Contents
Alternative water supply is a water-supply arrangement used where the conventional pressurised supply does not provide the required firefighting service. [1] Examples include developed static sources, natural water bodies and transported water. Each needs a defined extraction and delivery route, sufficient usable quantity and availability under adverse conditions. A large nearby water body is not automatically a dependable supply at the protected demand point. [2][3]
The supply assessment follows the complete route from the source to useful water at the incident. Seasonal minimum conditions, withdrawal limits, transport and initial availability can each govern the result. Total water volume is therefore different from sustained delivered flow. The mobilisation and handling involved also distinguish these arrangements from an immediately available automatic supply for a fixed sprinkler installation. [2][4] Availability can change with both season and weather. [5]
Establishing a dependable alternative
The assessment begins with the required fire water supply and the needed fire flow; an ordinary fire hydrant may be absent, or an existing main may be inadequate for the particular demand. Alternatives can then combine stored or natural water with pumping and transport. Their capacity is assessed through the actual route rather than through source volume alone. [1][6]
A dry hydrant develops a permanent suction access point, while drafting establishes flow from the static source; a water shuttle adds a transport cycle between the source and incident. These functions can form one chain but are not synonyms. A constraint at any stage can limit the sustained water delivered to the fireground. [7]
Seasonal minimum conditions and incident access are central to dependability; sediment can reduce useful depth, freezing can obstruct extraction, and a load-bearing access area may be necessary for apparatus. These conditions distinguish a mapped source from an operational source. The resulting arrangement also retains its mobilisation delays when compared with an automatic fixed-system supply. [8][4]
Static sources and fireground logistics
A natural or stored source is useful only if water can be withdrawn when the incident occurs; seasonal low level, drought, ice and sediment can reduce usable capacity or obstruct the intake. Access routes and the standing area for apparatus are part of the withdrawal arrangement. Surface area alone therefore says little about the dependable firefighting supply. [5]
A dry hydrant provides a permanent suction connection to a static source; the pipe is normally unpressurised, and apparatus supplies the pumping action. The intake arrangement excludes troublesome debris while remaining suitably submerged. Connections and joints must preserve the suction path, since admitting air can prevent reliable withdrawal even without a visible outward water leak. [9]
Drafting introduces limits that differ from receiving water under positive pressure; the available atmospheric-pressure head must cover lift, suction losses and the margin above vapour pressure required by the pump. Longer piping, restrictive fittings and falling source level reduce that available margin. A nominal pump capacity quoted under other conditions does not establish drafting performance at the site. [9][3]
Transporting water adds time and handling constraints; a vehicle repeatedly fills, travels, discharges and returns. Fill and dump arrangements can become bottlenecks when several vehicles share them. The fireground also needs water while these cycles develop, so an initial reserve and sustained delivery rate answer different operational questions. [10]
The same distinction applies when assessing a static source against a fire-flow demand; a pond may contain sufficient total water while its access or intake supports too little continuous withdrawal. A rapid initial discharge may exhaust a small available reserve before replenishment becomes effective. Both rate and duration are therefore assessed through the actual extraction and transport chain. [2][6]
These arrangements can support manual firefighting without constituting an automatic sprinkler supply; their dependence on mobilisation, priming, transport and connection must remain visible in the fire safety analysis. The handbook distinguishes automatic availability from water that requires human action before delivery. Treating the latter as immediately available would omit the delays that define its operation. [4][11]
Calculating transport throughput
The average delivery from a water-carrying vehicle is the usable quantity delivered during one complete cycle divided by the cycle time; the time includes filling, loaded travel, discharge and return travel. Manoeuvring and connection delays belong in the relevant operation. Omitting them overstates the continuous supply that the vehicle can maintain. [12]
The handbook expresses this relationship with a factor allowing for less than complete delivery of the nominal load. That factor describes the assumed operation rather than changing the vehicle's physical tank volume. The equation gives a cycle average; it does not imply that discharge occurs uniformly throughout the trip. [12]
| Symbol | Description | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| Average delivered flow | L/min | |
| Nominal vehicle volume and delivery factor | L; dimensionless | |
| Fill, outbound travel, dump and return times | min |
Using the handbook's rounded SI inputs gives a vehicle volume of 5,678 L and a delivery factor of 0.9. Filling takes 3 minutes, discharge takes 4 minutes, and the two travel legs take 4.22 and 4.25 minutes. The full cycle is therefore 15.47 minutes. Recalculation gives approximately 330 L/min as the cycle-average contribution. [13]
A fleet calculation cannot assume that every additional vehicle contributes that rate under unchanged conditions; queues at a common fill point or discharge point increase the cycle time. Limited access can also prevent simultaneous manoeuvres. The result must therefore represent the planned operation, including the capacity of the shared equipment. [10]
The demand comparison is made against sustained effective delivery and the initial water reserve; a brief high discharge rate from a portable tank is not itself a replenishment rate. Likewise, a large vehicle volume does not compensate for an indefinitely long turnaround. The calculation makes these trade-offs visible without predicting fire extinguishment from delivered volume alone. [10][6]
Suction conditions and cavitation
Water approaching an impeller must retain enough absolute pressure to avoid excessive vapour formation; pressure falls as flow accelerates through the inlet region. If local pressure reaches the water's vapour pressure, bubbles can form and subsequently collapse in higher-pressure regions. This cavitation can produce noise, vibration, loss of performance and material damage. [14][15]
Available net positive suction head describes the installation's suction energy above vapour-pressure head; required net positive suction head describes a pump characteristic supplied by the manufacturer for stated operating conditions. The two quantities must be compared at the relevant flow and speed. They are not two alternative names for a suction gauge reading. [16][15]
For a large open reservoir, the following form separates atmospheric pressure, water level and suction losses; the reservoir surface velocity is treated as negligible. A positive elevation difference means that the water surface is above the pump reference. A lower surface contributes a negative term. [15]
| Symbol | Description | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| Available net positive suction head | m | |
| Absolute atmospheric and vapour pressures | Pa | |
| Water density and gravitational acceleration | kg/m³; m/s² | |
| Surface elevation, pump elevation and suction loss | m |
The lowest usable tank level can be more demanding than the initial full condition; a greater flow increases suction-pipe loss and can also increase the pump's required suction head. Warmer water increases vapour pressure, while atmospheric pressure varies with elevation. These effects explain why a universal maximum suction lift cannot represent every installation. [17][15]
The handbook illustrates a pump requiring approximately 3.05 m of suction head at 7,570 L/min and 5.49 m at 11,400 L/min. These are converted values from one illustrative manufacturer's-style curve, not general acceptance limits. Their significance is the changing requirement as flow rises. The appropriate comparison uses the actual pump data and the available head under the corresponding supply condition. [14]
Flow, pressure and duration
A fire water supply has several necessary characteristics: adequate flow, sufficient pressure at that flow, an appropriate duration and availability when needed; these characteristics cannot replace one another. A large reservoir may have insufficient delivery capacity, while a high-pressure connection may offer too little sustained flow. The required combination depends on the fire protection demand being assessed. [6][18]
Demand must identify which outlets operate together; sprinkler calculations assemble the flows of individual operating sprinklers and include other applicable demands under the selected design basis. Municipal fire-flow planning addresses a different question and may include wider firefighting activity. Treating every quoted fire-flow value as a sprinkler demand obscures these differences. [19][20]
The supply location also matters; a pressure measured in a street main is not automatically available at a building riser. Connecting pipework, backflow assemblies and changes in elevation affect the transfer. The assessment follows the supply through these elements to the same reference point used for the calculated demand. [4][21]
Storage introduces a time dimension that a pressure-flow curve alone does not show; usable water is the quantity that the outlet or pump can actually draw while meeting its operating conditions. Water below the effective intake, or reserved for another purpose, cannot simply be counted as fire reserve. Replenishment contributes only through an identified source and a delivery arrangement that remains available. [22][23]
A constant-flow volume calculation multiplies flow by duration. In the following form, flow is in litres per minute and usable volume is in cubic metres. The factor converts litres to cubic metres. [23]
| Symbol | Description | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| Usable water volume | m³ | |
| Constant discharge and duration | L/min; min |
A worked example separates usable water from gross capacity. Using Fleming's example of 530 L/min for 30 minutes gives 15,900 L, or 15.9 m³, of usable water. This arithmetic does not select a design duration or establish the gross tank volume. The example is a historical worked calculation, with tank configuration and unavailable volume assessed separately. [23]
Public supplies can change with domestic use, industrial demand, maintenance and seasonal conditions; tank levels and pump operation can change during a fire as well. The design record therefore needs the conditions represented by the available supply, including relevant adverse conditions. A favourable isolated reading does not establish availability throughout the required incident duration. [6][24]
Availability and common dependencies
Two components do not necessarily provide two independent supplies; a pair of pumps may share the same tank, intake, electrical route or vulnerable connecting main. A looped network may still depend on one source connection. The relevant question is whether the required water path remains available after the particular failure being considered. [25][26]
The NIST investigation of the World Trade Center's 2001 fire suppression systems provides a specific illustration; its review identified vulnerabilities associated with floor-feed arrangements and with the limits of some hydraulic calculation paths. It also considered the dependence of manually operated equipment on personnel access and action. These findings describe that complex and that investigation; they are not failure probabilities for all buildings. [26]
The case also shows why upstream duplication alone is insufficient; alternative water sources may converge on a single downstream segment. Damage or isolation at that segment can interrupt the route to the affected area despite apparently generous upstream equipment. Conversely, a reserve serving another pressure zone does not automatically become a usable alternative without an available connection. [26]
Automatic and manual supply functions need separate treatment; a fire department connection depends on responding apparatus, water, personnel and access. A stored or pumped automatic supply can begin serving a demand without those same preliminary actions, provided its own operating chain remains intact. Calling both arrangements a water supply does not make their activation times or dependencies equivalent. [4][27]
Duration introduces further common dependencies; refill may rely on the same utility that a reserve is intended to supplement. Fuel and cooling water can constrain a driver even when the pump itself is mechanically sound. Seasonal source variation can affect both the initial reserve and its replenishment. Such dependencies belong in the description of the actual arrangement. [22][28][5]
Availability also changes during maintenance; sectional isolation can limit the area affected by work, while unclear valve identification can enlarge it. The handbook links planned shutdowns to preparation, notification and verified restoration. Records of the normal configuration make these operational controls meaningful rather than relying on an assumed open water path. [29]
Measuring the available supply
A supply test relates an observed discharge to the pressure remaining elsewhere in the connected system; the initial static reading describes the condition before the test discharge begins. The residual reading describes the pressure while the measured discharge is flowing. Both belong to the same test arrangement and must be recorded with its location and operating conditions. [30][31]
The flowing outlet and the pressure observation have different functions; a pitot measurement in an appropriate free jet supports an estimate of outlet flow. A gauge at the residual hydrant measures pressure in the distribution system during that discharge. Substituting jet pressure for residual system pressure confuses two different physical quantities. [31][30]
The discharge estimate depends on outlet geometry and the coefficient representing its losses; a disturbed or nonuniform jet makes a single point reading less representative. Probe alignment and position also influence the measurement. For some discharge devices, a calibrated nozzle or suitable flowmeter provides a more appropriate method than applying a simple pitot relation. [31]
Test results describe a network state, rather than an unlimited promise of future supply; domestic demand, pumps, source levels and closed valves can change that state. The pressure reference must also be carried correctly to the building calculation. A test performed at a different elevation or upstream of additional resistance needs hydraulic interpretation before comparison with system demand. [6][21]
A main-drain test provides a different kind of evidence; the handbook uses changes from previous static and flowing readings to identify possible deterioration or obstruction. This is useful for detecting change, but it does not independently establish the full sprinkler demand. Test opening, supply state and instrument condition affect whether successive observations are comparable. [32]
Pump testing likewise separates a start test from a flow-performance test; running successfully without substantial discharge demonstrates some operating functions but does not establish the entire pump curve. Flowing observations across the relevant operating range give evidence about delivery capability. The handbook describes retaining records so that deterioration and the ability to meet system demand can be assessed. [33]
See also
Notes
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 Cote (2008), ch. 13.4, pp. 13-37,13-40–13-49.
- ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 Cote (2008), ch. 13.4, pp. 13-40–13-49.
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 Titus (2002), ch. 4-2, pp. 4-68–4-69.
- ↑ 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 Cote (2008), ch. 15.4, pp. 15-63–15-65.
- ↑ 5.0 5.1 5.2 Cote (2008), ch. 13.4, pp. 13-40–13-44.
- ↑ 6.0 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 Cote (2008), ch. 15.2, pp. 15-23–15-24.
- ↑ Cote (2008), ch. 13.4, pp. 13-43–13-49.
- ↑ Cote (2008), ch. 13.4, pp. 13-40–13-45.
- ↑ 9.0 9.1 Cote (2008), ch. 13.4, pp. 13-43–13-45.
- ↑ 10.0 10.1 10.2 Cote (2008), ch. 13.4, pp. 13-47–13-49.
- ↑ Cote (2008), ch. 13.4, pp. 13-37,13-47–13-49.
- ↑ 12.0 12.1 Cote (2008), ch. 13.4, pp. 13-48–13-49.
- ↑ Cote (2008), ch. 13.4, pp. 13-49.
- ↑ 14.0 14.1 Cote (2008), ch. 15.6, pp. 15-91.
- ↑ 15.0 15.1 15.2 15.3 Titus (2002), ch. 4-2, pp. 4-68.
- ↑ Cote (2008), ch. 15.6, pp. 15-91–15-92.
- ↑ Cote (2008), ch. 15.6, pp. 15-91–15-95.
- ↑ Cote (2008), ch. 15.4, pp. 15-63–15-67.
- ↑ Cote (2008), ch. 15.2, pp. 15-23–15-29.
- ↑ Fleming (2002), ch. 4-3, pp. 4-74–4-81.
- ↑ 21.0 21.1 Fleming (2002), ch. 4-3, pp. 4-81–4-83.
- ↑ 22.0 22.1 Cote (2008), ch. 15.1, pp. 15-3–15-5.
- ↑ 23.0 23.1 23.2 Fleming (2002), ch. 4-3, pp. 4-83–4-84.
- ↑ Cote (2008), ch. 15.4, pp. 15-63–15-64.
- ↑ Cote (2008), ch. 15.2, pp. 15-27–15-30.
- ↑ 26.0 26.1 26.2 Hopkins et al. (2005), pp. xxxvii–xlii.
- ↑ Cote (2008), ch. 16.10, pp. 16-200–16-201.
- ↑ Cote (2008), ch. 15.6, pp. 15-98–15-99.
- ↑ Cote (2008), ch. 16.11, pp. 16-208–16-209,16-221.
- ↑ 30.0 30.1 Fleming (2002), ch. 4-3, pp. 4-81.
- ↑ 31.0 31.1 31.2 Cote (2008), ch. 15.3, pp. 15-46–15-47.
- ↑ Cote (2008), ch. 16.11, pp. 16-210–16-211.
- ↑ Cote (2008), ch. 16.11, pp. 16-220.
References
- Cote, A. E. (Ed.). (2008). Fire protection handbook (20th ed.). National Fire Protection Association.
- Fleming, R. P. (2002). Automatic sprinkler system calculations. In P. J. DiNenno (Ed.), SFPE handbook of fire protection engineering (3rd ed., pp. 4-72–4-87). National Fire Protection Association.
- Hopkins, M., Schoenrock, J., & Budnick, E. (2005). Fire suppression systems (NIST NCSTAR 1-4B). National Institute of Standards and Technology.
- Titus, J. J. (2002). Hydraulics. In P. J. DiNenno (Ed.), SFPE handbook of fire protection engineering (3rd ed., pp. 4-44–4-71). National Fire Protection Association.