Skip to content
From Fire Safety Academy Wiki
Lisa (talk | contribs)
New FSE wiki article: Fire station location (written by Claude Opus 5.5)
 
Lisa (talk | contribs)
FSE wiki: fact-check corrections (written by Claude Opus 5.5)
Line 1: Line 1:
'''Fire station location''' is the planning of where a community places its fire stations, so that fire and medical units can reach incidents within an adopted time and with enough resources. Fire and rescue services normally start from stations spread over the protected area, and crews must arrive in the minimum possible time after an incident is reported.<ref name="JP-12-217">Johnson and Price (2008), p. 12-217.</ref> For that reason the basis for placing stations is the time needed to deliver adequate resources from each station, or combination of stations, to the point of demand.<ref name="JP-12-219">Johnson and Price (2008), p. 12-219.</ref>
'''Fire station location''' is the planning of where a community places its fire stations, so that fire and medical units can reach incidents within an adopted time and with enough resources. Fire and rescue services normally start from stations spread over the protected area, and crews must arrive in the minimum possible time after an incident is reported.<ref name="JP-12-217">Johnson and Price (2008), p. 12-217.</ref> For that reason the basis for placing stations should be the time needed to deliver adequate resources from each station, or combination of stations, to the point of demand.<ref name="JP-12-219">Johnson and Price (2008), p. 12-219.</ref>


Station location planning starts from a community decision on its [[Emergency response time|response time]] objectives. These are turned into a travel-time allotment and tested on a road network model. Johnson and Price (2008) describe geographic information systems (GIS) as more accurate than the older grid and concentric-circle methods, because they simulate the real road network.<ref name="JP-12-222">Johnson and Price (2008), p. 12-222.</ref> Once a general location is chosen, a specific site is selected on criteria such as terrain, flooding and traffic.<ref name="JP-12-228">Johnson and Price (2008), p. 12-228.</ref> Most guidance summarised here is US practice as reported in the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) ''Fire Protection Handbook'' of 2008.
Station location planning starts from a community decision on its [[Emergency response time|response time]] objectives. These are turned into a travel-time allotment and tested on a road network model. Johnson and Price (2008) describe geographic information systems (GIS) as more accurate than the older grid and concentric-circle methods, because they simulate the real road network.<ref name="JP-12-222">Johnson and Price (2008), p. 12-222.</ref> Once a general location is chosen, a specific site is selected on criteria such as terrain, flooding and traffic.<ref name="JP-12-228">Johnson and Price (2008), p. 12-228.</ref> Most guidance summarised here is US practice as reported in the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) ''Fire Protection Handbook'' of 2008.
Line 6: Line 6:
The time between ignition and the start of fire suppression has a direct relationship to fire loss.<ref name="JP-12-217" /> Depending on room size, contents and available oxygen, flashover can occur in less than 2 or more than 10 minutes, most often between 4 and 10 minutes. The exact time cannot be predicted, because it depends on factors such as the type and arrangement of the fuel and the room size. A fire that has passed flashover burns hotter and spreads faster, while more fire fighters are needed for the attack.<ref name="JP-12-217" />
The time between ignition and the start of fire suppression has a direct relationship to fire loss.<ref name="JP-12-217" /> Depending on room size, contents and available oxygen, flashover can occur in less than 2 or more than 10 minutes, most often between 4 and 10 minutes. The exact time cannot be predicted, because it depends on factors such as the type and arrangement of the fuel and the room size. A fire that has passed flashover burns hotter and spreads faster, while more fire fighters are needed for the attack.<ref name="JP-12-217" />


The same reasoning applies to emergency medical services (EMS). Johnson and Price (2008) report that a heart attack victim who receives cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) within four minutes has an almost four times greater chance of leaving hospital alive.<ref name="JP-12-218">Johnson and Price (2008), p. 12-218.</ref> The survival rates they reproduce from a 1987 American Heart Association manual are 28 percent with CPR in four minutes or less and 7 percent when CPR starts later.<ref name="JP-12-219" /><ref name="JP-12-231">Johnson and Price (2008), p. 12-231.</ref> In fire-based EMS systems, resources are, with few exceptions, deployed from fire stations whose locations are routinely based on time and distance studies.<ref name="Krakeel-13-160">Krakeel (2008), p. 13-160.</ref>
The same reasoning applies to emergency medical services (EMS). Johnson and Price (2008) report that a heart attack victim who receives cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) within four minutes has an almost four times greater chance of leaving hospital alive.<ref name="JP-12-218">Johnson and Price (2008), p. 12-218.</ref> The survival rates they reproduce from a 1987 American Heart Association manual are 28 percent with CPR in four minutes or less and 7 percent when CPR starts later.<ref name="JP-12-219" /><ref name="JP-12-231">Johnson and Price (2008), p. 12-231.</ref> In fire-based EMS systems, resources are, with few exceptions, deployed from fixed locations, generally fire stations whose locations are routinely based on time and distance studies.<ref name="Krakeel-13-160">Krakeel (2008), p. 13-160.</ref>


For scale, in 2005 the United States had about 30,500 local fire departments, with about 48,400 fire stations and 81,200 pumpers of at least 500 gpm (about 1,900 L/min).<ref name="HallCote-3-27">Hall and Cote (2008), p. 3-27.</ref> Brodoff (2008) classes decisions about the number and location of stations as administrative policy decisions on the structure of a department, part of [[Fire department organisation|fire department organisation]]. US courts generally protect such decisions under the discretionary function exception, so a claim that the nearest station was too far away would generally fail.<ref name="Brodoff-12-103">Brodoff (2008), p. 12-103.</ref>
For scale, in 2005 the United States had about 30,500 local fire departments, with about 48,400 fire stations and 81,200 pumpers of at least 500 gpm (about 1,900 L/min).<ref name="HallCote-3-27">Hall and Cote (2008), p. 3-27.</ref> Brodoff (2008) classes decisions about the number and location of stations as administrative policy decisions on the structure of a department, part of [[Fire department organisation|fire department organisation]]. US courts generally protect such decisions under the discretionary function exception, so a claim that the nearest station was too far away would generally fail.<ref name="Brodoff-12-103">Brodoff (2008), p. 12-103.</ref>
Line 13: Line 13:
Johnson and Price (2008) state that each community must decide its own desired response and travel times. They list four factors: the types of service delivered, a reasonable travel time, the size of the area and its resources, and the level of risk the community accepts.<ref name="JP-12-219" /> A short travel time delivers service quickly but requires more stations, so the chosen time must balance service expectations against the community's financial ability to provide the stations and resources. Large rural regions normally have longer times and fewer resources than urban areas. A community that selects a longer travel time accepts a larger risk, a choice that may rest on past experience, for example where remote areas are known to have far fewer incidents.<ref name="JP-12-219" />
Johnson and Price (2008) state that each community must decide its own desired response and travel times. They list four factors: the types of service delivered, a reasonable travel time, the size of the area and its resources, and the level of risk the community accepts.<ref name="JP-12-219" /> A short travel time delivers service quickly but requires more stations, so the chosen time must balance service expectations against the community's financial ability to provide the stations and resources. Large rural regions normally have longer times and fewer resources than urban areas. A community that selects a longer travel time accepts a larger risk, a choice that may rest on past experience, for example where remote areas are known to have far fewer incidents.<ref name="JP-12-219" />


National documents give reference values. NFPA 1710, as described by Johnson and Price (2008), sets objectives for career fire departments of 4 minutes or less for the first engine company and 8 minutes or less for the full first-alarm assignment. These times are to be met in at least 90 percent of incidents.<ref name="JP-12-220">Johnson and Price (2008), p. 12-220.</ref> NFPA 1720, the companion standard for volunteer departments, relates response times to population density.<ref name="JP-12-220" /> Granito (2008) reports the general view that the first apparatus should be on scene within 5 minutes of the alarm sounding at the station. In dense urban settings, 4 minutes for the first pumper is a rule-of-thumb maximum for 90 percent of the area.<ref name="Granito-12-13-14">Granito (2008), pp. 12-13–12-14.</ref>
In the United States, national documents give reference values. NFPA 1710, as described by Johnson and Price (2008), sets objectives for career fire departments of 4 minutes or less for the first engine company and 8 minutes or less for the full first-alarm assignment. These times are to be met in at least 90 percent of incidents.<ref name="JP-12-220">Johnson and Price (2008), p. 12-220.</ref> NFPA 1720, the companion standard for volunteer departments, relates response times to population density.<ref name="JP-12-220" /> Granito (2008) reports the general view that the first apparatus should be on scene within 5 minutes of the alarm sounding at the station. In dense urban settings, 4 minutes for the first pumper is a rule-of-thumb maximum for 90 percent of the area.<ref name="Granito-12-13-14">Granito (2008), pp. 12-13–12-14.</ref>


A second approach is the [[Standards of cover|standards of response coverage]] process of the Commission on Fire Accreditation International (CFAI). It ends with statements such as: in 90 percent of incidents the first-due unit arrives within 4 minutes of travel, or 6 minutes of total reflex time.<ref name="JP-12-222" /> For insurance grading, the Insurance Services Office (ISO) grading schedule behind the [[Public Protection Classification]] checks whether the built-on area of a city has a first-due engine company within 1.5 mi (2.4 km). It also checks for a ladder-service company within 2.5 mi (4 km).<ref name="Granito-12-17">Granito (2008), p. 12-17.</ref> Property in Class 10, the unprotected class, is generally located more than 5 travel miles (8 km) from a recognised fire station.<ref name="Granito-12-16">Granito (2008), p. 12-16.</ref>
A second approach is the [[Standards of cover|standards of response coverage]] process of the Commission on Fire Accreditation International (CFAI). It ends with statements such as: in 90 percent of incidents the first-due unit arrives within 4 minutes of travel, or 6 minutes of total reflex time.<ref name="JP-12-222" /> For US insurance grading, the Insurance Services Office (ISO) grading schedule behind the [[Public Protection Classification]] checks whether the built-on area of a city has a first-due engine company within 1.5 mi (2.4 km). It also checks for a ladder-service company within 2.5 mi (4 km).<ref name="Granito-12-17">Granito (2008), p. 12-17.</ref> Property in Class 10, the unprotected class, is generally located more than 5 travel miles (8 km) from a recognised fire station.<ref name="Granito-12-16">Granito (2008), p. 12-16.</ref>


A community may adopt one standard for its whole area or several standards for different levels of risk. A single standard gives roughly the same initial response everywhere. Several standards mean that some areas are reached sooner than others.<ref name="JP-12-222" /> Risks that may justify different times include sprinklered against unsprinklered property, commercial against residential areas, and multifamily against single-family housing. High life hazard, high value, high incident rates and incidents that need many resources are also listed. A community that differentiates its service in this way needs a much more complex location study.<ref name="JP-12-222" />
A community may adopt one standard for its whole area or several standards for different levels of risk. A single standard gives roughly the same initial response everywhere. Several standards mean that some areas are reached sooner than others.<ref name="JP-12-222" /> Risks that may justify different times include sprinklered against unsprinklered property, commercial against residential areas, and multifamily against single-family housing. High life hazard, high value, high incident rates and incidents that need many resources are also listed. A community that differentiates its service in this way needs a much more complex location study.<ref name="JP-12-222" />


== From a time standard to a travel-time allotment ==
== From a time standard to a travel-time allotment ==
Johnson and Price (2008) describe the total reflex time of a fire department as five steps after receipt of an alarm. These are dispatch time, turnout time, response time, access time and setup time.<ref name="JP-12-218" /> Dispatch time covers receiving the call, determining the type of emergency, verifying the location, determining the resources needed and notifying the units. It is the task of the [[Emergency communications centre|emergency communications centre]], where enhanced 9-1-1 and computer-aided dispatch (CAD) systems can minimise it.<ref name="JP-12-218" /> Turnout time runs from the moment units acknowledge the alarm to the moment they start moving. Response time in this narrow sense is the travel from "wheel start to wheel stop".
Johnson and Price (2008) describe the total reflex time of a fire department as five steps after receipt of an alarm. These are dispatch time, turnout time, response time, access time and setup time.<ref name="JP-12-218" /> Dispatch time covers receiving the call, determining the type of emergency, verifying the location, determining the resources needed and notifying the units. It is the task of the [[Emergency communications centre|emergency communications centre]], where enhanced 9-1-1 and computer-aided dispatch (CAD) systems can minimise it.<ref name="JP-12-218" /> Turnout time runs from the moment units acknowledge the alarm to the moment they start moving. Response time in this narrow sense is the travel from "wheel start to wheel stop".<ref name="JP-12-218" />


Access time is the time for the crew to move from the apparatus to the emergency, including upper storeys and barriers, and depends on [[Fire service access|access]] to and within the building. Setup time covers positioning ladders, laying and charging hose lines and donning breathing apparatus.<ref name="JP-12-218" /> Of these steps, travel is the one that the choice of station location manages directly.
Access time is the time for the crew to move from the apparatus to the emergency, including upper storeys and barriers, and depends on [[Fire service access|access]] to and within the building. Setup time covers positioning ladders, laying and charging hose lines and donning breathing apparatus.<ref name="JP-12-218" /> Of these steps, travel is the one that the choice of station location manages directly.<ref name="JP-12-218" />


Once a standard is adopted, the next step in a location study is to divide it into time intervals for each component. Dispatch and turnout times can usually be set from historical data, while setup time depends on the type and complexity of the incident.<ref name="JP-12-222" /> The remaining time is the allotment for travel. In words, the travel allotment equals the response time standard minus the sum of the times for dispatch, turnout, access and setup:<ref name="JP-12-222" />
Once a standard is adopted, the next step in a location study is to divide it into time intervals for each component. Dispatch and turnout times can usually be set from historical data, while setup time depends on the type and complexity of the incident.<ref name="JP-12-222" /> The remaining time is the allotment for travel. In words, the travel allotment equals the response time standard minus the sum of the times for dispatch, turnout, access and setup:<ref name="JP-12-222" />
Line 41: Line 41:
| <math>t_\mathrm{acc}</math> || Access time: apparatus to the emergency || min
| <math>t_\mathrm{acc}</math> || Access time: apparatus to the emergency || min
|-
|-
| <math>t_\mathrm{set}</math> || Setup time: preparation to apply water or start care || min
| <math>t_\mathrm{set}</math> || Setup time: preparation to apply water || min
|}
|}


Line 53: Line 53:
<math display="block">A = \pi r^2 \quad \Rightarrow \quad r = \sqrt{A / \pi}</math>
<math display="block">A = \pi r^2 \quad \Rightarrow \quad r = \sqrt{A / \pi}</math>


As an illustration, if the ISO engine distance of 1.5 mi were the radius of a circular district, that district would cover about 7.1 mi² (18 km²). A 2.5 mi ladder radius would cover about 19.6 mi² (51 km²), 2.8 times as much. Granito (2008) makes a related point in planning terms. With equal service expectations, a community of 20 mi² (52 km²) needs more resources than one of 10 mi² (26 km²), because units must still arrive in time.<ref name="Granito-12-11">Granito (2008), p. 12-11.</ref>
As an illustration, if the ISO engine distance of 1.5 mi were the radius of a circular district, that district would cover about 7.1 mi² (18 km²). A 2.5 mi ladder radius would cover about 19.6 mi² (51 km²), 2.8 times as much.<ref name="Granito-12-17" /> Granito (2008) makes a related point in planning terms. With equal service expectations, a community of 20 mi² (52 km²) needs more resources than one of 10 mi² (26 km²), because units must still arrive in time.<ref name="Granito-12-11">Granito (2008), p. 12-11.</ref>


Real districts do not follow circles. Johnson and Price (2008) note that, unlike the earlier grid and concentric-circle analyses, GIS simulates the actual road network.<ref name="JP-12-222" /> A street layer is stored as line segments between intersections, each carrying attributes such as road type, distance and travel speed. A network analysis from a station then produces an irregular polygon showing where apparatus can travel in a specified time. The same analysis can be run for all stations at once to find gaps in coverage and to set run orders.<ref name="JP-12-217" /> Accuracy comes from actual distances, vehicle speeds, delays for congestion, turning radius, weather and hills, one-way or unusable roads, and user-defined risk factors.<ref name="JP-12-222" />
Real districts do not follow circles. Johnson and Price (2008) note that, unlike the earlier grid and concentric-circle analyses, GIS simulates the actual road network.<ref name="JP-12-222" /> A street layer is stored as line segments between intersections, each carrying attributes such as road type, distance and travel speed. A network analysis from a station then produces an irregular polygon showing where apparatus can travel in a specified time. The same analysis can be run for all stations at once to find gaps in coverage and to set run orders.<ref name="JP-12-217" /> Accuracy comes from actual distances, vehicle speeds, delays for congestion, turning radius, weather and hills, one-way or unusable roads, and user-defined risk factors.<ref name="JP-12-222" />


Historical data are used to check the model. Response and travel times recorded by CAD or by hand can be analysed by time of day and day of the week. If they reveal traffic patterns, the base map can be adjusted, and in peak hours another company may arrive first.<ref name="JP-12-222" /> The results are colour maps of the street segments reached from each station within the target time, the overlaps between first-due areas, and the areas with no or deficient coverage.<ref name="JP-12-223">Johnson and Price (2008), p. 12-223.</ref>
Historical data are used to check the model. Response and travel times recorded by CAD or by hand can be analysed by time of day and day of the week. If they reveal traffic patterns, the base map can be adjusted, and in peak hours another company may arrive first.<ref name="JP-12-222" /> The results are colour maps of the street segments reached from each station within the target time, the overlaps between first-due areas, and the areas with no or deficient coverage.<ref name="JP-12-222" /><ref name="JP-12-223">Johnson and Price (2008), p. 12-223.</ref>


The handbook chapter illustrates this with a series of maps from one GIS analysis. They show a four-minute analysis for five existing stations and the coverage gained by relocating one station and adding a new one. Further maps add six- and eight-minute analyses and shade areas by the number of apparatus that can be on scene within eight minutes.<ref name="JP-12-223-226">Johnson and Price (2008), pp. 12-223–12-226.</ref> Mutual-aid stations and special teams can be included.<ref name="JP-12-223" /> What-if scenarios for alternative and future sites can be combined with data from local and regional planning groups. A full GIS-based study can be the central component of a master plan for station locations.<ref name="JP-12-223" />
The handbook chapter illustrates this with a series of maps from one GIS analysis. They show a four-minute analysis for five existing stations and the coverage gained by relocating one station and adding a new one. Further maps add six- and eight-minute analyses and shade areas by the number of apparatus that can be on scene within eight minutes.<ref name="JP-12-223-226">Johnson and Price (2008), pp. 12-223–12-226.</ref> Mutual-aid stations and special teams can be included.<ref name="JP-12-223" /> What-if scenarios for alternative and future sites can be combined with data from local and regional planning groups. A full GIS-based study can be the central component of a master plan for station locations.<ref name="JP-12-223" />
Line 102: Line 102:
Built-in protection and the road network interact with station location. Comly (2008) notes that the response time of the fire department can be a major part of the total time to fire control. Limited-access highways may divide a community and delay travel to locations between access points, and lengthy response times may require greater built-in fire protection.<ref name="Comly-11-42-43">Comly (2008), pp. 11-42–11-43.</ref> Granito (2008) adds that a fire department's suppression capability can never fully compensate for missing or deficient built-in protection.<ref name="Granito-12-7">Granito (2008), p. 12-7.</ref> He also quotes a summary of a 2003 UK white paper on integrated risk management: suppression resources are to be allocated on the basis of risk rather than the number of buildings.<ref name="Granito-12-3">Granito (2008), p. 12-3.</ref>
Built-in protection and the road network interact with station location. Comly (2008) notes that the response time of the fire department can be a major part of the total time to fire control. Limited-access highways may divide a community and delay travel to locations between access points, and lengthy response times may require greater built-in fire protection.<ref name="Comly-11-42-43">Comly (2008), pp. 11-42–11-43.</ref> Granito (2008) adds that a fire department's suppression capability can never fully compensate for missing or deficient built-in protection.<ref name="Granito-12-7">Granito (2008), p. 12-7.</ref> He also quotes a summary of a 2003 UK white paper on integrated risk management: suppression resources are to be allocated on the basis of risk rather than the number of buildings.<ref name="Granito-12-3">Granito (2008), p. 12-3.</ref>


Station location also enters performance-based building design. The International Fire Engineering Guidelines (2005) list the number and location of fire stations relative to the building among the principal factors governing fire service capability, which may change over the life of the building.<ref name="IFEG-1.9-5">National Research Council of Canada et al. (2005), p. 1.9-5.</ref> Changes in station locations, budgets and traffic density are named as causes.<ref name="IFEG-1.9-2">National Research Council of Canada et al. (2005), p. 1.9-2.</ref> In Australia, the fire brigade intervention scenario of the Fire Safety Verification Method Standard 2022 applies only to buildings within 50 km of road travel from a fire station.<ref name="ABCB2022-15">Australian Building Codes Board (2022), p. 15.</ref> The accompanying data sheets state that the time to water application is generally based on the notification time of the Fire Brigade Intervention Model and the building's proximity to fire stations.<ref name="ABCB2020a-B1-19">Australian Building Codes Board (2020a), Data Sheet B1, p. 19.</ref>
Station location also enters performance-based building design. The International Fire Engineering Guidelines (2005) list the number and location of fire stations relative to the building among the principal factors governing fire service capability.<ref name="IFEG-1.9-5">National Research Council of Canada et al. (2005), p. 1.9-5.</ref> This capability may vary over the life of the building through changes in fire service location, budgets, equipment and traffic density.<ref name="IFEG-1.9-2">National Research Council of Canada et al. (2005), p. 1.9-2.</ref> In Australia, the fire brigade intervention scenario of the Fire Safety Verification Method Standard 2022 applies only to buildings within 50 km of road travel from a fire station.<ref name="ABCB2022-15">Australian Building Codes Board (2022), p. 15.</ref> The accompanying data sheets state that the time to water application is generally based on the notification time of the Fire Brigade Intervention Model and the building's proximity to fire stations.<ref name="ABCB2020a-B1-19">Australian Building Codes Board (2020a), Data Sheet B1, p. 19.</ref>


The data and standards above describe the United States around 2000 to 2007, as reported in the 2008 handbook. A GIS result depends on its street data and assumed speeds, which is why recorded CAD times are used to calibrate it.<ref name="JP-12-222" /> Johnson and Price (2008) suggest choosing the final times after reviewing several scenarios.<ref name="JP-12-219" />
The US data and standards in this article describe the situation around 2000 to 2007, as reported in the 2008 handbook. A GIS result depends on its street data and assumed speeds, which is why recorded CAD times are used to calibrate it.<ref name="JP-12-222" /> Johnson and Price (2008) suggest choosing the final times after reviewing several scenarios.<ref name="JP-12-219" />


== See also ==
== See also ==

Revision as of 22:31, 7 November 2026

Fire station location is the planning of where a community places its fire stations, so that fire and medical units can reach incidents within an adopted time and with enough resources. Fire and rescue services normally start from stations spread over the protected area, and crews must arrive in the minimum possible time after an incident is reported.[1] For that reason the basis for placing stations should be the time needed to deliver adequate resources from each station, or combination of stations, to the point of demand.[2]

Station location planning starts from a community decision on its response time objectives. These are turned into a travel-time allotment and tested on a road network model. Johnson and Price (2008) describe geographic information systems (GIS) as more accurate than the older grid and concentric-circle methods, because they simulate the real road network.[3] Once a general location is chosen, a specific site is selected on criteria such as terrain, flooding and traffic.[4] Most guidance summarised here is US practice as reported in the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) Fire Protection Handbook of 2008.

Role of station location in fire protection

The time between ignition and the start of fire suppression has a direct relationship to fire loss.[1] Depending on room size, contents and available oxygen, flashover can occur in less than 2 or more than 10 minutes, most often between 4 and 10 minutes. The exact time cannot be predicted, because it depends on factors such as the type and arrangement of the fuel and the room size. A fire that has passed flashover burns hotter and spreads faster, while more fire fighters are needed for the attack.[1]

The same reasoning applies to emergency medical services (EMS). Johnson and Price (2008) report that a heart attack victim who receives cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) within four minutes has an almost four times greater chance of leaving hospital alive.[5] The survival rates they reproduce from a 1987 American Heart Association manual are 28 percent with CPR in four minutes or less and 7 percent when CPR starts later.[2][6] In fire-based EMS systems, resources are, with few exceptions, deployed from fixed locations, generally fire stations whose locations are routinely based on time and distance studies.[7]

For scale, in 2005 the United States had about 30,500 local fire departments, with about 48,400 fire stations and 81,200 pumpers of at least 500 gpm (about 1,900 L/min).[8] Brodoff (2008) classes decisions about the number and location of stations as administrative policy decisions on the structure of a department, part of fire department organisation. US courts generally protect such decisions under the discretionary function exception, so a claim that the nearest station was too far away would generally fail.[9]

Response time standards as the design basis

Johnson and Price (2008) state that each community must decide its own desired response and travel times. They list four factors: the types of service delivered, a reasonable travel time, the size of the area and its resources, and the level of risk the community accepts.[2] A short travel time delivers service quickly but requires more stations, so the chosen time must balance service expectations against the community's financial ability to provide the stations and resources. Large rural regions normally have longer times and fewer resources than urban areas. A community that selects a longer travel time accepts a larger risk, a choice that may rest on past experience, for example where remote areas are known to have far fewer incidents.[2]

In the United States, national documents give reference values. NFPA 1710, as described by Johnson and Price (2008), sets objectives for career fire departments of 4 minutes or less for the first engine company and 8 minutes or less for the full first-alarm assignment. These times are to be met in at least 90 percent of incidents.[10] NFPA 1720, the companion standard for volunteer departments, relates response times to population density.[10] Granito (2008) reports the general view that the first apparatus should be on scene within 5 minutes of the alarm sounding at the station. In dense urban settings, 4 minutes for the first pumper is a rule-of-thumb maximum for 90 percent of the area.[11]

A second approach is the standards of response coverage process of the Commission on Fire Accreditation International (CFAI). It ends with statements such as: in 90 percent of incidents the first-due unit arrives within 4 minutes of travel, or 6 minutes of total reflex time.[3] For US insurance grading, the Insurance Services Office (ISO) grading schedule behind the Public Protection Classification checks whether the built-on area of a city has a first-due engine company within 1.5 mi (2.4 km). It also checks for a ladder-service company within 2.5 mi (4 km).[12] Property in Class 10, the unprotected class, is generally located more than 5 travel miles (8 km) from a recognised fire station.[13]

A community may adopt one standard for its whole area or several standards for different levels of risk. A single standard gives roughly the same initial response everywhere. Several standards mean that some areas are reached sooner than others.[3] Risks that may justify different times include sprinklered against unsprinklered property, commercial against residential areas, and multifamily against single-family housing. High life hazard, high value, high incident rates and incidents that need many resources are also listed. A community that differentiates its service in this way needs a much more complex location study.[3]

From a time standard to a travel-time allotment

Johnson and Price (2008) describe the total reflex time of a fire department as five steps after receipt of an alarm. These are dispatch time, turnout time, response time, access time and setup time.[5] Dispatch time covers receiving the call, determining the type of emergency, verifying the location, determining the resources needed and notifying the units. It is the task of the emergency communications centre, where enhanced 9-1-1 and computer-aided dispatch (CAD) systems can minimise it.[5] Turnout time runs from the moment units acknowledge the alarm to the moment they start moving. Response time in this narrow sense is the travel from "wheel start to wheel stop".[5]

Access time is the time for the crew to move from the apparatus to the emergency, including upper storeys and barriers, and depends on access to and within the building. Setup time covers positioning ladders, laying and charging hose lines and donning breathing apparatus.[5] Of these steps, travel is the one that the choice of station location manages directly.[5]

Once a standard is adopted, the next step in a location study is to divide it into time intervals for each component. Dispatch and turnout times can usually be set from historical data, while setup time depends on the type and complexity of the incident.[3] The remaining time is the allotment for travel. In words, the travel allotment equals the response time standard minus the sum of the times for dispatch, turnout, access and setup:[3]

ttravel=tstd−(tdisp+tturn+tacc+tset)

Symbol Description Unit
ttravel Time allotted to travel from the station to the incident min
tstd Adopted response time standard (total reflex time) min
tdisp Dispatch time: call receipt to notification of units min
tturn Turnout time: acknowledgement to start of travel min
tacc Access time: apparatus to the emergency min
tset Setup time: preparation to apply water min

As an illustration, take a standard of 6 minutes total reflex time measured up to arrival, as in the CFAI example statement. NFPA 1221, as described by Johnson and Price (2008), requires dispatch to be completed within 60 seconds in at least 95 percent of cases, and NFPA 1710 allows a turnout time of 60 seconds.[10] Because the standard ends at arrival, access and setup are not subtracted, and the travel allotment is 6 − 1 − 1 = 4 minutes. This matches the 4 minutes of travel in the CFAI example. The same subtraction applied to its 10-minute standard for the effective response force gives the 8 minutes of travel stated there.[3]

The allotment is sensitive to the type of department. Johnson and Price (2008) note that most of their guidance addresses career departments with stations staffed around the clock, while turnout for call and volunteer departments is typically longer.[3] Granito (2008) gives a rule of thumb that, for a volunteer station without staff on duty, the average time from call to departure of a crewed vehicle could be 6 minutes or longer.[14] Under a fixed standard, a longer turnout leaves less time for travel.

Mapping coverage: from circles to GIS

The simplest model of a station's district is a circle with the station at its centre. Ramachandran (2002b) treats travel time as proportional to travel distance and uses this picture to show that travel distance is proportional to the square root of the area served. Doubling the distance from the station to the edge of its district doubles the radius and quadruples the area.[15] For a circle of radius r and area A:

A=πr2⇒r=A/π

As an illustration, if the ISO engine distance of 1.5 mi were the radius of a circular district, that district would cover about 7.1 mi² (18 km²). A 2.5 mi ladder radius would cover about 19.6 mi² (51 km²), 2.8 times as much.[12] Granito (2008) makes a related point in planning terms. With equal service expectations, a community of 20 mi² (52 km²) needs more resources than one of 10 mi² (26 km²), because units must still arrive in time.[16]

Real districts do not follow circles. Johnson and Price (2008) note that, unlike the earlier grid and concentric-circle analyses, GIS simulates the actual road network.[3] A street layer is stored as line segments between intersections, each carrying attributes such as road type, distance and travel speed. A network analysis from a station then produces an irregular polygon showing where apparatus can travel in a specified time. The same analysis can be run for all stations at once to find gaps in coverage and to set run orders.[1] Accuracy comes from actual distances, vehicle speeds, delays for congestion, turning radius, weather and hills, one-way or unusable roads, and user-defined risk factors.[3]

Historical data are used to check the model. Response and travel times recorded by CAD or by hand can be analysed by time of day and day of the week. If they reveal traffic patterns, the base map can be adjusted, and in peak hours another company may arrive first.[3] The results are colour maps of the street segments reached from each station within the target time, the overlaps between first-due areas, and the areas with no or deficient coverage.[3][17]

The handbook chapter illustrates this with a series of maps from one GIS analysis. They show a four-minute analysis for five existing stations and the coverage gained by relocating one station and adding a new one. Further maps add six- and eight-minute analyses and shade areas by the number of apparatus that can be on scene within eight minutes.[18] Mutual-aid stations and special teams can be included.[17] What-if scenarios for alternative and future sites can be combined with data from local and regional planning groups. A full GIS-based study can be the central component of a master plan for station locations.[17]

Historical incidents can also be mapped and queried by type, cause, time or unit to support decisions on staffing and apparatus placement.[19] Optimisation models exist as well: the FIRE STATION model described by Phillips (2002) finds the optimum among five alternative sites for an urban station in a community of 25 wards. It minimises lives lost, building damage and capital outlay, with losses calculated from the travel-time delay.[20]

Distribution, concentration and changing demand

A location study must cover more than the first-due unit. Granito (2008) distinguishes a department's capability for a quick, adequately staffed initial attack from its capacity to handle multiple alarms and simultaneous calls.[14] Where a company may expect two or three working fires per day, or where structures need a heavy initial response, closer spacing of companies or larger crews may be necessary.[16] First-alarm units that cannot arrive within the first critical period have limited effect on the initial attack, whatever the running card says.[16]

Coverage also changes while units are busy. When companies are committed to a large fire, idle companies should be repositioned through the jurisdiction to keep response times short for other alarms.[21] GIS can show high-risk areas left uncovered during periods of high call volume and recommend how to reallocate the available units, a practice called move-up and cover.[22]

Johnson and Price (2008) state that all fire department planning that involves the allocation of resources requires a station location study. A proper study shows how station placement can improve service while limiting both capital and recurring costs.[4] Future development also matters: community planning influences where new stations are needed and how they are equipped.[23] Relocating or closing a station affects groups outside the fire department, which should be involved early in the planning.[24]

Selecting the station site

A location found by analysis usually leaves several candidate sites. Johnson and Price (2008) list terrain and susceptibility to flooding among the general site factors. GIS can display soil types, earthquake faults, elevation, slope and flood-prone areas, and the size of the structure, the staff and any training area determine the required plot size.[4] Traffic is the second group of factors. Apparatus must be able to enter streets safely and return without disrupting traffic, so a side street may be better than a heavily travelled one. Volunteer stations need easy access for members driving in, and apparatus may be leaving while volunteers are still arriving.[4]

Acomb and LeBoeuf (2008), writing on fire station design, add that the site follows from the department's response goals. A goal of reaching any incident within 4 minutes leads to a different site than a 9-minute goal. The analysis must include a traffic study of intersection delays, travel times and access to routes, and for volunteer stations the members' travel to the station.[25] Stations are often placed in response to past growth, whereas site selection should anticipate growth up to 50 years ahead. Sites on major routes may remove expensive land from the tax base, and a secondary road with a signalised junction onto the main route can improve egress and reduce the risk of accidents.[26]

The same authors give rules of thumb for the plot. The driveway cut should be at least 100 ft (about 30 m) from an intersection. The apparatus apron should be at least 60 ft (about 18 m) deep with a slope of no more than 2 percent, and the road at least 24 ft (about 7.3 m) wide.[27] Permanent barriers such as railway tracks, one-way streets or bridges prone to high water should be avoided, as should the bottom of a hill and the vicinity of schools or entertainment venues. Due diligence covers environmental, geotechnical, archaeological and hazardous materials investigations, utilities, storm water, future road improvements and the concerns of the neighbourhood.[27]

Choosing between candidate sites is a decision with several objectives. Donegan (2002) notes that a fire authority siting a new station may have to balance minimum cost, minimum risk and minimum travel distance, and that such a problem never has a single correct solution.[28] His illustration uses the Simple Multi-Attribute Rating Technique (SMART). Each site receives a value from 0 to 100 on each attribute, and its aggregate benefit is the weighted sum of these values:[29]

Sj=∑i=1nwivij,∑i=1nwi=1

Symbol Description Unit
Sj Aggregate benefit of candidate site j score (0–100)
wi Weight of attribute i –
vij Value of site j on attribute i score (0–100)
n Number of attributes –

In the worked example, five sites in a large urban area are rated on six attributes. The weights are road infrastructure 0.34, spatial access 0.26, bearing capacity 0.19, site dimensions 0.10, area fire statistics 0.08 and planning freedom 0.03.[29] Site A scores 95, 70, 60, 45, 25 and 70 on these attributes, which gives 0.34 × 95 + 0.26 × 70 + 0.19 × 60 + 0.10 × 45 + 0.08 × 25 + 0.03 × 70 = 70.5. The other sites score 36.4 (B), 47.1 (C), 48.1 (D) and 58.2 (E), so site A is the provisional choice.[30]

A sensitivity analysis then varies the combined weight of the situation attributes (road infrastructure, spatial access and area statistics), which is 68 percent in the base case. Site E would overtake site A only if that weight fell below 48.2 percent, well below the professionally judged 68 percent, so site A is recommended. Donegan stresses that the example deals with benefits only and leaves out costs.[30]

Limits and wider context

Station location acts only on the part of the time line after the alarm is received. Johnson and Price (2008) call the interval from ignition through discovery to reporting only indirectly manageable, through automatic detection or suppression and automatic reporting to the public safety answering point.[31] In the MGM Grand Hotel fire in Clark County, Nevada, on 21 November 1980, the fire was discovered at about 7:10 a.m., but the fire department received the call at 7:17 a.m. The first company arrived at about 7:18 a.m. from a station directly across the street, and flashover and spread through the casino followed immediately.[32]

Built-in protection and the road network interact with station location. Comly (2008) notes that the response time of the fire department can be a major part of the total time to fire control. Limited-access highways may divide a community and delay travel to locations between access points, and lengthy response times may require greater built-in fire protection.[33] Granito (2008) adds that a fire department's suppression capability can never fully compensate for missing or deficient built-in protection.[34] He also quotes a summary of a 2003 UK white paper on integrated risk management: suppression resources are to be allocated on the basis of risk rather than the number of buildings.[35]

Station location also enters performance-based building design. The International Fire Engineering Guidelines (2005) list the number and location of fire stations relative to the building among the principal factors governing fire service capability.[36] This capability may vary over the life of the building through changes in fire service location, budgets, equipment and traffic density.[37] In Australia, the fire brigade intervention scenario of the Fire Safety Verification Method Standard 2022 applies only to buildings within 50 km of road travel from a fire station.[38] The accompanying data sheets state that the time to water application is generally based on the notification time of the Fire Brigade Intervention Model and the building's proximity to fire stations.[39]

The US data and standards in this article describe the situation around 2000 to 2007, as reported in the 2008 handbook. A GIS result depends on its street data and assumed speeds, which is why recorded CAD times are used to calibrate it.[3] Johnson and Price (2008) suggest choosing the final times after reviewing several scenarios.[2]

See also

Notes

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 Johnson and Price (2008), p. 12-217.
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 Johnson and Price (2008), p. 12-219.
  3. ↑ 3.00 3.01 3.02 3.03 3.04 3.05 3.06 3.07 3.08 3.09 3.10 3.11 3.12 Johnson and Price (2008), p. 12-222.
  4. ↑ 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.3 Johnson and Price (2008), p. 12-228.
  5. ↑ 5.0 5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 Johnson and Price (2008), p. 12-218.
  6. ↑ Johnson and Price (2008), p. 12-231.
  7. ↑ Krakeel (2008), p. 13-160.
  8. ↑ Hall and Cote (2008), p. 3-27.
  9. ↑ Brodoff (2008), p. 12-103.
  10. ↑ 10.0 10.1 10.2 Johnson and Price (2008), p. 12-220.
  11. ↑ Granito (2008), pp. 12-13–12-14.
  12. ↑ 12.0 12.1 Granito (2008), p. 12-17.
  13. ↑ Granito (2008), p. 12-16.
  14. ↑ 14.0 14.1 Granito (2008), p. 12-8.
  15. ↑ Ramachandran (2002b), p. 5-86.
  16. ↑ 16.0 16.1 16.2 Granito (2008), p. 12-11.
  17. ↑ 17.0 17.1 17.2 Johnson and Price (2008), p. 12-223.
  18. ↑ Johnson and Price (2008), pp. 12-223–12-226.
  19. ↑ Johnson and Price (2008), pp. 12-216–12-217.
  20. ↑ Phillips (2002), pp. 5-116–5-117.
  21. ↑ Granito (2008), p. 12-13.
  22. ↑ Johnson and Price (2008), p. 12-229.
  23. ↑ Granito (2008), p. 12-19.
  24. ↑ Granito (2008), p. 12-18.
  25. ↑ Acomb and LeBoeuf (2008), p. 12-234.
  26. ↑ Acomb and LeBoeuf (2008), pp. 12-234–12-235.
  27. ↑ 27.0 27.1 Acomb and LeBoeuf (2008), p. 12-235.
  28. ↑ Donegan (2002), p. 5-13.
  29. ↑ 29.0 29.1 Donegan (2002), pp. 5-14–5-15.
  30. ↑ 30.0 30.1 Donegan (2002), p. 5-15.
  31. ↑ Johnson and Price (2008), pp. 12-217–12-218.
  32. ↑ Bryan (2002), pp. 3-325–3-326.
  33. ↑ Comly (2008), pp. 11-42–11-43.
  34. ↑ Granito (2008), p. 12-7.
  35. ↑ Granito (2008), p. 12-3.
  36. ↑ National Research Council of Canada et al. (2005), p. 1.9-5.
  37. ↑ National Research Council of Canada et al. (2005), p. 1.9-2.
  38. ↑ Australian Building Codes Board (2022), p. 15.
  39. ↑ Australian Building Codes Board (2020a), Data Sheet B1, p. 19.

References

  • Acomb, D. J., & LeBoeuf, R. M. (2008). Fire rescue stations and fire service training centers. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall, Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 12-233–12-251). National Fire Protection Association.
  • Australian Building Codes Board. (2020a). Data sheets: Fire Safety Verification Method (Handbook annex, Print version 1.1).
  • Australian Building Codes Board. (2022). Fire Safety Verification Method Standard 2022.
  • Brodoff, M. (2008). Liability of fire service organizations for negligent fire fighting. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall, Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 12-99–12-106). National Fire Protection Association.
  • Bryan, J. L. (2002). Behavioral response to fire and smoke. In P. J. DiNenno, D. Drysdale, C. L. Beyler, W. D. Walton, R. L. P. Custer, J. R. Hall Jr., & J. M. Watts Jr. (Eds.), SFPE handbook of fire protection engineering (3rd ed., pp. 3-315–3-341). National Fire Protection Association; Society of Fire Protection Engineers.
  • Comly, A. M., Jr. (2008). Building and site planning for fire safety. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall, Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 11-39–11-45). National Fire Protection Association.
  • Donegan, H. A. (2002). Decision analysis. In P. J. DiNenno, D. Drysdale, C. L. Beyler, W. D. Walton, R. L. P. Custer, J. R. Hall Jr., & J. M. Watts Jr. (Eds.), SFPE handbook of fire protection engineering (3rd ed., pp. 5-8–5-23). National Fire Protection Association; Society of Fire Protection Engineers.
  • Granito, J. A. (2008). Planning for public fire-rescue protection. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall, Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 12-3–12-22). National Fire Protection Association.
  • Hall, J. R., Jr., & Cote, A. E. (2008). An overview of the fire problem and fire protection. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall, Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 3-3–3-30). National Fire Protection Association.
  • Johnson, R., & Price, M. (2008). GIS for fire station locations and response protocols. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall, Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 12-215–12-231). National Fire Protection Association.
  • Krakeel, J. J. (2008). Emergency medical services and the fire department. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall, Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 13-145–13-161). National Fire Protection Association.
  • National Research Council of Canada, International Code Council, Department of Building and Housing, & Australian Building Codes Board. (2005). International fire engineering guidelines (2005 ed.). Australian Building Codes Board.
  • Phillips, W. G. B. (2002). Computer simulation for fire protection engineering (D. K. Beller & R. F. Fahy, Rev.). In P. J. DiNenno, D. Drysdale, C. L. Beyler, W. D. Walton, R. L. P. Custer, J. R. Hall Jr., & J. M. Watts Jr. (Eds.), SFPE handbook of fire protection engineering (3rd ed., pp. 5-112–5-124). National Fire Protection Association; Society of Fire Protection Engineers.
  • Ramachandran, G. (2002b). Measuring fire consequences in economic terms (J. R. Hall Jr., Rev.). In P. J. DiNenno, D. Drysdale, C. L. Beyler, W. D. Walton, R. L. P. Custer, J. R. Hall Jr., & J. M. Watts Jr. (Eds.), SFPE handbook of fire protection engineering (3rd ed., pp. 5-79–5-92). National Fire Protection Association; Society of Fire Protection Engineers.