a reversible inflammatory effect on living tissue by chemical action at the site of contact.[3] The test is formal. A chemical is a skin irritant if it scores 5 or more on intact skin of albino rabbits after at least four hours' exposure under 16 CFR 1500.41. Other appropriate techniques are permitted. It is an eye irritant if so determined by the procedure of 16 CFR 1500.42 or another appropriate technique.[3]
Reversibility separates the NFPA 55 irritant classification from the corrosive-gas classification. A corrosive gas causes visible destruction or irreversible alteration of living tissue at the point of contact.[3] Fire toxicologists also call halogen acids such as hydrogen chloride irritants because they cause sensory and lung responses in smoke; that describes an effect rather than assigning the gas to the narrower non-corrosive category.[1]
Combustion toxicology divides the effects into two groups. Sensory irritation covers the eyes and the upper respiratory tract, while pulmonary irritation affects the lungs.[1] Most fire irritants produce signs of both.[1] Occupational limits are of little help here. Threshold limit values and long-term exposure values are designed for daily workplace exposure, while fire exposures are high concentrations over a few minutes.[4]
Sensory and pulmonary irritation
Eye irritation is immediate and depends primarily on concentration.[1] Nerve endings in the cornea are stimulated, which causes pain, reflex blinking and tearing, and severe exposure can damage the eye.[1] A victim may shut the eyes to relieve the pain, which protects the cornea but also prevents them from finding the way out.[1] Airborne irritants also enter the nose, mouth and throat, where they cause burning sensations and mucus secretion.[1] These sensory effects do not normally grow more severe as the exposure continues.[1]
What follows is different in kind. Inhaled irritants reach the lungs and produce coughing, bronchoconstriction and increased pulmonary flow resistance.[1] Tissue inflammation, pulmonary oedema and death may follow high concentrations, usually within 6 to 48 hours, and survivors appear more liable to bacterial infection afterwards.[1] Unlike sensory irritation, this response depends on both the concentration and the duration of the exposure, and it follows the accumulated dose fairly closely.[1][7]
The gap between the two effects is wide. For a fixed 30 minute exposure, the concentration that kills is usually 15 to 500 times the concentration producing severe irritation, according to Purser.[7] Animal data must be read with care, because the response differs between species. Rodents reflexively slow their breathing when exposed, which protects them, whereas primates breathe faster, so a larger share of the irritant reaches the lungs.[1][8]
The standard animal measure is the mouse RD50, the concentration that halves the respiratory rate.[8] A relationship has been demonstrated between this value and the potency of known irritants in people.[8] One author holds that a human exposed at the mouse RD50 of any substance would be severely irritated, and seriously incapacitated within three minutes.[8] Potencies cover an enormous span. The sensory potencies of fire irritants differ by six orders of magnitude, and their lethal potencies by about five.[11]
Which gases occur in fire smoke
Inorganic irritants in smoke are the halogen acids and the compounds formed from nitrogen oxides; the organic irritants are mainly aldehydes.[12] Polymers containing fluorine, chlorine or bromine give hydrogen fluoride, Hydrogen chloride and hydrogen bromide.[6] These acids form during the pyrolysis part of combustion and are not oxidised further, so they can appear even without flaming. The handbook says their formation efficiencies can be close to unity, while material composition can reduce the yield.[6]
Polyvinyl chloride is the best known source. It releases hydrogen chloride readily at about 225 to 275 °C, and the mass yield can exceed the stoichiometric value early in decomposition.[6] Formulations with a high calcium carbonate filler give far lower yields, because the chlorine reacts to form solid calcium chloride, which is thermally stable in a fire.[6] Fluoropolymers are a major source of hydrogen fluoride, and halogenated fire-retardant additives contribute as well.[1]
Acid-gas concentrations can decay quickly where adsorptive surfaces and water droplets are present in fire effluent below 100 °C.[6] As smoke travels from a fire, surface deposition can reduce acid-gas concentrations relative to narcotic gases. A model that assumes a fixed proportion can therefore overestimate acid-gas exposure farther away.[13] The same deposition can lower the exposure of equipment to corrosion. The CFAST zone model described in the 2008 handbook includes a routine for hydrogen chloride loss to surfaces.[14]
Nitrogen dioxide and nitric oxide are the main oxides of nitrogen, with nitric oxide about one fifth as potent as the dioxide.[1] In rat tests under smoke toxicity test conditions nitrogen dioxide has a lethal potency comparable with hydrogen cyanide, but it acts as a pulmonary irritant, and deaths occur after the exposure, usually within a day.[1] Sulfur-containing polymers give sulfur oxides, and phosphorus-based fire retardants can give a phosphoric acid aerosol, for which no predictive yields exist.[6]
Among the organic irritants, formaldehyde, the unsaturated aldehydes and the isocyanates from nitrogen-containing polymers are judged the most important.[6] Acrolein stands out. It has been found in many fire atmospheres, and it forms during the smouldering of all cellulosic materials and the oxidative pyrolysis of polyethylenes.[6] Benedetti and Colonna describe hydrogen chloride and sulfur dioxide from some burning polymer products as so strongly irritating that occupants would ordinarily leave before toxic effects became dangerous. That observation depends on an available escape route and does not remove the risk of delayed lung injury.[15][7]
Effect on escape
The practical importance of irritants lies in what they do to movement. Sensory irritation of the respiratory tract can reduce the speed of movement and the ability to negotiate an escape route, and at higher exposures it leads to incapacitation or death.[16] Eye irritation prolongs exposure to all the other hazards, because it adds to the loss of Visibility in smoke.[16]
Walking experiments show the size of the effect. In nonirritant smoke, walking speed fell from about 1.2 m/s in clear air to 0.3 m/s at an optical density of 0.5 per metre. At that density people behaved as if in darkness and felt their way along the walls.[17] With irritant smoke from heated wood chippings, speed dropped to the same level at an optical density of only 0.2 per metre, and the experience was more distressing.[17] In one corridor study, 31 subjects walked up to 10.5 m through smoke from smouldering cedar crib chips at extinction coefficients of 0.1 to 1.2 per metre. Both their walking speed and their ability to answer mental arithmetic questions fell as the smoke density and the radiant heat rose.[18]
Tears are the specific mechanism. In thick irritating smoke they prevented subjects from reading the words on signs and made them walk irregularly or along the wall. In thin smoke, walking speeds were about the same as in non-irritating smoke.[19] Visibility through thin smoke is governed by physical obscuration, but in thick smoke the physiological irritant effect becomes the dominant factor.[20] Roughly 30 per cent of people turn back rather than enter smoke, on average at a visibility of about 3 m.[17]
Classification tests do not capture all of these effects. The smoke developed index of NFPA 255 is determined solely by obscuration of light. The irritancy of the smoke and its debilitating effect on escaping occupants are not evaluated by the usual limit of 450.[21] Lethality endpoints commonly used in a Smoke toxicity test do not directly measure sensory irritation.[22] In nonflaming cup furnace tests of wood and flexible polyurethane foam, measured gases accounted for only 0.47 and 0.29 of the observed toxic potency. Purser presumed that much of the remainder was due to organic irritants that were not measured.[23]
Tenability criteria
Sensory irritation follows the concentration rather than the dose. It is therefore assessed with a Fractional effective concentration rather than with an accumulated dose. Each irritant present is divided by the concentration of that gas judged to incapacitate, and the fractions are added:[5]
The time at which the sum reaches 1 is taken as the time at which the average person becomes incapacitated.[5] The same criterion of 1 is used for the dose-based measure applied to the asphyxiants. The two thresholds should be set equal, so that neither hazard is weighted more heavily than the other.[13]
| Symbol | Description | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| volume fraction of irritant x present at that moment | µL/L | |
| volume fraction of irritant x judged to incapacitate | µL/L | |
| sum of the fractions for all irritants present | – |
| Gas | Incapacitating value, ISO 13571[1][24] | Impairs escape in half the population[25] | Incapacitates half the population[25] |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hydrogen chloride | 1,000 | 200 | 900 |
| Hydrogen bromide | 1,000 | 200 | 900 |
| Hydrogen fluoride | 500 | 200 | 900 |
| Sulfur dioxide | 150 | 24 | 120 |
| Nitrogen dioxide | 250 | 70 | 350 |
| Acrolein | 30 | 4 | 20 |
| Formaldehyde | 250 | 6 | 30 |
A second sum handles the delayed lung injury. The fraction of a lethal dose is formed from the exposure doses of the same gases and accumulated until it reaches 1. The doses used are 114,000 ppm·min for hydrogen chloride and 4,500 ppm·min for acrolein.[26] Dividing those doses by 30 minutes gives 3,800 and 150 µL/L, numerically equal to the handbook's 30 minute rat LC50 values for the two gases.[27] Purser's table describes predicted lethal doses for people, so these endpoints should not be treated as identical evidence. Where the aldehyde concentrations are unknown, an optical density of 0.5 per metre may stand in for escape-impairing irritancy, and 90 OD·m−1·min for a lethal organic irritant dose.[25][26]
Worked example: two baboon exposures
Baboons were trained to operate a lever to escape from a chamber after a five minute exposure. They performed the task at 2,780 µL/L of acrolein and at 16,570 µL/L of hydrogen chloride.[28][1] Dividing by the human incapacitation criteria in the equation gives 2,780/30 = 92.7 for the acrolein test and 16,570/1,000 = 16.6 for the hydrogen chloride test.[1][24]
Both quotients exceed 1 by a wide margin, yet neither exposure prevented the trained lever movement. The criteria are estimates for human escape, not validated predictions of baboon behaviour, so these quotients illustrate an extrapolation limit. The handbook considers its acrolein criterion conservative in light of the baboon result.[1][24]
The lethal side of the same experiments points the other way. One baboon died from pulmonary effects after exposure at 1,025 µL/L of acrolein, and two died at about 17,000 µL/L of hydrogen chloride.[28] These deaths followed the short exposures, even though the trained movement was still possible at high concentrations.[28] Performing a lever task and surviving the subsequent lung injury are distinct outcomes; neither directly measures a person's ability to find an exit in a real fire.[1][29]
Uncertainty and disagreement
Setting irritant thresholds has been controversial, because almost no controlled human studies exist and most information is anecdotal.[1] The two main sources in fire engineering do not agree. For hydrogen chloride the handbook's consensus incapacitating value is five times the concentration at which Purser expects escape to be impaired, and for formaldehyde it is more than forty times.[1][24][25] Values for hydrogen fluoride run the other way, with Purser placing incapacitation at 900 µL/L against the handbook's 500 µL/L.[1][25]
Human data that do exist come from accidents and from low-level experiments. Hydrogen chloride is perceived as irritant from about 10 to 50 µL/L, is strongly irritant at 50 to 100 µL/L, and brief exposure at 1,000 to 2,000 µL/L is regarded as dangerous to lethal.[25] A separate account gives 75 µL/L as extremely irritating to the eyes and upper respiratory tract, with 50 µL/L as the maximum for exposures of 30 to 60 minutes.[30] For nitrogen dioxide, throat irritation can begin at 62 µL/L, 117 to 154 µL/L is dangerous for short exposures, and 140 to 775 µL/L is rapidly fatal.[31]
Hydrogen fluoride shows how widely the thresholds are spaced. Detection, severe sensory irritation and the approximate lethal concentration lie roughly two and three orders of magnitude apart.[32] Published health effects put slight eye and nasal irritation below 50 µL/L for two minutes, while above 200 µL/L for ten minutes escape-impairing effects will occur and higher concentrations can be lethal without medical treatment.[33] Emergency planning guidelines for ten minute exposures set 50 µL/L as the level at which evacuation should begin and 170 µL/L as the maximum non-lethal concentration.[33]
Susceptibility varies as much as the data. Asthmatics and people with chronic bronchitis or reactive airways dysfunction can suffer bronchoconstriction, collapse and occasionally death after brief exposure to low irritant concentrations.[13] A criterion of 0.3 instead of 1 leaves about 11 per cent of the population liable to incapacitation, and no threshold is statistically safe for everyone.[13] Applying a factor of 0.3 to the escape-impairment concentrations is suggested as allowing nearly all exposed people to escape.[25]
Two further gaps remain. Smoke atmospheres often prove more irritant than their measured composition can explain, which points to short-lived reactive species that are not routinely measured.[34] Tests for incapacitation by sensory irritation have been developed but are little used, partly for want of validation against effects on people, so the field has settled on inferring incapacitation from lethality instead.[27]
See also
Notes
- ↑ 1.00 1.01 1.02 1.03 1.04 1.05 1.06 1.07 1.08 1.09 1.10 1.11 1.12 1.13 1.14 1.15 1.16 1.17 1.18 1.19 1.20 1.21 1.22 1.23 1.24 1.25 Gann and Bryner (2008), p. 6-16.
- ↑ Iqbal and Salley (2004), p. F-40.
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 3.3 Lemoff (2008), p. 6-167.
- ↑ 4.0 4.1 Gann and Bryner (2008), p. 6-14.
- ↑ 5.0 5.1 5.2 5.3 Gann and Bryner (2008), p. 6-24.
- ↑ 6.0 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 6.6 6.7 6.8 Gann and Bryner (2008), p. 6-13.
- ↑ 7.0 7.1 7.2 7.3 Purser (2002), p. 2-112.
- ↑ 8.0 8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4 Purser (2002), p. 2-113.
- ↑ Van Rossum (2027), §7.7.
- ↑ Lemoff (2008), p. 6-166.
- ↑ Purser (2002), p. 2-91.
- ↑ Gann and Bryner (2008), p. 6-15.
- ↑ 13.0 13.1 13.2 13.3 Gann and Bryner (2008), p. 6-25.
- ↑ Hurley and Bukowski (2008), p. 3-133.
- ↑ Benedetti and Colonna (2008), p. 6-230.
- ↑ 16.0 16.1 Gann and Bryner (2008), p. 6-11.
- ↑ 17.0 17.1 17.2 Purser (2002), p. 2-118.
- ↑ Bryan (2008), pp. 4-35–4-36.
- ↑ Iqbal and Salley (2004), p. 18-3.
- ↑ Iqbal and Salley (2004), p. 18-6.
- ↑ Hirschler (2008b), p. 18-27.
- ↑ Purser (2002), p. 2-151.
- ↑ Purser (2002), p. 2-152.
- ↑ 24.0 24.1 24.2 24.3 Gann and Bryner (2008), p. 6-17.
- ↑ 25.0 25.1 25.2 25.3 25.4 25.5 25.6 Purser (2002), p. 2-121.
- ↑ 26.0 26.1 Purser (2002), p. 2-122.
- ↑ 27.0 27.1 Gann and Bryner (2008), p. 6-18.
- ↑ 28.0 28.1 28.2 Purser (2002), p. 2-115.
- ↑ Purser (2002), p. 2-114.
- ↑ Iqbal and Salley (2004), p. B-68.
- ↑ Iqbal and Salley (2004), p. B-69.
- ↑ DiNenno and Taylor (2008), p. 17-115.
- ↑ 33.0 33.1 DiNenno and Taylor (2008), p. 17-116.
- ↑ Purser (2002), p. 2-116.
References
- Benedetti, R. P., & Colonna, G. R. (2008). Polymeric materials. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 6-209–6-231). National Fire Protection Association.
- Bryan, J. L. (2008). Human behavior and fire. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 4-3–4-47). National Fire Protection Association.
- DiNenno, P. J., & Taylor, G. M. (2008). Halon and halon replacement agents and systems. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 17-93–17-121). National Fire Protection Association.
- Gann, R. G., & Bryner, N. P. (2008). Combustion products and their effects on life safety. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 6-11–6-34). National Fire Protection Association.
- Hirschler, M. M. (2008b). Interior finish. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 18-23–18-42). National Fire Protection Association.
- Hurley, M. J., & Bukowski, R. W. (2008). Fire hazard analysis techniques. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 3-121–3-134). National Fire Protection Association.
- Iqbal, N., & Salley, M. H. (2004). Fire Dynamics Tools (FDTs): Quantitative fire hazard analysis methods for the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Fire Protection Inspection Program (NUREG-1805). U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation.
- Lemoff, T. C. (2008). Gases. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 6-165–6-186). National Fire Protection Association.
- Purser, D. A. (2002). Toxicity assessment of combustion products. In P. J. DiNenno, D. Drysdale, C. L. Beyler, W. D. Walton, R. L. P. Custer, J. R. Hall Jr., & J. M. Watts Jr. (Eds.), SFPE handbook of fire protection engineering (3rd ed., pp. 2-83–2-171). National Fire Protection Association; Society of Fire Protection Engineers.
- Van Rossum, E. (2027). Introduction to Fire Safety Engineering. Fire Safety Academy.