Skip to content
From Fire Safety Academy Wiki
Peter (talk | contribs)
New FSE wiki article: Pesticide fire hazards (written by Claude Opus 5.5)
 
Linda (talk | contribs)
Remove bibliographic source lines from image captions and descriptions
 
(2 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 17: Line 17:
Layers of some pesticide dusts ignite at 120 to 180 °C. The handbook chapter on electrical systems lists them in a table of Group G dusts. The minimum layer ignition temperatures given there are 180 °C for Dithane, 150 °C for Ferban, 140 °C for Sevin and 120 °C for Manganese vancide.<ref name="Mi-8-167">Milatovich (2008), pp. 8-167–8-168.</ref> Fumigants are a further case: some are water-reactive, which limits the use of water on them.<ref name="Wh-6-242">Whitford (2008), p. 6-242.</ref> Aerosol packaging is also used for pesticides.<ref name="Fr-6-257">Fredrickson (2008), p. 6-257.</ref>
Layers of some pesticide dusts ignite at 120 to 180 °C. The handbook chapter on electrical systems lists them in a table of Group G dusts. The minimum layer ignition temperatures given there are 180 °C for Dithane, 150 °C for Ferban, 140 °C for Sevin and 120 °C for Manganese vancide.<ref name="Mi-8-167">Milatovich (2008), pp. 8-167–8-168.</ref> Fumigants are a further case: some are water-reactive, which limits the use of water on them.<ref name="Wh-6-242">Whitford (2008), p. 6-242.</ref> Aerosol packaging is also used for pesticides.<ref name="Fr-6-257">Fredrickson (2008), p. 6-257.</ref>


Laboratory measurements show that the pesticide compounds tested release little heat but much smoke. Tewarson lists heats of combustion and product yields for five pesticides, measured in the ASTM E2058 fire propagation apparatus under well-ventilated conditions.<ref name="Tw-3-111">Tewarson (2002), pp. 3-111 and 3-115.</ref> The net heat of complete combustion is the heat released if all fuel burned completely. The chemical heat of combustion is the heat actually released per gram burned. Their ratio is the combustion efficiency, and the yield of a product is the mass formed per gram of fuel.<ref name="Tw-3-102">Tewarson (2002), p. 3-102.</ref>
In Tewarson's laboratory data, five pesticides released less heat than heptane; three of the four with measured smoke yields produced at least four times as much smoke per gram. Tewarson lists heats of combustion and product yields for five pesticides, measured in the ASTM E2058 fire propagation apparatus under well-ventilated conditions.<ref name="Tw-3-111">Tewarson (2002), pp. 3-111 and 3-115.</ref> The net heat of complete combustion is the heat released if all fuel burned completely. The chemical heat of combustion is the heat actually released per gram burned. Their ratio is the combustion efficiency, and the yield of a product is the mass formed per gram of fuel.<ref name="Tw-3-102">Tewarson (2002), p. 3-102.</ref>


{| class="wikitable"
{| class="wikitable"
Line 35: Line 35:
| Heptane (for comparison) || 44.6 || 41.2 || 0.92 || 0.010 || 0.037
| Heptane (for comparison) || 44.6 || 41.2 || 0.92 || 0.010 || 0.037
|}
|}
The combustion efficiencies in this table were calculated from Tewarson's heats of combustion; a dash means that the value was not measured or is below 0.001.<ref name="Tw-3-111" /> The chemical heat of combustion of these pesticides is only 9 to 34 % of that of heptane. Their smoke yields are up to 7.8 times higher, and the carbon monoxide yields of three of them are about seven times higher. For 2,4-D acid and Folpel the combustion efficiency is about 0.4. Tewarson notes, for a polymethylmethacrylate example, that combustion becomes unstable and flames go out at efficiencies of about 0.40.<ref name="Tw-3-102-103">Tewarson (2002), pp. 3-102–3-103.</ref> By these measures, the compounds burn with low efficiency and form much smoke and carbon monoxide per gram. In a real store, flammable solvents, combustible packaging and combustible construction add to the fire load, and the handbook lists them among the factors for planning the fire-fighting response.<ref name="Wh-6-244" />
The combustion efficiencies in this table were calculated from Tewarson's heats of combustion; a dash means that the value was not measured or is below 0.001.<ref name="Tw-3-111" /> The chemical heat of combustion of these pesticides is only 9 to 34 % of that of heptane. Their smoke yields are up to 7.8 times higher, and the carbon monoxide yields of three of them are about seven times higher. For 2,4-D acid and Folpel the combustion efficiency is about 0.4. Tewarson notes, for a polymethylmethacrylate example, that combustion becomes unstable and flames go out at efficiencies of about 0.40.<ref name="Tw-3-102-103">Tewarson (2002), pp. 3-102–3-103.</ref> The measured compounds vary substantially: several show low combustion efficiency or high smoke and carbon monoxide yields relative to heptane. In a real store, flammable solvents, combustible packaging and combustible construction add to the fire load, and the handbook lists them among the factors for planning the fire-fighting response.<ref name="Wh-6-244" />
[[File:fse-pesticide-fire-hazards-v1.svg|thumb|upright=1.5|alt=Two charts compare five pesticides with heptane: less heat per gram, varied smoke yields and one missing value.|Chemical heat of combustion (left) and smoke yield (right) of five pesticides compared with heptane, measured in well-ventilated fires.]]


== Toxic smoke and contaminated runoff ==
== Toxic smoke and contaminated runoff ==
Golinveaux stresses that special attention must be given to the hazard to people, in addition to the combustibility of the commodity.<ref name="Go-16-89" /> Products of combustion may be a significant health hazard to fire fighters and to people on neighbouring properties.<ref name="Wh-6-236" /> Information on the combined effects of a fire, or of a release of a mixture of pesticides, is not available from any source.<ref name="Wh-6-238">Whitford (2008), p. 6-238.</ref> The handbook concludes that this lack of information should make responders consider their initial approach, their protective equipment and a possible evacuation in great detail. The broader subject of harmful fire effluents is described in [[fire toxicity]].
Golinveaux stresses that special attention must be given to the hazard to people, in addition to the combustibility of the commodity.<ref name="Go-16-89" /> Products of combustion may be a significant health hazard to fire fighters and to people on neighbouring properties.<ref name="Wh-6-236" /> Whitford (2008) reported that no source then described the combined effects of a fire or release involving a mixture of pesticides.<ref name="Wh-6-238">Whitford (2008), p. 6-238.</ref> The handbook concludes that this lack of information should make responders consider their initial approach, their protective equipment and a possible evacuation in great detail. The broader subject of harmful fire effluents is described in [[fire toxicity]].
 
The extreme case of a toxic release from a pesticide plant is Bhopal, India. On 3 December 1984, a pesticide plant explosion there released chemical fumes that killed 3,849 people, which places it sixth on the handbook's list of the deadliest fires and explosions in the world.<ref name="HC-3-11">Hall and Cote (2008), p. 3-11.</ref> Pesticides are also chemically related to some chemical weapons. Most nerve agents were discovered shortly before or during the Second World War, are related to organophosphorus insecticides and act in a similar way to many pesticides.<ref name="MG-1-113">Meacham and Galioto (2008), p. 1-113.</ref>


Water used on a pesticide fire picks up the chemicals. When water is applied to such fires, some fuel is carried off with the steam, some water is absorbed by the fuel and some fuel leaves with the runoff water.<ref name="Fk-17-43">Frank (2008), p. 17-43.</ref> Contaminated runoff can kill large numbers of fish and other aquatic animals or severely contaminate a drinking water supply.<ref name="Wh-6-242" /> The fire-fighting water itself may become a [[hazardous waste]]. In November 1986, a fire at a warehouse for agricultural chemicals on the Rhine in Basel, Switzerland, produced contaminated water that caused a massive fish kill. The pollution spread as far as Germany and the Netherlands.<ref name="Se-7-65" />
Water used on a pesticide fire picks up the chemicals. When water is applied to such fires, some fuel is carried off with the steam, some water is absorbed by the fuel and some fuel leaves with the runoff water.<ref name="Fk-17-43">Frank (2008), p. 17-43.</ref> Contaminated runoff can kill large numbers of fish and other aquatic animals or severely contaminate a drinking water supply.<ref name="Wh-6-242" /> The fire-fighting water itself may become a [[hazardous waste]]. In November 1986, a fire at a warehouse for agricultural chemicals on the Rhine in Basel, Switzerland, produced contaminated water that caused a massive fish kill. The pollution spread as far as Germany and the Netherlands.<ref name="Se-7-65" />
[[File:fse-pesticide-fire-hazards-v2.svg|thumb|upright=1.5|alt=Cross-section of a burning pesticide store with a smoke plume drifting to houses and fire water flowing towards a drain and a river.|Pathways of harm in a pesticide fire: toxic smoke downwind, contaminated fire water to drains and surface water, and exposure of fire fighters.]]


The handbook chapter on extinguishment theory describes the resulting dilemma. Where water is the only practical agent, the alternatives may be to use as little water as possible or to let the building burn.<ref name="YN-2-91">Yu and Newman (2008), p. 2-91.</ref> Letting it burn produces air pollution downwind if the fire does not completely destroy the toxic chemicals. The same trade-off appears in waste handling. If a waste mixture of a flammable solvent and a toxic pesticide is incinerated, the pesticide or its toxic combustion products may be released to the atmosphere.<ref name="Se-7-62">Severson (2008), p. 7-62.</ref>
The handbook chapter on extinguishment theory describes the resulting dilemma. Where water is the only practical agent, the alternatives may be to use as little water as possible or to let the building burn.<ref name="YN-2-91">Yu and Newman (2008), p. 2-91.</ref> Letting it burn produces air pollution downwind if the fire does not completely destroy the toxic chemicals. The same trade-off appears in waste handling. If a waste mixture of a flammable solvent and a toxic pesticide is incinerated, the pesticide or its toxic combustion products may be released to the atmosphere.<ref name="Se-7-62">Severson (2008), p. 7-62.</ref>
Line 50: Line 50:


{| class="wikitable"
{| class="wikitable"
|+ EPA toxicity categories for pesticide labels<ref name="Wh-6-238" />
|+ EPA pesticide toxicity categories as reproduced in the 2008 handbook<ref name="Wh-6-238" />
! Category and signal word !! Oral LD50 !! Inhalation LD50 !! Dermal LD50
! Category and signal word !! Oral LD50 !! Inhalation value (mg/L) !! Dermal LD50
|-
|-
| 1: Danger (with "Poison" and skull and crossbones if based on oral, inhalation or dermal toxicity) || up to 50 mg/kg || up to 0.2 mg/L || up to 200 mg/kg
| 1: Danger (with "Poison" and skull and crossbones if based on oral, inhalation or dermal toxicity) || up to 50 mg/kg || up to 0.2 mg/L || up to 200 mg/kg
Line 60: Line 60:
|}
|}


The label has clear limits for fire fighters. It does not usually address the fire or reactivity hazards of the whole formulation, and it gives only general advice beyond small spills.<ref name="Wh-6-237" /> Inert ingredients are not named on the label or on the material [[safety data sheet]] (MSDS), although some data sheets list their hazards.<ref name="Wh-6-237" /> The handbook nevertheless calls the MSDS the key source of information in a pesticide emergency, partly because its emergency telephone number connects responders with experts.<ref name="Wh-6-238" /><ref name="Wh-6-240">Whitford (2008), p. 6-240.</ref> Copies should be kept off site and given to the fire department and local hospitals. An up-to-date site plan should show the classes and approximate quantities of products in each storage area.<ref name="Wh-6-236" />
The handbook labels the inhalation column “LD50” even though it reports concentrations in mg/L; the table above uses a neutral heading. The label has clear limits for fire fighters. It does not usually address the fire or reactivity hazards of the whole formulation, and it gives only general advice beyond small spills.<ref name="Wh-6-237" /> Whitford (2008) reported that inert ingredients were not named on labels or on material [[safety data sheet]]s (MSDSs), although some data sheets listed their hazards.<ref name="Wh-6-237" />  
 
The handbook nevertheless calls the MSDS the key source of information in a pesticide emergency, partly because its emergency telephone number connects responders with experts.<ref name="Wh-6-238" /><ref name="Wh-6-240">Whitford (2008), p. 6-240.</ref> Copies should be kept off site and given to the fire department and local hospitals. An up-to-date site plan should show the classes and approximate quantities of products in each storage area.<ref name="Wh-6-236" />


Most pesticides are not required to carry transport placards and are not listed in the Emergency Response Guidebook.<ref name="Wh-6-240" /> Fixed hazard signs are therefore important. Structures and tanks that store hazardous materials should carry signs in the [[NFPA 704]] system, coordinated with the local fire service. Where water must not be used, operators may post the W signal of NFPA 704, but only after consulting the local authorities and insurers.<ref name="Wh-6-242" /> Under the federal [[community right-to-know]] rules (SARA Title III and the Emergency Planning and Community Right-to-Know Act), a facility that stores a listed pesticide above its reportable quantity must report to the local fire department. It must also report to the state emergency response commission and the local emergency planning committee.<ref name="Wh-6-243">Whitford (2008), p. 6-243.</ref>
The 2008 handbook reported that most pesticides were not required to carry transport placards and were not listed in the Emergency Response Guidebook.<ref name="Wh-6-240" /> Fixed hazard signs are therefore important. Structures and tanks that store hazardous materials should carry signs in the [[NFPA 704]] system, coordinated with the local fire service. Where water must not be used, operators may post the W signal of NFPA 704, but only after consulting the local authorities and insurers.<ref name="Wh-6-242" /> Under the federal [[community right-to-know]] rules (SARA Title III and the Emergency Planning and Community Right-to-Know Act), a facility that stores a listed pesticide above its reportable quantity must report to the local fire department. It must also report to the state emergency response commission and the local emergency planning committee.<ref name="Wh-6-243">Whitford (2008), p. 6-243.</ref>


== Storage and facility design ==
== Storage and facility design ==
Most state and federal laws in the United States do not prescribe how pesticides must be stored, apart from rules on diking large volumes in warehouses and large agricultural facilities.<ref name="Wh-6-238" /> NFPA 434, NFPA 30 and NFPA 13 give guidance on aisle space in storage areas. A list of NFPA codes in NUREG-1805 (2004) gives NFPA 434 in its 2002 edition.<ref name="IS-E7">Iqbal and Salley (2004), p. E-7.</ref> Flammable and restricted-use pesticides should be stored and displayed separately from other products. Incompatible materials should be segregated, with the DOT tables for joint shipment in cargo vans as a first guide.<ref name="Wh-6-238" />
Whitford (2008) reported that most United States state and federal laws then did not prescribe how pesticides were stored, apart from rules on diking large volumes in warehouses and large agricultural facilities.<ref name="Wh-6-238" /> NFPA 434, NFPA 30 and NFPA 13 give guidance on aisle space in storage areas. A list of NFPA codes in NUREG-1805 (2004) gives NFPA 434 in its 2002 edition.<ref name="IS-E7">Iqbal and Salley (2004), p. E-7.</ref> Flammable and restricted-use pesticides should be stored and displayed separately from other products. Incompatible materials should be segregated, with the DOT tables for joint shipment in cargo vans as a first guide.<ref name="Wh-6-238" />


Site selection is treated as perhaps the most important decision. A new pesticide store should be placed as far as possible from schools, hospitals, retirement homes, places of assembly and day care centres, and preferably where floods, earthquakes and storms are unlikely.<ref name="Wh-6-238" /><ref name="Wh-6-239">Whitford (2008), p. 6-239.</ref> Several entry points allow fire crews a safe approach from upwind. Products with very different hazards may need separate rooms or buildings. Nonflammable materials with an NFPA 704 health hazard rating of 3 or 4 should also be isolated, although small businesses often lack the space to segregate.<ref name="Wh-6-239" />
Site selection is treated as perhaps the most important decision. A new pesticide store should be placed as far as possible from schools, hospitals, retirement homes, places of assembly and day care centres, and preferably where floods, earthquakes and storms are unlikely.<ref name="Wh-6-238" /><ref name="Wh-6-239">Whitford (2008), p. 6-239.</ref> Several entry points allow fire crews a safe approach from upwind. Products with very different hazards may need separate rooms or buildings. Nonflammable materials with an NFPA 704 health hazard rating of 3 or 4 should also be isolated, although small businesses often lack the space to segregate.<ref name="Wh-6-239" />


For buildings smaller than warehouses, the handbook suggests single-storey construction without basements and noncombustible materials.<ref name="Wh-6-239" /> Interior fire walls should have a 4-hour rating, extend 0.9 m (3 ft) above the roofline and be liquid-tight, with ramps or raised sills at openings. The floor should slope to a "blind" drain, and all drains leaving the building should be sealed so that spills cannot reach the sewer.<ref name="Wh-6-239" /> Ideally a pesticide facility has full sprinkler coverage, enough extinguishers for a first response by staff, and smoke and heat detection.<ref name="Wh-6-240" /> Detection should warn staff of a small fire before the sprinklers operate.<ref name="Wh-6-241">Whitford (2008), p. 6-241.</ref>
For buildings smaller than warehouses, the handbook suggests single-storey construction without basements and noncombustible materials.<ref name="Wh-6-239" /> Interior fire walls should have a 4-hour rating, extend 0.9 m (3 ft) above the roofline and be liquid-tight, with ramps or raised sills at openings. The floor should slope to a "blind" drain, and all drains leaving the building should be sealed so that spills cannot reach the sewer.<ref name="Wh-6-239" /> Ideally a pesticide facility has full sprinkler coverage, enough extinguishers for a first response by staff, and smoke and heat detection.<ref name="Wh-6-240" /> Detection should warn staff of a small fire before the sprinklers operate.<ref name="Wh-6-241">Whitford (2008), p. 6-241.</ref>
[[File:fse-pesticide-fire-hazards-v4.svg|thumb|upright=1.5|alt=Cut-away of a single-storey store with a fire wall rising above the roof, raised sills at doors and a floor sloping to a sealed drain.|Construction features suggested for small pesticide stores: single storey, noncombustible, 4-hour fire wall extending 0.9 m above the roof, liquid-tight sills and a sloped floor to a blind drain.]]


Fire water and spills must be held on site by a containment system. Its volume should cover a credible worst-case release from a single tank or vessel plus the contaminated water from fire fighting and sprinklers.<ref name="Wh-6-240" /> The authority having jurisdiction decides how much fire water must be contained. Internal containment by curbs and ramps keeps spills under control and out of the rain. Its drawbacks are worker exposure, the risk of a flash fire or vapour explosion from retained chemicals, and harder conditions for fire crews.<ref name="Wh-6-240" /> Such planning also has to allow for the fuels, anhydrous ammonia and other fertilisers that many pesticide stores keep as well.<ref name="Wh-6-242" />
Fire water and spills must be held on site by a containment system. Its volume should cover a credible worst-case release from a single tank or vessel plus the contaminated water from fire fighting and sprinklers.<ref name="Wh-6-240" /> The authority having jurisdiction decides how much fire water must be contained. Internal containment by curbs and ramps keeps spills under control and out of the rain. Its drawbacks are worker exposure, the risk of a flash fire or vapour explosion from retained chemicals, and harder conditions for fire crews.<ref name="Wh-6-240" /> Such planning also has to allow for the fuels, anhydrous ammonia and other fertilisers that many pesticide stores keep as well.<ref name="Wh-6-242" />
Line 77: Line 80:


The most important planning decision is whether a fire will be fought or allowed to burn. The handbook lists ten factors for this choice: flammable products, combustible packaging, the stage of the fire on arrival and combustible construction.<ref name="Wh-6-244" /> It adds the toxicity of the products, the expected toxicity of the smoke, the direction of the smoke, the surrounding population, the effect of runoff and the location of drinking water sources. Many commercial and farm insurance policies exclude pollution remediation, but the fire service remains responsible for judging whether letting the fire burn protects the public better.<ref name="Wh-6-244" /> The handbook illustrates this with a barn that was allowed to burn because pesticides were stored inside. General guidance on hazardous materials response likewise distinguishes offensive, defensive and nonintervention options.<ref name="CJW-13-137">C. J. Wright (2008a), p. 13-137.</ref>
The most important planning decision is whether a fire will be fought or allowed to burn. The handbook lists ten factors for this choice: flammable products, combustible packaging, the stage of the fire on arrival and combustible construction.<ref name="Wh-6-244" /> It adds the toxicity of the products, the expected toxicity of the smoke, the direction of the smoke, the surrounding population, the effect of runoff and the location of drinking water sources. Many commercial and farm insurance policies exclude pollution remediation, but the fire service remains responsible for judging whether letting the fire burn protects the public better.<ref name="Wh-6-244" /> The handbook illustrates this with a barn that was allowed to burn because pesticides were stored inside. General guidance on hazardous materials response likewise distinguishes offensive, defensive and nonintervention options.<ref name="CJW-13-137">C. J. Wright (2008a), p. 13-137.</ref>
[[File:fse-pesticide-fire-hazards-v3.svg|thumb|upright=1.5|alt=Decision chart: ten factors grouped as fire, toxicity and surroundings lead to two outcomes, fight the fire or let it burn.|Factors for deciding in advance whether a fire in a pesticide store is fought or allowed to burn, as listed in the 2008 Fire Protection Handbook.]]


In the United States, facilities may be required to prepare emergency plans under SARA Title III and other rules. Guidance is given in NFPA 434 and NFPA 471, and responder training follows the federal HAZWOPER rule (29 CFR 1910.120) and NFPA 472.<ref name="Wh-6-243" /> Plans should be exercised and reviewed every year with the local fire department, and the emergency telephone list should be checked at least twice a year.<ref name="Wh-6-244" /> Fire crews are encouraged to visit pesticide sites regularly so that they know the layout, the quantities stored and the times of peak inventory.<ref name="Wh-6-238" /> Specialist support is available through hazardous materials networks, which include a Pesticide Safety Team Network.<ref name="CJW-13-131">C. J. Wright (2008a), p. 13-131.</ref>
In the United States, facilities may be required to prepare emergency plans under SARA Title III and other rules. Guidance is given in NFPA 434 and NFPA 471, and responder training follows the federal HAZWOPER rule (29 CFR 1910.120) and NFPA 472.<ref name="Wh-6-243" /> Plans should be exercised and reviewed every year with the local fire department, and the emergency telephone list should be checked at least twice a year.<ref name="Wh-6-244" /> Fire crews are encouraged to visit pesticide sites regularly so that they know the layout, the quantities stored and the times of peak inventory.<ref name="Wh-6-238" /> Specialist support is available through hazardous materials networks, which include a Pesticide Safety Team Network.<ref name="CJW-13-131">C. J. Wright (2008a), p. 13-131.</ref>


== Limits of knowledge ==
== Limits of knowledge ==
Pesticide fire hazards are hard to predict because the products are so varied. Each product has to be reviewed individually for its flammability and health risks.<ref name="Wh-6-236" /> The hazards of the inert ingredients must be judged case by case during a release, because they are usually not disclosed.<ref name="Wh-6-237" /> When several products burn together, the data sheets for single products are of little use, and no source describes the combined effects.<ref name="Wh-6-236" /><ref name="Wh-6-238" />
Pesticide fire hazards are hard to predict because the products are so varied. Each product has to be reviewed individually for its flammability and health risks.<ref name="Wh-6-236" /> The hazards of the inert ingredients must be judged case by case during a release, because they are usually not disclosed.<ref name="Wh-6-237" /> When several products burn together, data sheets for single products have limited use; Whitford (2008) reported no source then describing the combined effects.<ref name="Wh-6-236" /><ref name="Wh-6-238" />


The laboratory data are also limited. Tewarson's values were measured on individual compounds in a laboratory apparatus under well-ventilated conditions, and only five pesticides are listed.<ref name="Tw-3-111" /> They do not describe a burning store with solvents, packaging and mixed products. Most of the guidance summarised here reflects United States practice around 2007, as described by the handbook. Much of it is presented as suggestions, since very few jurisdictions regulate the design of pesticide stores beyond the building codes.<ref name="Wh-6-239" />
The laboratory data are also limited. Tewarson's values were measured on individual compounds in a laboratory apparatus under well-ventilated conditions, and only five pesticides are listed.<ref name="Tw-3-111" /> They do not describe a burning store with solvents, packaging and mixed products. Most of the guidance summarised here reflects United States practice around 2007, as described by the handbook. Much of it is presented as suggestions, since very few jurisdictions regulate the design of pesticide stores beyond the building codes.<ref name="Wh-6-239" />
Line 100: Line 104:
* Golinveaux, J. E. (2008). Sprinkler systems for storage facilities. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), ''Fire protection handbook'' (20th ed., pp. 16-71–16-89). National Fire Protection Association.
* Golinveaux, J. E. (2008). Sprinkler systems for storage facilities. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), ''Fire protection handbook'' (20th ed., pp. 16-71–16-89). National Fire Protection Association.
* Granito, J. A. (2008). Planning for public fire-rescue protection. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), ''Fire protection handbook'' (20th ed., pp. 12-3–12-22). National Fire Protection Association.
* Granito, J. A. (2008). Planning for public fire-rescue protection. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), ''Fire protection handbook'' (20th ed., pp. 12-3–12-22). National Fire Protection Association.
* Hall, J. R., Jr., & Cote, A. E. (2008). An overview of the fire problem and fire protection. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), ''Fire protection handbook'' (20th ed., pp. 3-3–3-30). National Fire Protection Association.
* Iqbal, N., & Salley, M. H. (2004). ''Fire Dynamics Tools (FDTs): Quantitative fire hazard analysis methods for the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Fire Protection Inspection Program'' (NUREG-1805). U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation.
* Iqbal, N., & Salley, M. H. (2004). ''Fire Dynamics Tools (FDTs): Quantitative fire hazard analysis methods for the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Fire Protection Inspection Program'' (NUREG-1805). U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation.
* Meacham, B. J., & Galioto, C. (2008). Protecting against extreme events. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), ''Fire protection handbook'' (20th ed., pp. 1-109–1-136). National Fire Protection Association.
* Milatovich, R. M. (2008). Electrical systems and appliances. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), ''Fire protection handbook'' (20th ed., pp. 8-127–8-173). National Fire Protection Association.
* Milatovich, R. M. (2008). Electrical systems and appliances. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), ''Fire protection handbook'' (20th ed., pp. 8-127–8-173). National Fire Protection Association.
* Moore, J. (2008). Storage occupancies. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), ''Fire protection handbook'' (20th ed., pp. 20-157–20-178). National Fire Protection Association.
* Moore, J. (2008). Storage occupancies. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), ''Fire protection handbook'' (20th ed., pp. 20-157–20-178). National Fire Protection Association.

Latest revision as of 08:27, 8 November 2026

Pesticide fire hazards are the dangers that arise when pesticides are involved in a fire: ignition and burning of the products and their solvents, toxic smoke, and contaminated fire-fighting water. A pesticide is a chemical or mixture of chemicals used to repel or combat animal or plant pests, such as insects, rodents, weeds, plant diseases and microorganisms.[1] The products are stored as solutions in flammable or combustible liquids, as powders or granules in combustible packages, and as compressed gases for fumigation.[2]

In a fire, pesticides can harm and even kill people who breathe their combustion products. Water runoff from fire fighting can pollute soil and water, as the 1986 fire at an agricultural chemicals warehouse in Basel showed.[2][3] Data for single products tell little about a fire involving many products.[4] Emergency plans should therefore state in advance under which scenarios such a fire will be fought or allowed to burn.[5] The NFPA Fire Protection Handbook (2008 edition) describes United States practice for storage, labelling and emergency planning. In that practice, NFPA 434, Code for the Storage of Pesticides, gives general requirements for inside and outside storage.[2]

Definition and where pesticides are found

The handbook uses the definition of the United States Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act (FIFRA). Under it, household germicides and plant growth regulators are also pesticides.[1] The general term covers groups named after the pests they control: insecticides control insects, fungicides plant diseases, bactericides bacteria, herbicides weeds and rodenticides mice and rats. FIFRA, enacted in 1972 and amended in 1988, requires toxicity testing and registration of pesticides and sets tolerance levels for residues in food.[6]

There are thousands of different pesticide products, and they differ widely in chemical composition, formulation and hazard.[1] Large volumes are stored at manufacturing sites, farm supply stores, distribution warehouses, public warehouses and agricultural chemical warehouses. Smaller amounts are found at nurseries, supermarkets, hardware stores and other shops, and at lawn care, pest control and farm businesses. State and county agencies, such as highway departments and mosquito control units, also keep stocks.[1] Rural properties may hold extensive supplies of fertiliser and pesticides, and golf courses commonly store significant quantities of both.[7][8] Pesticides are shipped in solid and liquid form and, in a few cases, as gases.[1]

Fire protection guidance has traditionally focused on warehouses, but the handbook stresses that the same products appear in many other places.[1] In storage occupancies, pesticides are listed among the high-hazard materials, together with flammable liquids, rubber tyres and reactive chemicals. Such materials can sometimes be segregated from other storage, and NFPA 13 gives specific sprinkler requirements for areas that contain them.[9] The general hazards of large stores are treated in warehouse fire.

How pesticides burn

The hazard of a pesticide product can come from its active ingredients, from the inert ingredients that act as the carrier, or from both. The carrier may be a flammable or combustible liquid solvent or a flammable gas.[4] Taken together, a formulation can be corrosive, reactive, flammable or combustible, or relatively harmless.[4] Most pesticide products stored in large volumes are liquids. Some are flammable or combustible liquids under the rules of the United States Department of Transportation (DOT), and their packaging carries the matching transport label.[4] A release of such a liquid can range from a manageable spill fire to an almost explosive ignition of vapours in a confined area.[4]

Solid pesticides are usually stored and handled as granules, dusts and powders.[10] Combustible solids can cause a dust explosion when they are dispersed in air. Most solid pesticides, however, are formulations absorbed into an inert material such as clay.

Layers of some pesticide dusts ignite at 120 to 180 °C. The handbook chapter on electrical systems lists them in a table of Group G dusts. The minimum layer ignition temperatures given there are 180 °C for Dithane, 150 °C for Ferban, 140 °C for Sevin and 120 °C for Manganese vancide.[11] Fumigants are a further case: some are water-reactive, which limits the use of water on them.[12] Aerosol packaging is also used for pesticides.[13]

In Tewarson's laboratory data, five pesticides released less heat than heptane; three of the four with measured smoke yields produced at least four times as much smoke per gram. Tewarson lists heats of combustion and product yields for five pesticides, measured in the ASTM E2058 fire propagation apparatus under well-ventilated conditions.[14] The net heat of complete combustion is the heat released if all fuel burned completely. The chemical heat of combustion is the heat actually released per gram burned. Their ratio is the combustion efficiency, and the yield of a product is the mass formed per gram of fuel.[15]

Combustion data for pesticides and heptane in well-ventilated fires[14]
Material Net heat of complete combustion (kJ/g) Chemical heat of combustion (kJ/g) Combustion efficiency CO yield (g/g) Smoke yield (g/g)
2,4-D acid (herbicide) 11.5 4.5 0.39 0.074 0.163
Mancozeb 14.0 9.5 0.68 – –
Folpel 9.1 3.6 0.40 0.072 0.205
Chlorfenvinphos 18.0 7.7 0.43 0.011 0.288
Chlormephos 19.1 13.9 0.73 0.075 0.055
Heptane (for comparison) 44.6 41.2 0.92 0.010 0.037

The combustion efficiencies in this table were calculated from Tewarson's heats of combustion; a dash means that the value was not measured or is below 0.001.[14] The chemical heat of combustion of these pesticides is only 9 to 34 % of that of heptane. Their smoke yields are up to 7.8 times higher, and the carbon monoxide yields of three of them are about seven times higher. For 2,4-D acid and Folpel the combustion efficiency is about 0.4. Tewarson notes, for a polymethylmethacrylate example, that combustion becomes unstable and flames go out at efficiencies of about 0.40.[16] The measured compounds vary substantially: several show low combustion efficiency or high smoke and carbon monoxide yields relative to heptane. In a real store, flammable solvents, combustible packaging and combustible construction add to the fire load, and the handbook lists them among the factors for planning the fire-fighting response.[5]

Two charts compare five pesticides with heptane: less heat per gram, varied smoke yields and one missing value.
Chemical heat of combustion (left) and smoke yield (right) of five pesticides compared with heptane, measured in well-ventilated fires.

Toxic smoke and contaminated runoff

Golinveaux stresses that special attention must be given to the hazard to people, in addition to the combustibility of the commodity.[2] Products of combustion may be a significant health hazard to fire fighters and to people on neighbouring properties.[4] Whitford (2008) reported that no source then described the combined effects of a fire or release involving a mixture of pesticides.[17] The handbook concludes that this lack of information should make responders consider their initial approach, their protective equipment and a possible evacuation in great detail. The broader subject of harmful fire effluents is described in fire toxicity.

Water used on a pesticide fire picks up the chemicals. When water is applied to such fires, some fuel is carried off with the steam, some water is absorbed by the fuel and some fuel leaves with the runoff water.[18] Contaminated runoff can kill large numbers of fish and other aquatic animals or severely contaminate a drinking water supply.[12] The fire-fighting water itself may become a hazardous waste. In November 1986, a fire at a warehouse for agricultural chemicals on the Rhine in Basel, Switzerland, produced contaminated water that caused a massive fish kill. The pollution spread as far as Germany and the Netherlands.[3]

Cross-section of a burning pesticide store with a smoke plume drifting to houses and fire water flowing towards a drain and a river.
Pathways of harm in a pesticide fire: toxic smoke downwind, contaminated fire water to drains and surface water, and exposure of fire fighters.

The handbook chapter on extinguishment theory describes the resulting dilemma. Where water is the only practical agent, the alternatives may be to use as little water as possible or to let the building burn.[19] Letting it burn produces air pollution downwind if the fire does not completely destroy the toxic chemicals. The same trade-off appears in waste handling. If a waste mixture of a flammable solvent and a toxic pesticide is incinerated, the pesticide or its toxic combustion products may be released to the atmosphere.[20]

Labels and hazard information

In the United States, pesticide labels are regulated by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and grouped by acute toxicity to humans.[10] The front panel carries one of three signal words: "Danger", "Warning" or "Caution", in descending order of toxicity. Products that carry additional risks to human health, water or wildlife are restricted-use pesticides, marked with a statement in a box above the brand name.[10] The EPA toxicity categories as given in the handbook are summarised below.

EPA pesticide toxicity categories as reproduced in the 2008 handbook[17]
Category and signal word Oral LD50 Inhalation value (mg/L) Dermal LD50
1: Danger (with "Poison" and skull and crossbones if based on oral, inhalation or dermal toxicity) up to 50 mg/kg up to 0.2 mg/L up to 200 mg/kg
2: Warning 50 to 500 mg/kg 0.2 to 2.0 mg/L 200 to 2,000 mg/kg
3 and 4: Caution above 500 mg/kg above 2.0 mg/L above 2,000 mg/kg

The handbook labels the inhalation column “LD50” even though it reports concentrations in mg/L; the table above uses a neutral heading. The label has clear limits for fire fighters. It does not usually address the fire or reactivity hazards of the whole formulation, and it gives only general advice beyond small spills.[10] Whitford (2008) reported that inert ingredients were not named on labels or on material safety data sheets (MSDSs), although some data sheets listed their hazards.[10]

The handbook nevertheless calls the MSDS the key source of information in a pesticide emergency, partly because its emergency telephone number connects responders with experts.[17][21] Copies should be kept off site and given to the fire department and local hospitals. An up-to-date site plan should show the classes and approximate quantities of products in each storage area.[4]

The 2008 handbook reported that most pesticides were not required to carry transport placards and were not listed in the Emergency Response Guidebook.[21] Fixed hazard signs are therefore important. Structures and tanks that store hazardous materials should carry signs in the NFPA 704 system, coordinated with the local fire service. Where water must not be used, operators may post the W signal of NFPA 704, but only after consulting the local authorities and insurers.[12] Under the federal community right-to-know rules (SARA Title III and the Emergency Planning and Community Right-to-Know Act), a facility that stores a listed pesticide above its reportable quantity must report to the local fire department. It must also report to the state emergency response commission and the local emergency planning committee.[22]

Storage and facility design

Whitford (2008) reported that most United States state and federal laws then did not prescribe how pesticides were stored, apart from rules on diking large volumes in warehouses and large agricultural facilities.[17] NFPA 434, NFPA 30 and NFPA 13 give guidance on aisle space in storage areas. A list of NFPA codes in NUREG-1805 (2004) gives NFPA 434 in its 2002 edition.[23] Flammable and restricted-use pesticides should be stored and displayed separately from other products. Incompatible materials should be segregated, with the DOT tables for joint shipment in cargo vans as a first guide.[17]

Site selection is treated as perhaps the most important decision. A new pesticide store should be placed as far as possible from schools, hospitals, retirement homes, places of assembly and day care centres, and preferably where floods, earthquakes and storms are unlikely.[17][24] Several entry points allow fire crews a safe approach from upwind. Products with very different hazards may need separate rooms or buildings. Nonflammable materials with an NFPA 704 health hazard rating of 3 or 4 should also be isolated, although small businesses often lack the space to segregate.[24]

For buildings smaller than warehouses, the handbook suggests single-storey construction without basements and noncombustible materials.[24] Interior fire walls should have a 4-hour rating, extend 0.9 m (3 ft) above the roofline and be liquid-tight, with ramps or raised sills at openings. The floor should slope to a "blind" drain, and all drains leaving the building should be sealed so that spills cannot reach the sewer.[24] Ideally a pesticide facility has full sprinkler coverage, enough extinguishers for a first response by staff, and smoke and heat detection.[21] Detection should warn staff of a small fire before the sprinklers operate.[25]

Cut-away of a single-storey store with a fire wall rising above the roof, raised sills at doors and a floor sloping to a sealed drain.
Construction features suggested for small pesticide stores: single storey, noncombustible, 4-hour fire wall extending 0.9 m above the roof, liquid-tight sills and a sloped floor to a blind drain.

Fire water and spills must be held on site by a containment system. Its volume should cover a credible worst-case release from a single tank or vessel plus the contaminated water from fire fighting and sprinklers.[21] The authority having jurisdiction decides how much fire water must be contained. Internal containment by curbs and ramps keeps spills under control and out of the rain. Its drawbacks are worker exposure, the risk of a flash fire or vapour explosion from retained chemicals, and harder conditions for fire crews.[21] Such planning also has to allow for the fuels, anhydrous ammonia and other fertilisers that many pesticide stores keep as well.[12]

Fire fighting and emergency planning

A sprinkler chapter of the handbook advises automatic sprinklers for pesticide storage, with provision for collecting and disposing of the runoff.[2] Fire-fighting plans should include protective clothing, respiratory protection, spray nozzles instead of straight streams to reduce runoff, and specialised medical backup. Breaking containers and dispersing the pesticide must be avoided.[2] Because of runoff and the water-reactivity of some fumigants, dry chemical, carbon dioxide or other agents may be suitable, provided they are compatible with the stored products.[12]

The most important planning decision is whether a fire will be fought or allowed to burn. The handbook lists ten factors for this choice: flammable products, combustible packaging, the stage of the fire on arrival and combustible construction.[5] It adds the toxicity of the products, the expected toxicity of the smoke, the direction of the smoke, the surrounding population, the effect of runoff and the location of drinking water sources. Many commercial and farm insurance policies exclude pollution remediation, but the fire service remains responsible for judging whether letting the fire burn protects the public better.[5] The handbook illustrates this with a barn that was allowed to burn because pesticides were stored inside. General guidance on hazardous materials response likewise distinguishes offensive, defensive and nonintervention options.[26]

Decision chart: ten factors grouped as fire, toxicity and surroundings lead to two outcomes, fight the fire or let it burn.
Factors for deciding in advance whether a fire in a pesticide store is fought or allowed to burn, as listed in the 2008 Fire Protection Handbook.

In the United States, facilities may be required to prepare emergency plans under SARA Title III and other rules. Guidance is given in NFPA 434 and NFPA 471, and responder training follows the federal HAZWOPER rule (29 CFR 1910.120) and NFPA 472.[22] Plans should be exercised and reviewed every year with the local fire department, and the emergency telephone list should be checked at least twice a year.[5] Fire crews are encouraged to visit pesticide sites regularly so that they know the layout, the quantities stored and the times of peak inventory.[17] Specialist support is available through hazardous materials networks, which include a Pesticide Safety Team Network.[27]

Limits of knowledge

Pesticide fire hazards are hard to predict because the products are so varied. Each product has to be reviewed individually for its flammability and health risks.[4] The hazards of the inert ingredients must be judged case by case during a release, because they are usually not disclosed.[10] When several products burn together, data sheets for single products have limited use; Whitford (2008) reported no source then describing the combined effects.[4][17]

The laboratory data are also limited. Tewarson's values were measured on individual compounds in a laboratory apparatus under well-ventilated conditions, and only five pesticides are listed.[14] They do not describe a burning store with solvents, packaging and mixed products. Most of the guidance summarised here reflects United States practice around 2007, as described by the handbook. Much of it is presented as suggestions, since very few jurisdictions regulate the design of pesticide stores beyond the building codes.[24]

See also

Notes

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 Whitford (2008), p. 6-233.
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 Golinveaux (2008), p. 16-89.
  3. ↑ 3.0 3.1 Severson (2008), p. 7-65.
  4. ↑ 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6 4.7 4.8 Whitford (2008), p. 6-236.
  5. ↑ 5.0 5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 Whitford (2008), p. 6-244.
  6. ↑ Severson (2008), p. 7-59.
  7. ↑ Granito (2008), p. 12-10.
  8. ↑ Serapiglia (2008), p. 12-291.
  9. ↑ J. Moore (2008), pp. 20-158–20-160.
  10. ↑ 10.0 10.1 10.2 10.3 10.4 10.5 Whitford (2008), p. 6-237.
  11. ↑ Milatovich (2008), pp. 8-167–8-168.
  12. ↑ 12.0 12.1 12.2 12.3 12.4 Whitford (2008), p. 6-242.
  13. ↑ Fredrickson (2008), p. 6-257.
  14. ↑ 14.0 14.1 14.2 14.3 Tewarson (2002), pp. 3-111 and 3-115.
  15. ↑ Tewarson (2002), p. 3-102.
  16. ↑ Tewarson (2002), pp. 3-102–3-103.
  17. ↑ 17.0 17.1 17.2 17.3 17.4 17.5 17.6 17.7 Whitford (2008), p. 6-238.
  18. ↑ Frank (2008), p. 17-43.
  19. ↑ Yu and Newman (2008), p. 2-91.
  20. ↑ Severson (2008), p. 7-62.
  21. ↑ 21.0 21.1 21.2 21.3 21.4 Whitford (2008), p. 6-240.
  22. ↑ 22.0 22.1 Whitford (2008), p. 6-243.
  23. ↑ Iqbal and Salley (2004), p. E-7.
  24. ↑ 24.0 24.1 24.2 24.3 24.4 Whitford (2008), p. 6-239.
  25. ↑ Whitford (2008), p. 6-241.
  26. ↑ C. J. Wright (2008a), p. 13-137.
  27. ↑ C. J. Wright (2008a), p. 13-131.

References

  • Frank, J. A. (2008). Characteristics and hazards of water and water additives for fire suppression. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 17-31–17-43). National Fire Protection Association.
  • Fredrickson, D. L. (2008). Manufacture and storage of aerosol products. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 6-257–6-267). National Fire Protection Association.
  • Golinveaux, J. E. (2008). Sprinkler systems for storage facilities. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 16-71–16-89). National Fire Protection Association.
  • Granito, J. A. (2008). Planning for public fire-rescue protection. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 12-3–12-22). National Fire Protection Association.
  • Iqbal, N., & Salley, M. H. (2004). Fire Dynamics Tools (FDTs): Quantitative fire hazard analysis methods for the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Fire Protection Inspection Program (NUREG-1805). U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation.
  • Milatovich, R. M. (2008). Electrical systems and appliances. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 8-127–8-173). National Fire Protection Association.
  • Moore, J. (2008). Storage occupancies. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 20-157–20-178). National Fire Protection Association.
  • Serapiglia, M. J. (2008). Pre-Incident planning for industrial and municipal emergency response. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 12-289–12-298). National Fire Protection Association.
  • Severson, P. R. (2008). Hazardous waste control. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 7-57–7-69). National Fire Protection Association.
  • Tewarson, A. (2002). Generation of heat and chemical compounds in fires. In P. J. DiNenno, D. Drysdale, C. L. Beyler, W. D. Walton, R. L. P. Custer, J. R. Hall Jr., & J. M. Watts Jr. (Eds.), SFPE handbook of fire protection engineering (3rd ed., pp. 3-82–3-161). National Fire Protection Association; Society of Fire Protection Engineers.
  • Whitford, F. (2008). Pesticides in the workplace. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 6-233–6-245). National Fire Protection Association.
  • Wright, C. J. (2008a). Managing the response to hazardous material incidents. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 13-117–13-144). National Fire Protection Association.
  • Yu, H.-Z., & Newman, J. S. (2008). Theory of fire extinguishment. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 2-79–2-92). National Fire Protection Association.