Skip to content
From Fire Safety Academy Wiki
Mark (talk | contribs)
FSE wiki: fact-check: qualify 2008 FCV design claims and hydrogen dilution example (written by Claude Opus 5.5)
Peter (talk | contribs)
Add SVG figures fse-fuel-cell-vehicle-v1.svg, fse-fuel-cell-vehicle-v2.svg, fse-fuel-cell-vehicle-v3.svg, fse-fuel-cell-vehicle-v4.svg (list-3 visual plan)
Line 5: Line 5:
== Principle and main components ==
== Principle and main components ==
A [[Fuel cell]] has two electrodes, an anode and a cathode, separated by an electrolyte. Unlike a battery, it stores its fuel and oxidant outside the cell, so it keeps operating as long as both are replenished.<ref name="Biggins-8-108">Biggins (2008), p. 8-108.</ref> Almost all prototype fuel cell cars and buses described in the 2008 handbook used proton exchange membrane (PEM) fuel cells. Each cell is a thin wafer: a catalyst-coated membrane enclosed in electrically conducting graphite or metal plates.<ref name="SC-21-81">Scheffler and Collins (2008), p. 21-81.</ref> At the anode, hydrogen atoms release their electrons and become protons, which pass through the membrane to the cathode. There they combine with oxygen from the air and with the electrons, which have flowed through the external circuit, to form water.<ref name="SC-21-81" />
A [[Fuel cell]] has two electrodes, an anode and a cathode, separated by an electrolyte. Unlike a battery, it stores its fuel and oxidant outside the cell, so it keeps operating as long as both are replenished.<ref name="Biggins-8-108">Biggins (2008), p. 8-108.</ref> Almost all prototype fuel cell cars and buses described in the 2008 handbook used proton exchange membrane (PEM) fuel cells. Each cell is a thin wafer: a catalyst-coated membrane enclosed in electrically conducting graphite or metal plates.<ref name="SC-21-81">Scheffler and Collins (2008), p. 21-81.</ref> At the anode, hydrogen atoms release their electrons and become protons, which pass through the membrane to the cathode. There they combine with oxygen from the air and with the electrons, which have flowed through the external circuit, to form water.<ref name="SC-21-81" />
[[File:fse-fuel-cell-vehicle-v1.svg|thumb|upright=1.5|alt=Cross-section of a PEM fuel cell with hydrogen at the anode, protons crossing the membrane, oxygen at the cathode and water leaving|Operating principle of a proton exchange membrane (PEM) fuel cell. Based on Scheffler and Collins (2008), p. 21-81 (Figure 21.5.10, redrawn).]]


Cells are assembled in stacks to give enough power and voltage for the drive system; stacks of 50 kW to 150 kW powered prototype cars, minivans and transit buses.<ref name="SC-21-81" /> The rest of the fuel cell system, the balance of plant, delivers hydrogen to the stack, supplies fresh air to the cathodes and manages stack temperature and water.<ref name="SC-21-81" /> A power control turns the driver's throttle input into electric power for the drive motors.<ref name="SC-21-78" /> Many FCVs are hybrids that recover braking energy and store it in batteries or ultracapacitors. Some carry a separate small fuel cell, an auxiliary power unit of typically 3 kW to 10 kW, for systems such as radios and air conditioning.<ref name="SC-21-78" />
Cells are assembled in stacks to give enough power and voltage for the drive system; stacks of 50 kW to 150 kW powered prototype cars, minivans and transit buses.<ref name="SC-21-81" /> The rest of the fuel cell system, the balance of plant, delivers hydrogen to the stack, supplies fresh air to the cathodes and manages stack temperature and water.<ref name="SC-21-81" /> A power control turns the driver's throttle input into electric power for the drive motors.<ref name="SC-21-78" /> Many FCVs are hybrids that recover braking energy and store it in batteries or ultracapacitors. Some carry a separate small fuel cell, an auxiliary power unit of typically 3 kW to 10 kW, for systems such as radios and air conditioning.<ref name="SC-21-78" />
Line 16: Line 17:


The storage system has four main functions. A filling receptacle, for example to SAE J2600, typically contains a check valve to limit backflow when the nozzle is disconnected, and a second check valve usually provides redundancy.<ref name="SC-21-84" /><ref name="SC-21-85" /> One or more containers hold the gas, and shutoff valves and pressure regulators control its delivery to the fuel cells, as on compressed natural gas vehicles. One or more pressure relief devices are intended to reduce the risk of tank rupture if the system is exposed to fire.<ref name="SC-21-85" /> The containers draw on experience with compressed natural gas and are designed to contain hydrogen without bursting.<ref name="SC-21-85" />
The storage system has four main functions. A filling receptacle, for example to SAE J2600, typically contains a check valve to limit backflow when the nozzle is disconnected, and a second check valve usually provides redundancy.<ref name="SC-21-84" /><ref name="SC-21-85" /> One or more containers hold the gas, and shutoff valves and pressure regulators control its delivery to the fuel cells, as on compressed natural gas vehicles. One or more pressure relief devices are intended to reduce the risk of tank rupture if the system is exposed to fire.<ref name="SC-21-85" /> The containers draw on experience with compressed natural gas and are designed to contain hydrogen without bursting.<ref name="SC-21-85" />
[[File:fse-fuel-cell-vehicle-v2.svg|thumb|upright=1.5|alt=Schematic of a vehicle compressed hydrogen system with receptacle, check valves, container, shutoff valve, relief device and regulator|Compressed hydrogen storage system of a fuel cell vehicle. Based on Scheffler and Collins (2008), pp. 21-84–21-85 (Figure 21.5.19, redrawn).]]


Compressed hydrogen cylinders are protected against overpressure by frangible (bursting) discs, alone or combined with fusible plugs. Because they contain no liquid, they are not subject to a [[BLEVE|boiling liquid expanding vapour explosion]], although they can still fail.<ref name="Lemoff-6-181" /> For identification, SAE recommended a blue diamond label like the one used on natural gas vehicles, marked with compressed hydrogen or the other storage method used.<ref name="SC-21-85" />
Compressed hydrogen cylinders are protected against overpressure by frangible (bursting) discs, alone or combined with fusible plugs. Because they contain no liquid, they are not subject to a [[BLEVE|boiling liquid expanding vapour explosion]], although they can still fail.<ref name="Lemoff-6-181" /> For identification, SAE recommended a blue diamond label like the one used on natural gas vehicles, marked with compressed hydrogen or the other storage method used.<ref name="SC-21-85" />
Line 27: Line 29:


Whether a discharge from a vehicle can burn depends on how it mixes with air. A mixture of hydrogen, oxygen and nitrogen is potentially flammable when it contains more than 4 % hydrogen and more than 5 % oxygen by volume.<ref name="SC-21-86" /> A discharge already diluted to 5 % hydrogen with inert gas never becomes flammable, because its hydrogen falls below 4 % before the oxygen reaches 5 %. Pure hydrogen, in contrast, passes through a flammable mixture as it disperses.<ref name="SC-21-86" /> The 4 % limit comes from tests on uniform, quiescent mixtures. Tests on discharges have shown that flow and mixing can suppress ignition, and that more than 8 % hydrogen is typically needed to ignite them.<ref name="SC-21-86" />
Whether a discharge from a vehicle can burn depends on how it mixes with air. A mixture of hydrogen, oxygen and nitrogen is potentially flammable when it contains more than 4 % hydrogen and more than 5 % oxygen by volume.<ref name="SC-21-86" /> A discharge already diluted to 5 % hydrogen with inert gas never becomes flammable, because its hydrogen falls below 4 % before the oxygen reaches 5 %. Pure hydrogen, in contrast, passes through a flammable mixture as it disperses.<ref name="SC-21-86" /> The 4 % limit comes from tests on uniform, quiescent mixtures. Tests on discharges have shown that flow and mixing can suppress ignition, and that more than 8 % hydrogen is typically needed to ignite them.<ref name="SC-21-86" />
[[File:fse-fuel-cell-vehicle-v3.svg|thumb|upright=1.5|alt=Chart of oxygen versus hydrogen percentage with a potentially flammable region and two mixing lines from the discharge to air|Potential flammability of hydrogen discharges as they mix with air: a discharge diluted to 5 % hydrogen stays outside the potentially flammable region, a pure discharge crosses it. Based on Scheffler and Collins (2008), p. 21-86 (Figure 21.5.20, redrawn).]]


An ignited release from a small opening forms a [[Jet fire]]. The SFPE Handbook gives an example for hydrogen flowing from a 5 mm nozzle out of a reservoir at 300 kPa.<ref name="Heskestad-2-5">Heskestad (2002), p. 2-5.</ref> The flow is choked at 3.65 g/s, the heat release rate is 436 kW, and the flame is about 239 nozzle diameters long, or about 1.2 m.<ref name="Heskestad-2-5" /> In this momentum-dominated regime the flame length is proportional to the opening diameter for a given gas and discharge density.<ref name="Heskestad-2-4">Heskestad (2002), pp. 2-4–2-5.</ref> Vehicle storage pressures are more than a hundred times higher than in this example, so it shows the scaling, not the flame length from a vehicle leak.<ref name="SC-21-84" />
An ignited release from a small opening forms a [[Jet fire]]. The SFPE Handbook gives an example for hydrogen flowing from a 5 mm nozzle out of a reservoir at 300 kPa.<ref name="Heskestad-2-5">Heskestad (2002), p. 2-5.</ref> The flow is choked at 3.65 g/s, the heat release rate is 436 kW, and the flame is about 239 nozzle diameters long, or about 1.2 m.<ref name="Heskestad-2-5" /> In this momentum-dominated regime the flame length is proportional to the opening diameter for a given gas and discharge density.<ref name="Heskestad-2-4">Heskestad (2002), pp. 2-4–2-5.</ref> Vehicle storage pressures are more than a hundred times higher than in this example, so it shows the scaling, not the flame length from a vehicle leak.<ref name="SC-21-84" />
Line 74: Line 77:


Fuelling borrows its static protection from gasoline. The handbook describes a conductive path from the fuelling neck to the tyres and from the tyre contact surface to the station nozzle.<ref name="SC-21-87" /><ref name="SC-21-88">Scheffler and Collins (2008), p. 21-88.</ref> This [[Bonding and grounding|bonding and grounding]] path reduces the risk of ignition by static sparks, and the countermeasure was adapted to hydrogen fuelling.<ref name="SC-21-88" /> The handbook also calls for station leak detection, emergency shutoff on a fault, and breakaway protection if the vehicle moves off with the nozzle connected.<ref name="SC-21-88" /> Station relief valves are intended to protect vehicle storage against overpressure. The stated setting is 1.38 times nominal working pressure: 48.3 MPa for a 35 MPa system and 96.6 MPa for a 70 MPa system.<ref name="SC-21-88" />
Fuelling borrows its static protection from gasoline. The handbook describes a conductive path from the fuelling neck to the tyres and from the tyre contact surface to the station nozzle.<ref name="SC-21-87" /><ref name="SC-21-88">Scheffler and Collins (2008), p. 21-88.</ref> This [[Bonding and grounding|bonding and grounding]] path reduces the risk of ignition by static sparks, and the countermeasure was adapted to hydrogen fuelling.<ref name="SC-21-88" /> The handbook also calls for station leak detection, emergency shutoff on a fault, and breakaway protection if the vehicle moves off with the nozzle connected.<ref name="SC-21-88" /> Station relief valves are intended to protect vehicle storage against overpressure. The stated setting is 1.38 times nominal working pressure: 48.3 MPa for a 35 MPa system and 96.6 MPa for a 70 MPa system.<ref name="SC-21-88" />
[[File:fse-fuel-cell-vehicle-v4.svg|thumb|upright=1.5|alt=Horizontal bar chart of pressures for natural gas systems, hydrogen vehicle storage and hydrogen station relief settings|Pressures of natural gas and hydrogen fuelling systems, with station relief valve settings at 1.38 times the nominal working pressure. Based on Scheffler and Collins (2008), pp. 21-84 and 21-88, and Rivkin (2008b), pp. 21-69 and 21-74.]]


Repair garages built to NFPA 30A, ''Code for Motor Fuel Dispensing Facilities and Repair Garages'', were considered adequate for FCVs as long as nobody works on the hydrogen storage system.<ref name="SC-21-88" /> Areas for such work need more. A vent system will probably be required to depressurise and purge the vehicle storage system before major repairs.<ref name="SC-21-88" /> Ventilation, gas and fire detection, electrical classification, links between the ventilation system and other areas, and the fire rating of walls and doors should also be considered.<ref name="SC-21-88" />
Repair garages built to NFPA 30A, ''Code for Motor Fuel Dispensing Facilities and Repair Garages'', were considered adequate for FCVs as long as nobody works on the hydrogen storage system.<ref name="SC-21-88" /> Areas for such work need more. A vent system will probably be required to depressurise and purge the vehicle storage system before major repairs.<ref name="SC-21-88" /> Ventilation, gas and fire detection, electrical classification, links between the ventilation system and other areas, and the fire rating of walls and doors should also be considered.<ref name="SC-21-88" />

Revision as of 13:22, 12 November 2026

A fuel cell vehicle (FCV) is an electric vehicle in which a fuel cell turns hydrogen carried on board into electric power for the traction motors. Unlike a battery, the cell draws its reactants from a continuing hydrogen and air supply; the vehicle consumes its stored hydrogen while driving.[1] At the point of use, a hydrogen fuel cell vehicle emits water vapour from its exhaust.[2] In the 20th edition of the NFPA Fire Protection Handbook (2008), FCVs were demonstration vehicles; about 300 fuel cell cars and buses were expected in California by 2007.[2]

The 2008 handbook described about 6 kg of hydrogen as typical on-board storage, with pressure then rising from 350 bar (35 MPa) towards 700 bar, and 300 V to 600 V as typical drive voltage.[3][4] The fire hazards therefore come from two sources: a gas with a very wide flammable range and an often invisible flame, and a high-voltage electrical system.[5][6] The handbook describes design measures to reduce these risks: fail-safe valves and disconnects, managed hydrogen discharges, and pressure relief devices intended to vent the gas during a fire and reduce the risk of container rupture.[7][8]

Principle and main components

A Fuel cell has two electrodes, an anode and a cathode, separated by an electrolyte. Unlike a battery, it stores its fuel and oxidant outside the cell, so it keeps operating as long as both are replenished.[9] Almost all prototype fuel cell cars and buses described in the 2008 handbook used proton exchange membrane (PEM) fuel cells. Each cell is a thin wafer: a catalyst-coated membrane enclosed in electrically conducting graphite or metal plates.[10] At the anode, hydrogen atoms release their electrons and become protons, which pass through the membrane to the cathode. There they combine with oxygen from the air and with the electrons, which have flowed through the external circuit, to form water.[10]

Cross-section of a PEM fuel cell with hydrogen at the anode, protons crossing the membrane, oxygen at the cathode and water leaving
Operating principle of a proton exchange membrane (PEM) fuel cell. Based on Scheffler and Collins (2008), p. 21-81 (Figure 21.5.10, redrawn).

Cells are assembled in stacks to give enough power and voltage for the drive system; stacks of 50 kW to 150 kW powered prototype cars, minivans and transit buses.[10] The rest of the fuel cell system, the balance of plant, delivers hydrogen to the stack, supplies fresh air to the cathodes and manages stack temperature and water.[10] A power control turns the driver's throttle input into electric power for the drive motors.[1] Many FCVs are hybrids that recover braking energy and store it in batteries or ultracapacitors. Some carry a separate small fuel cell, an auxiliary power unit of typically 3 kW to 10 kW, for systems such as radios and air conditioning.[1]

The 2008 handbook used efficiency and emissions to explain the case for FCVs. It estimated that an internal combustion engine converted about 16 % of gasoline energy into motion at the wheels, whereas an FCV could exceed 50 %.[1] The exhaust contains no combustion pollutants, although producing the hydrogen can cause upstream emissions.[2] Fuel cell types are named after their electrolyte. Phosphoric acid cells operate at about 200 °C and solid oxide cells at about 1,000 °C, while polymer electrolyte cells run cooler and were mainly used in mobile applications.[11] In stationary use, the high operating temperatures of some fuel cells can ignite nearby combustibles, and the fuel is often a flammable gas or liquid.[11]

FCVs range from 12.2 m (40 ft) transit buses down to motor scooters and fork-lift trucks.[1] Transit buses were seen as a good early market because they have well-defined duty cycles, central fuelling and maintenance, and dedicated maintenance staff.[12] As a hydrogen-fuelled vehicle, an FCV is one kind of alternative fuel vehicle, since United States law lists hydrogen among the alternative fuels.[13] Most hydrogen vehicles are fuel cell powered; the few that burn hydrogen in an internal combustion engine present hazards similar to those of natural gas vehicles.[14]

Hydrogen storage on board

Hydrogen can be carried as compressed gas, as liquid, in reversible metal hydrides or as a chemical hydride. It can also be produced on board from hydrocarbon fuels or alcohol. All these methods had been demonstrated by 2008, but most FCVs described then used compressed hydrogen stored at high pressure in containers on the vehicle.[1] The technical challenge was to carry enough gas for a reasonable driving range. The handbook estimated that a typical FCV needed about 6 kg of hydrogen; manufacturers were raising storage pressures from 350 bar to 700 bar (approximately 5,000 psig to 10,000 psig).[3]

The storage system has four main functions. A filling receptacle, for example to SAE J2600, typically contains a check valve to limit backflow when the nozzle is disconnected, and a second check valve usually provides redundancy.[3][8] One or more containers hold the gas, and shutoff valves and pressure regulators control its delivery to the fuel cells, as on compressed natural gas vehicles. One or more pressure relief devices are intended to reduce the risk of tank rupture if the system is exposed to fire.[8] The containers draw on experience with compressed natural gas and are designed to contain hydrogen without bursting.[8]

Schematic of a vehicle compressed hydrogen system with receptacle, check valves, container, shutoff valve, relief device and regulator
Compressed hydrogen storage system of a fuel cell vehicle. Based on Scheffler and Collins (2008), pp. 21-84–21-85 (Figure 21.5.19, redrawn).

Compressed hydrogen cylinders are protected against overpressure by frangible (bursting) discs, alone or combined with fusible plugs. Because they contain no liquid, they are not subject to a boiling liquid expanding vapour explosion, although they can still fail.[5] For identification, SAE recommended a blue diamond label like the one used on natural gas vehicles, marked with compressed hydrogen or the other storage method used.[8]

FCVs need clean hydrogen, and the industry was aiming for less than 1,000 ppm of impurities.[15] For this reason the fuel is not odorised, unlike natural gas. An odorant would either damage fuel cell components or pass through the cell and be concentrated up to 500 times in the exhaust, masking any real leak.[16] In liquid hydrogen all compounds except helium freeze, so an odorant would stay behind while the hydrogen leaked out.[16] Hydrogen delivered by pipeline with an odorant should therefore be deodorised before it is dispensed.[16]

Hydrogen properties and release behaviour

Hydrogen has an extremely wide flammable range, from about 4 % to 75 % by volume in air, and the highest burning velocity of any gas.[5][17] Its ignition temperature is reasonably high, but its ignition energy is very low, and with a density of only 0.07 relative to air it disperses rapidly.[5][17] Because it contains no carbon, it burns with a nonluminous flame that is often invisible in daylight and gives off little thermal radiation, so people can walk into it unaware.[5][18] For hydrogen safety these properties work in both directions. The wide flammable range and high burning rate accentuate the hazard, while the low ignition energy, low heat of combustion per unit volume and low-radiation flame counteract it in many cases.[5]

How a release behaves depends on its pressure. When gaseous hydrogen escapes at high pressure, small heat sources such as friction or static electricity can ignite it promptly, so it often behaves as if it were self-igniting. Such releases usually lead to fires rather than explosions.[5] At low pressure self-ignition is unlikely, but an accumulated cloud can explode with a very rapid pressure rise that is extremely difficult to vent.[5] Escaping hydrogen gas seldom leaves a situation without fire, because it either ignites promptly or rises rapidly.[18]

Whether a discharge from a vehicle can burn depends on how it mixes with air. A mixture of hydrogen, oxygen and nitrogen is potentially flammable when it contains more than 4 % hydrogen and more than 5 % oxygen by volume.[15] A discharge already diluted to 5 % hydrogen with inert gas never becomes flammable, because its hydrogen falls below 4 % before the oxygen reaches 5 %. Pure hydrogen, in contrast, passes through a flammable mixture as it disperses.[15] The 4 % limit comes from tests on uniform, quiescent mixtures. Tests on discharges have shown that flow and mixing can suppress ignition, and that more than 8 % hydrogen is typically needed to ignite them.[15]

Chart of oxygen versus hydrogen percentage with a potentially flammable region and two mixing lines from the discharge to air
Potential flammability of hydrogen discharges as they mix with air: a discharge diluted to 5 % hydrogen stays outside the potentially flammable region, a pure discharge crosses it. Based on Scheffler and Collins (2008), p. 21-86 (Figure 21.5.20, redrawn).

An ignited release from a small opening forms a Jet fire. The SFPE Handbook gives an example for hydrogen flowing from a 5 mm nozzle out of a reservoir at 300 kPa.[19] The flow is choked at 3.65 g/s, the heat release rate is 436 kW, and the flame is about 239 nozzle diameters long, or about 1.2 m.[19] In this momentum-dominated regime the flame length is proportional to the opening diameter for a given gas and discharge density.[20] Vehicle storage pressures are more than a hundred times higher than in this example, so it shows the scaling, not the flame length from a vehicle leak.[3]

Hydrogen quantities: worked example

Three simple relations show what the hydrogen on board means for fire safety. The volume of the gas at ambient conditions is its mass divided by its density. The air volume needed to reach the lower flammable limit under ideal uniform mixing follows from the method Slye (2008) gives for flammable vapours: (100 − LFL) volumes of air per LFL volumes of gas.[21] The chemical energy stored is the mass multiplied by the heat of combustion.[19]

Vg=mρ

Vair=Vg100−LFLLFL

E=mΔHc

Symbol Description Unit
m Mass of hydrogen kg
ρ Density of hydrogen at ambient temperature and pressure kg/m³
Vg Volume of the hydrogen at ambient conditions m³
LFL Lower flammable limit of hydrogen in air % by volume
Vair Air volume at which hydrogen reaches the lower flammable limit under uniform mixing m³
ΔHc Heat of combustion of hydrogen MJ/kg
E Chemical energy of the stored hydrogen MJ

As a worked example, take the handbook's typical on-board quantity of 6 kg.[3] With a density of 0.083 kg/m³ at ambient temperature and pressure, it occupies 6 / 0.083 = 72.3 m³.[19] Uniform mixing with 72.3 × 96 / 4 = 1,735 m³, or about 1,740 m³, of air would give a concentration of 4 %. Slightly more air would be needed to fall below this lower flammable limit.[15][21] With a heat of combustion of 120 MJ/kg, the 6 kg holds 720 MJ of chemical energy.[19] Using the lower heating value and density of gasoline in the handbook, this equals the energy of about 16 kg to 17 kg, or 21 L to 24 L, of gasoline.[22]

The dilution estimate assumes complete, uniform mixing, which is rarely achieved in practice. It is an ideal mixing threshold and not a ventilation design value; Slye calls for a substantial excess of air in a ventilated enclosure.[23] Hydrogen's high diffusion rate also makes it difficult for the gas to accumulate in ordinary buildings unless it escapes quickly.[18] On the other hand, the tests on vehicle discharges suggest that real jets often need more than 8 % hydrogen to ignite.[15] For garages and other structures, the SAE approach combines analysis with tests on the vehicle.[15]

Vehicle safety design

The handbook sets a design objective that foreseeable single-point hardware or software failures should not create an unreasonable risk or uncontrolled vehicle behaviour.[7] It recommends redundant safety features or, where redundancy is not possible, a high safety factor, as for a pressure vessel. Failure modes and effects analysis (FMEA) identifies risks, and separating hazards aims to prevent failures from cascading.[7] The fail-safe approach calls for electrical disconnects to open and fuel shutoff valves to close when they lose power. This is intended to isolate electrical and fuel sources if a control signal is interrupted by accident, equipment failure or human error.[7] When crash sensors detect a collision, the fuel is typically shut off and the electrical system disconnected automatically.[10]

SAE J2578 recommended managing hydrogen discharges so that FCVs could be used like gasoline cars. Its design approach calls for discharges into compartments that may contain ignition sources to be rendered nonflammable.[8] Barriers, dilution or catalytic recombiners can maintain a nonhazardous atmosphere in the passenger compartment. A leak beyond the capacity of these countermeasures is intended to trigger a staged warning and shutdown.[8]

The local region where a discharge mixes with air should be unignitible at all times.[8] An SAE approach combines analysis and tests to assess the atmosphere around a vehicle parked in a residential garage or operating in a mechanically ventilated commercial building. Manufacturers were to verify that it remained unclassified under Article 500 of NFPA 70 on hazardous area classification. The handbook envisaged that vehicles meeting this objective could be used in those settings without building-code changes.[15]

The 2008 prototype electric drives typically operated at 300 V to 600 V and borrowed safety measures from electric and hybrid vehicles.[4][6] Their high-voltage circuits are designed to be isolated from the chassis, so a single-point touch of an intact, isolated circuit does not give a shock. Interlocks or special fasteners are intended to prevent access to live parts, and fuses limit overcurrent.[6] High-voltage cables are identified by permanent orange covering, and compartments by a black-on-yellow high-voltage symbol. Automatic and manual disconnects are intended to isolate both poles of the fuel cell stack, the traction battery and other high-voltage sources.[6][3]

Fuelling and maintenance

Hydrogen fuelling stations described in the 2008 handbook typically stored hydrogen on site, often as a cryogenic liquid that was warmed back into gas before use.[24] The handbook gave pressures of up to 69 MPa (10,000 psi) for hydrogen stations, against 20.7 MPa to 27.6 MPa (3,000 psi to 4,000 psi) for natural gas stations.[24] The low density of hydrogen requires these high tank pressures to store enough fuel for a practical driving range.[24] In 2008 the California Hydrogen Highway plan aimed for a network of stations along the state's interstate highways by 2010.[16]

Fuelling borrows its static protection from gasoline. The handbook describes a conductive path from the fuelling neck to the tyres and from the tyre contact surface to the station nozzle.[16][25] This bonding and grounding path reduces the risk of ignition by static sparks, and the countermeasure was adapted to hydrogen fuelling.[25] The handbook also calls for station leak detection, emergency shutoff on a fault, and breakaway protection if the vehicle moves off with the nozzle connected.[25] Station relief valves are intended to protect vehicle storage against overpressure. The stated setting is 1.38 times nominal working pressure: 48.3 MPa for a 35 MPa system and 96.6 MPa for a 70 MPa system.[25]

Horizontal bar chart of pressures for natural gas systems, hydrogen vehicle storage and hydrogen station relief settings
Pressures of natural gas and hydrogen fuelling systems, with station relief valve settings at 1.38 times the nominal working pressure. Based on Scheffler and Collins (2008), pp. 21-84 and 21-88, and Rivkin (2008b), pp. 21-69 and 21-74.

Repair garages built to NFPA 30A, Code for Motor Fuel Dispensing Facilities and Repair Garages, were considered adequate for FCVs as long as nobody works on the hydrogen storage system.[25] Areas for such work need more. A vent system will probably be required to depressurise and purge the vehicle storage system before major repairs.[25] Ventilation, gas and fire detection, electrical classification, links between the ventilation system and other areas, and the fire rating of walls and doors should also be considered.[25]

Crash, fire and emergency response

The 2008 handbook estimated that, in the United States, about 1.2 % (385) of roughly 32,000 passenger vehicle occupants killed annually in traffic accidents died in post-collision motor vehicle fires. It identified fuel-fed fires and fires starting in engine compartments as the two main post-collision categories.[26] FCVs were expected to be at least as crashworthy as other vehicles. The SAE identified two keys to safety after a crash: nobody may be exposed to electric shock, and the hydrogen must stay contained.[25]

In a crash, the hydrogen shutoff valves at the containers typically close and isolate the system. Only a small amount of gas remains downstream, whose energy is typically less than that of the fuel lines of a gasoline vehicle.[8] If the vehicle is then exposed to fire, from the crash or from another burning vehicle, the pressure relief devices are designed to activate thermally and vent hydrogen, reducing the risk of container rupture. FCV makers adopted this practice from natural gas vehicles.[8][25] The SAE post-crash design goal was to discharge high-voltage circuits or isolate them from ground to prevent a harmful shock from contact.[25]

For responders the main difficulty is that a hydrogen flame may be invisible. The 2008 handbook describes holding a broom out in front while advancing slowly and throwing dirt ahead; the particles glow and show the edge of the flame.[18] Water should be applied to fire-exposed containers, and the flow of gas stopped if possible.[18] A Dutch guidance document on car parks notes that the incident response risks of hydrogen cars can be as complex as those of electric vehicle fires.[27] It calls for more research into the flame egress and thermal load on car park structures of fires in hydrogen or natural gas vehicles.[28]

Limits of the evidence

The handbook chapter on FCVs was written with contributions from members of the United States fuel cell industry association, at a time when the vehicles were still in demonstration.[2] Its safety conclusions rest partly on studies it quotes, such as a 1997 Ford study for the Department of Energy. That study judged an FCV potentially safer than gasoline or propane vehicles and equal to or better than natural gas vehicles.[8] Many of the SAE standards it describes, including the test methods for discharges and crashes, were still being developed.[15][25]

The source documents contain no fire test data for fuel cell vehicles. The Dutch car park guidance leaves hydrogen vehicles out of its scope because they were still rare, and refers to a separate report that is not among the sources.[27] The handbook chapters also differ on the density of hydrogen relative to air, giving 0.07 and 0.1.[17][29]

See also

Notes

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 Scheffler and Collins (2008), p. 21-78.
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 Scheffler and Collins (2008), p. 21-77.
  3. ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 Scheffler and Collins (2008), p. 21-84.
  4. ↑ 4.0 4.1 Scheffler and Collins (2008), p. 21-82.
  5. ↑ 5.0 5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 5.6 5.7 Lemoff (2008), p. 6-181.
  6. ↑ 6.0 6.1 6.2 6.3 Scheffler and Collins (2008), p. 21-83.
  7. ↑ 7.0 7.1 7.2 7.3 Scheffler and Collins (2008), p. 21-80.
  8. ↑ 8.00 8.01 8.02 8.03 8.04 8.05 8.06 8.07 8.08 8.09 8.10 Scheffler and Collins (2008), p. 21-85.
  9. ↑ Biggins (2008), p. 8-108.
  10. ↑ 10.0 10.1 10.2 10.3 10.4 Scheffler and Collins (2008), p. 21-81.
  11. ↑ 11.0 11.1 Biggins (2008), p. 8-109.
  12. ↑ Scheffler and Collins (2008), p. 21-79.
  13. ↑ Rivkin (2008b), p. 21-41.
  14. ↑ Rivkin (2008b), p. 21-73.
  15. ↑ 15.0 15.1 15.2 15.3 15.4 15.5 15.6 15.7 15.8 Scheffler and Collins (2008), p. 21-86.
  16. ↑ 16.0 16.1 16.2 16.3 16.4 Scheffler and Collins (2008), p. 21-87.
  17. ↑ 17.0 17.1 17.2 Rivkin (2008b), p. 21-55.
  18. ↑ 18.0 18.1 18.2 18.3 18.4 Lemoff (2008), p. 6-182.
  19. ↑ 19.0 19.1 19.2 19.3 19.4 Heskestad (2002), p. 2-5.
  20. ↑ Heskestad (2002), pp. 2-4–2-5.
  21. ↑ 21.0 21.1 Slye (2008), p. 6-202.
  22. ↑ Rivkin (2008b), p. 21-56 (Table 21.4.14).
  23. ↑ Slye (2008), pp. 6-202–6-203.
  24. ↑ 24.0 24.1 24.2 Rivkin (2008b), p. 21-74.
  25. ↑ 25.00 25.01 25.02 25.03 25.04 25.05 25.06 25.07 25.08 25.09 25.10 Scheffler and Collins (2008), p. 21-88.
  26. ↑ Long et al. (2008), p. 21-5.
  27. ↑ 27.0 27.1 Van der Graaf et al. (2021/2023), p. 19.
  28. ↑ Van der Graaf et al. (2021/2023), p. 55.
  29. ↑ Biggins (2008), p. 8-110.

References

  • Biggins, J. B. (2008). Stationary combustion engines and fuel cells. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 8-105–8-111). National Fire Protection Association.
  • Heskestad, G. (2002). Fire plumes, flame height, and air entrainment. In P. J. DiNenno, D. Drysdale, C. L. Beyler, W. D. Walton, R. L. P. Custer, J. R. Hall Jr., & J. M. Watts Jr. (Eds.), SFPE handbook of fire protection engineering (3rd ed., pp. 2-1–2-17). National Fire Protection Association; Society of Fire Protection Engineers.
  • Lemoff, T. C. (2008). Gases. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 6-165–6-186). National Fire Protection Association.
  • Long, R. T., Jr., Colwell, J. D., Ray, R., Grossman, H. L., Thomas, B., & Strassburger, R. (2008). Passenger vehicle fires. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 21-3–21-14). National Fire Protection Association.
  • Rivkin, C. H. (2008b). Vehicle fueling using gaseous fuels. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 21-41–21-76). National Fire Protection Association.
  • Scheffler, G. W., & Collins, W. P. (2008). Fuel cell vehicles. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 21-77–21-89). National Fire Protection Association.
  • Slye, O. M., Jr. (2008). Flammable and combustible liquids. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 6-197–6-208). National Fire Protection Association.
  • Van der Graaf, J., Hessels, T., & Rosmuller, N. (2023). Fire safety of indoor car parks accommodating electrically powered vehicles. Nederlands Instituut Publieke Veiligheid. (Original work published 2021)