New FSE wiki article: Spark detection and extinguishing system (written by Claude Opus 5.5) |
Add SVG figures fse-spark-detection-and-extinguishing-system-v1.svg, fse-spark-detection-and-extinguishing-system-v2.svg, fse-spark-detection-and-extinguishing-system-v3.svg (list-2 visual plan) |
||
| (One intermediate revision by one other user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
A '''spark detection and extinguishing system''' is a fire protection system that detects burning sparks and embers in a duct by their radiant energy and quenches them with a short water spray downstream.<ref name="CH-9-23">Cholin (2008d), p. 9-23.</ref> It is typically fitted to the ducts of a [[Pneumatic conveying system]] that carries wood dust or other combustible particles to a [[Dust collector]], silo or bin.<ref name="CH-9-6">Cholin (2008d), p. 9-6.</ref><ref name="DU-14-25">Dungan (2008a), p. 14-25.</ref> Its purpose is to stop a small burning particle from reaching a place where it could start a large fire or a [[Dust explosion]].<ref name="DU-14-25" /> | A '''spark detection and extinguishing system''' is a fire protection system that detects burning sparks and embers in a duct by their radiant energy and quenches them with a short water spray downstream.<ref name="CH-9-23">Cholin (2008d), p. 9-23.</ref> It is typically fitted to the ducts of a [[Pneumatic conveying system]] that carries wood dust or other combustible particles to a [[Dust collector]], silo or bin.<ref name="CH-9-6">Cholin (2008d), p. 9-6.</ref><ref name="DU-14-25">Dungan (2008a), p. 14-25.</ref> Its purpose is to stop a small burning particle from reaching a place where it could start a large fire or a [[Dust explosion]].<ref name="DU-14-25" /> | ||
A typical system has three parts listed together as one system: spark/ember detectors on the duct, a water spray extinguishing unit downstream of them, and a control panel.<ref name="CH-9-23" /> The system works only where the dust concentration in the duct is below the minimum explosible concentration (MEC). It is a fire-extinguishing system, not an explosion protection system.<ref name="CH-9-24">Cholin (2008d), p. 9-24.</ref><ref name="CH-9-25">Cholin (2008d), p. 9-25.</ref> The ''Fire Protection Handbook'' (2008) describes its use in US woodworking plants under NFPA 664, NFPA 69 and NFPA 72 as they stood around 2007–2008.<ref name="CH-9-15">Cholin (2008d), p. 9-15.</ref><ref name="UG-17-151">Ural and Garzia (2008), p. 17-151.</ref> | A typical system has three parts listed together as one system: spark/ember detectors on the duct, a water spray extinguishing unit downstream of them, and a control panel.<ref name="CH-9-23" /> The system works only where the dust concentration in the duct is below the minimum explosible concentration (MEC). It is a fire-extinguishing system, not an explosion protection system.<ref name="CH-9-24">Cholin (2008d), p. 9-24.</ref><ref name="CH-9-25">Cholin (2008d), p. 9-25.</ref> The ''Fire Protection Handbook'' (2008) describes its use in US woodworking plants under NFPA 664, NFPA 69 and NFPA 72 as they stood around 2007–2008.<ref name="CH-9-15">Cholin (2008d), p. 9-15.</ref><ref name="UG-17-151">Ural and Garzia (2008), p. 17-151.</ref><ref name="CH-9-22">Cholin (2008d), p. 9-22.</ref> | ||
== Why sparks in ducts matter == | == Why sparks in ducts matter == | ||
Woodworking machines that saw, mill or sand wood regularly produce sparks and embers, and the dust collection system picks them up together with the wood particulate.<ref name="CH-9-21">Cholin (2008d), p. 9-21.</ref> In some plants dozens of sparks per hour have been detected, some no larger than a BB of about 4 mm (0.177 in.).<ref name="CH-9-21" /> Most are quenched on the duct walls, on large chips or in resinous material, and perhaps one in a million survives the journey to the collector.<ref name="CH-9-21" /> Inside the collector, a surviving spark can start a fire on the filter media or ignite the dust suspension in the hopper.<ref name="CH-9-21" /> Embers produced by grinding, sanding and cutting can also ignite a wood dust layer in which they become embedded. Ural and Garzia (2008) note that spark detection and extinguishing systems described in NFPA 69 may be appropriate in such operations.<ref name="UG-17-151" /> | Woodworking machines that saw, mill or sand wood regularly produce sparks and embers, and the dust collection system picks them up together with the wood particulate.<ref name="CH-9-21">Cholin (2008d), p. 9-21.</ref> In some plants dozens of sparks per hour have been detected, some no larger than a BB of about 4 mm (0.177 in.).<ref name="CH-9-21" /> Most are quenched on the duct walls, on large chips or in resinous material, and perhaps one in a million survives the journey to the collector.<ref name="CH-9-21" /> Inside the collector, a surviving spark can start a fire on the filter media or ignite the dust suspension in the hopper.<ref name="CH-9-21" /> Embers produced by grinding, sanding and cutting can also ignite a wood dust layer in which they become embedded. Ural and Garzia (2008) note that spark detection and extinguishing systems described in NFPA 69 may be appropriate in such operations.<ref name="UG-17-151" /> | ||
Heat detection is a poor alternative inside a collector because the large airflow carries the heat away. In a collection system of 50,000 cfm (1,400 m³/min), a fire of about 16 kW raises the air temperature by only 0.556 °C (1 °F). A differential heat detection system set at about 5.5 °C (10 °F) would respond only when the fire had grown to about 160 kW.<ref name="CH-9-25" /> Bits of burning material in a duct, by contrast, are easily detected with spark detectors.<ref name="CH-9-22" | Heat detection is a poor alternative inside a collector because the large airflow carries the heat away. In a collection system of 50,000 cfm (1,400 m³/min), a fire of about 16 kW raises the air temperature by only 0.556 °C (1 °F). A differential heat detection system set at about 5.5 °C (10 °F) would respond only when the fire had grown to about 160 kW.<ref name="CH-9-25" /> Bits of burning material in a duct, by contrast, are easily detected with spark detectors.<ref name="CH-9-22" /> Lataille (2008) lists spark extinguishing systems, together with inerting and explosion suppression, as options where ignition sources are hard to control, and describes them as suitable for fibres and flyings.<ref name="LA-8-13">Lataille (2008), p. 8-13.</ref> | ||
== Components and operation == | == Components and operation == | ||
The typical system consists of three basic components, each listed by a nationally recognised testing laboratory as part of one system.<ref name="CH-9-23" /> The first is a set of spark/ember detectors mounted on the duct. The second is a water spray extinguishing unit mounted downstream from the detectors. The third is a control panel that powers the detectors, receives their signals and provides power to actuate the extinguishing unit.<ref name="CH-9-23" /> | The typical system consists of three basic components, each listed by a nationally recognised testing laboratory as part of one system.<ref name="CH-9-23" /> The first is a set of spark/ember detectors mounted on the duct. The second is a water spray extinguishing unit mounted downstream from the detectors. The third is a control panel that powers the detectors, receives their signals and provides power to actuate the extinguishing unit.<ref name="CH-9-23" /> | ||
The system relies on the extreme sensitivity and speed of response of the detectors. Sparks travel down the conveying duct often at speeds as high as 6000 ft/min (30 m/s).<ref name="CH-9-23" /> When a detector senses the radiant emission of a spark, it signals the control unit, which energises the solenoid valve of the extinguishing unit. The unit then establishes a water spray pattern inside the duct that quenches the spark as it arrives at the nozzle.<ref name="CH-9-23" /> Dungan (2008a) describes the same sequence | The system relies on the extreme sensitivity and speed of response of the detectors. Sparks travel down the conveying duct often at speeds as high as 6000 ft/min (30 m/s).<ref name="CH-9-23" /> When a detector senses the radiant emission of a spark, it signals the control unit, which energises the solenoid valve of the extinguishing unit. The unit then establishes a water spray pattern inside the duct that quenches the spark as it arrives at the nozzle.<ref name="CH-9-23" /> Dungan (2008a) describes the same sequence with an example in which sawdust or textile fibre embers may be travelling past the detector at 328 ft/s (100 m/s). A subsequent detector further downstream often verifies extinguishment and, if necessary, repeats the spray burst at another point in the duct.<ref name="DU-14-25" /> | ||
[[File:fse-spark-detection-and-extinguishing-system-v1.svg|thumb|upright=1.5|alt=Duct with two spark detectors with overlapping fields of view, a downstream solenoid valve and spray nozzle, and a control unit|Basic layout of a spark detection and extinguishing system on a conveying duct.]] | |||
Each spray is short. The control panel has a timer that limits the water discharge, usually to between 3 and 15 seconds, after which the extinguishing unit is de-energised and the system waits for the next spark.<ref name="CH-9-24" /> The air movement is not shut down, and the whole dust collection system keeps running. The water discharged is normally limited to less than about 25 L (6.6 gal), a quantity that readily evaporates in the airflow.<ref name="CH-9-24" /> The systems are listed as integrated systems for the inlet pipes that convey dust to the collector, and every duct that enters the collector must be monitored.<ref name="CH-9-24" /> | Each spray is short. The control panel has a timer that limits the water discharge, usually to between 3 and 15 seconds, after which the extinguishing unit is de-energised and the system waits for the next spark.<ref name="CH-9-24" /> The air movement is not shut down, and the whole dust collection system keeps running. The water discharged is normally limited to less than about 25 L (6.6 gal), a quantity that readily evaporates in the airflow.<ref name="CH-9-24" /> The systems are listed as integrated systems for the inlet pipes that convey dust to the collector, and every duct that enters the collector must be monitored.<ref name="CH-9-24" /> | ||
| Line 29: | Line 30: | ||
If the distance from the detector to the source is doubled, the signal drops to (1/2)<sup>2</sup> = 1/4 of its previous value.<ref name="DU-14-23" /> Seen the other way round, an ember three times farther away must emit nine times more radiant power to give the same signal. The SFPE Handbook adds an extinction coefficient of the air to account for absorption between source and detector. Manufacturers use the relation to publish fire size versus distance curves for each detector.<ref name="SM-4-31" /> | If the distance from the detector to the source is doubled, the signal drops to (1/2)<sup>2</sup> = 1/4 of its previous value.<ref name="DU-14-23" /> Seen the other way round, an ember three times farther away must emit nine times more radiant power to give the same signal. The SFPE Handbook adds an extinction coefficient of the air to account for absorption between source and detector. Manufacturers use the relation to publish fire size versus distance curves for each detector.<ref name="SM-4-31" /> | ||
The second relation is the travel distance of the spark during the response of the system. | The second relation is the travel distance of the spark during the response of the system. Cholin (2008d) states that the distance between detector and extinguishing unit must be computed from the duct diameter, the conveying velocity and the response times of the detectors, extinguishing unit and control panel:<ref name="CH-9-23" /> | ||
<math display="block">L = v\,t_\mathrm{r}</math> | <math display="block">L = v\,t_\mathrm{r}</math> | ||
| Line 49: | Line 50: | ||
''Worked example.'' The handbook gives no response times for spark extinguishing units. For scale, the definition of an ultra-high-speed water spray system in NFPA 15 is used here: water discharge within 100 milliseconds (ms) of detection, with about 10 ms achievable.<ref name="GA-16-109">Gagnon (2008), p. 16-109.</ref> A spark moving at 30 m/s travels 30 × 0.100 = 3.0 m in 100 ms and 0.30 m in 10 ms. At the 100 m/s quoted by Dungan (2008a), the distances become 10 m and 1.0 m.<ref name="DU-14-25" /> The water spray must therefore be established at a point that the spark reaches only after the whole response sequence has run. | ''Worked example.'' The handbook gives no response times for spark extinguishing units. For scale, the definition of an ultra-high-speed water spray system in NFPA 15 is used here: water discharge within 100 milliseconds (ms) of detection, with about 10 ms achievable.<ref name="GA-16-109">Gagnon (2008), p. 16-109.</ref> A spark moving at 30 m/s travels 30 × 0.100 = 3.0 m in 100 ms and 0.30 m in 10 ms. At the 100 m/s quoted by Dungan (2008a), the distances become 10 m and 1.0 m.<ref name="DU-14-25" /> The water spray must therefore be established at a point that the spark reaches only after the whole response sequence has run. | ||
The example also shows why a wrong velocity input matters. Failure to compute these factors properly makes it possible for the spark to pass the extinguishing unit before the water discharge has built up an effective concentration in the duct.<ref name="CH-9-23" /> There is usually also a minimum distance between the extinguishing unit and the dust collector, set by the conveying velocity, the duct diameter and the water pressure.<ref name="CH-9-23" /> The | The example also shows why a wrong velocity input matters. Failure to compute these factors properly makes it possible for the spark to pass the extinguishing unit before the water discharge has built up an effective concentration in the duct.<ref name="CH-9-23" /> There is usually also a minimum distance between the extinguishing unit and the dust collector, set by the conveying velocity, the duct diameter and the water pressure.<ref name="CH-9-23" /> The handbook gives an upper value of 30 m/s from Cholin (2008d) and an illustrative 100 m/s from Dungan (2008a). These differ by a factor of about three, so the travel distance can only be fixed once the actual conveying velocity of the duct is known.<ref name="CH-9-23" /><ref name="DU-14-25" /> | ||
[[File:fse-spark-detection-and-extinguishing-system-v2.svg|thumb|upright=1.5|alt=Line chart of spark travel distance against response time for spark speeds of 30 and 100 metres per second|Distance a spark travels during the response time of the system, L = v × t, using NFPA 15 ultra-high-speed response times for scale; the sources give no response times for spark extinguishing units.]] | |||
== Applications == | == Applications == | ||
The main application is the protection of dust collectors in a [[Woodworking facility]]. A spark detection and extinguishing system on the inlet lines detects and quenches the sparks in the wood particulate stream before they enter the collector.<ref name="CH-9-24" /> A second set of detectors on the return air duct actuates an abort gate that keeps smoke, flame and burning material out of the building. The same signal shuts off the automatic bag cleaning of the collector.<ref name="CH-9-24" /> In some cases the second set of detectors actuates a water deluge system inside the collector.<ref name="CH-9-24" /> | The main application is the protection of dust collectors in a [[Woodworking facility]]. A spark detection and extinguishing system on the inlet lines detects and quenches the sparks in the wood particulate stream before they enter the collector.<ref name="CH-9-24" /> A second set of detectors on the return air duct actuates an abort gate that keeps smoke, flame and burning material out of the building. The same signal shuts off the automatic bag cleaning of the collector.<ref name="CH-9-24" /> In some cases the second set of detectors actuates a water deluge system inside the collector.<ref name="CH-9-24" /> | ||
[[File:fse-spark-detection-and-extinguishing-system-v3.svg|thumb|upright=1.5|alt=Dust collector with spark detectors and extinguishing nozzle on the inlet duct and a second set of detectors operating an abort gate on the return air duct|Spark detection and extinguishing on the inlet of a dust collector, with a second detector set operating the return air abort gate.]] | |||
As described in the 2008 handbook, NFPA 664 required a listed spark detection system that activates an abort gate wherever cleaned conveying air was returned to the building.<ref name="CH-9-15" /> This abort function was the minimum code-compliant protection for a woodworking dust collector, not the accepted best practice. Most plants add spark detection and extinguishment on the inlets to reduce downtime and protect the investment in the collector.<ref name="CH-9-23" /> Design and installation of the spark detection were governed by NFPA 72. Because operating the abort gate is a remedial action for life safety and property, a listed protected premises fire alarm control panel, listed as a releasing device, was required.<ref name="CH-9-22" /><ref name="CH-9-23" /> | As described in the 2008 handbook, NFPA 664 required a listed spark detection system that activates an abort gate wherever cleaned conveying air was returned to the building.<ref name="CH-9-15" /> This abort function was the minimum code-compliant protection for a woodworking dust collector, not the accepted best practice. Most plants add spark detection and extinguishment on the inlets to reduce downtime and protect the investment in the collector.<ref name="CH-9-23" /> Design and installation of the spark detection were governed by NFPA 72. Because operating the abort gate is a remedial action for life safety and property, a listed protected premises fire alarm control panel, listed as a releasing device, was required.<ref name="CH-9-22" /><ref name="CH-9-23" /> | ||
The systems are also used before storage. Material conveyed into silos, bunkers and bins is usually monitored by spark detection coupled with an intermittent water spray on the in-feed conveyor. In some plants the detectors instead operate diverter valves that send the flow to a safe location known as a fire dump.<ref name="CH-9-6" /> Downstream of wood particle dryers, spark/ember detection and intermittent water spray limit the number of sparks entering the production space.<ref name="CH-9-8">Cholin (2008d), p. 9-8.</ref> Outside woodworking, Dungan (2008a) names textile plant ventilation as a typical use.<ref name="DU-14-25" /> | The systems are also used before storage. Material conveyed into silos, bunkers and bins is usually monitored by spark detection coupled with an intermittent water spray on the in-feed conveyor. In some plants the detectors instead operate diverter valves that send the flow to a safe location known as a fire dump.<ref name="CH-9-6" /> Downstream of wood particle dryers, spark/ember detection and intermittent water spray limit the number of sparks entering the production space.<ref name="CH-9-8">Cholin (2008d), p. 9-8.</ref> For dryers in general, Ostrowski (2008a) notes that high-speed infrared detectors with water spray might be needed to extinguish sparks or embers in the ducts of the dust-collecting system. Their purpose is to prevent propagation to bins or dust collectors.<ref name="OS-8-91">Ostrowski (2008a), p. 8-91.</ref> Outside woodworking, Dungan (2008a) names textile plant ventilation as a typical use.<ref name="DU-14-25" /> | ||
== Limits and misconceptions == | == Limits and misconceptions == | ||
| Line 71: | Line 74: | ||
== Related fast-acting systems == | == Related fast-acting systems == | ||
Spark extinguishing systems share their detection principle with | Spark extinguishing systems share their detection principle with other fast-acting systems. Ultra-high-speed water spray systems combine flame detection with very short water discharge times. Gagnon (2008) lists explosive dust collecting and conveying operations among the hazards for which the squib-actuated version is recommended.<ref name="GA-16-118" /> Explosion suppression systems detect an incipient explosion inside an enclosure and discharge an agent before the pressure reaches the damage threshold. In dust applications they usually rely on pressure detectors rather than radiation sensors.<ref name="ZS-3-417">Zalosh (2002), p. 3-417.</ref> Both deal with a different hazard from the single sparks that a spark detection and extinguishing system is built to quench.<ref name="CH-9-24" /> | ||
== See also == | == See also == | ||
| Line 88: | Line 91: | ||
* Gagnon, R. M. (2008). Ultra-High-Speed water spray systems. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), ''Fire protection handbook'' (20th ed., pp. 16-109–16-133). National Fire Protection Association. | * Gagnon, R. M. (2008). Ultra-High-Speed water spray systems. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), ''Fire protection handbook'' (20th ed., pp. 16-109–16-133). National Fire Protection Association. | ||
* Lataille, J. I. (2008). Air-Moving equipment. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), ''Fire protection handbook'' (20th ed., pp. 8-3–8-15). National Fire Protection Association. | * Lataille, J. I. (2008). Air-Moving equipment. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), ''Fire protection handbook'' (20th ed., pp. 8-3–8-15). National Fire Protection Association. | ||
* Ostrowski, R. (2008a). Industrial and commercial heat utilization equipment. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), ''Fire protection handbook'' (20th ed., pp. 8-71–8-92). National Fire Protection Association. | |||
* Schifiliti, R. P., Meacham, B. J., & Custer, R. L. P. (2002). Design of detection systems. In P. J. DiNenno, D. Drysdale, C. L. Beyler, W. D. Walton, R. L. P. Custer, J. R. Hall Jr., & J. M. Watts Jr. (Eds.), ''SFPE handbook of fire protection engineering'' (3rd ed., pp. 4-1–4-43). National Fire Protection Association; Society of Fire Protection Engineers. | * Schifiliti, R. P., Meacham, B. J., & Custer, R. L. P. (2002). Design of detection systems. In P. J. DiNenno, D. Drysdale, C. L. Beyler, W. D. Walton, R. L. P. Custer, J. R. Hall Jr., & J. M. Watts Jr. (Eds.), ''SFPE handbook of fire protection engineering'' (3rd ed., pp. 4-1–4-43). National Fire Protection Association; Society of Fire Protection Engineers. | ||
* Ural, E. A., & Garzia, H. W. (2008). Explosion prevention and protection. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), ''Fire protection handbook'' (20th ed., pp. 17-141–17-165). National Fire Protection Association. | * Ural, E. A., & Garzia, H. W. (2008). Explosion prevention and protection. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), ''Fire protection handbook'' (20th ed., pp. 17-141–17-165). National Fire Protection Association. | ||
Latest revision as of 08:57, 9 November 2026
A spark detection and extinguishing system is a fire protection system that detects burning sparks and embers in a duct by their radiant energy and quenches them with a short water spray downstream.[1] It is typically fitted to the ducts of a Pneumatic conveying system that carries wood dust or other combustible particles to a Dust collector, silo or bin.[2][3] Its purpose is to stop a small burning particle from reaching a place where it could start a large fire or a Dust explosion.[3]
A typical system has three parts listed together as one system: spark/ember detectors on the duct, a water spray extinguishing unit downstream of them, and a control panel.[1] The system works only where the dust concentration in the duct is below the minimum explosible concentration (MEC). It is a fire-extinguishing system, not an explosion protection system.[4][5] The Fire Protection Handbook (2008) describes its use in US woodworking plants under NFPA 664, NFPA 69 and NFPA 72 as they stood around 2007–2008.[6][7][8]
Why sparks in ducts matter
Woodworking machines that saw, mill or sand wood regularly produce sparks and embers, and the dust collection system picks them up together with the wood particulate.[9] In some plants dozens of sparks per hour have been detected, some no larger than a BB of about 4 mm (0.177 in.).[9] Most are quenched on the duct walls, on large chips or in resinous material, and perhaps one in a million survives the journey to the collector.[9] Inside the collector, a surviving spark can start a fire on the filter media or ignite the dust suspension in the hopper.[9] Embers produced by grinding, sanding and cutting can also ignite a wood dust layer in which they become embedded. Ural and Garzia (2008) note that spark detection and extinguishing systems described in NFPA 69 may be appropriate in such operations.[7]
Heat detection is a poor alternative inside a collector because the large airflow carries the heat away. In a collection system of 50,000 cfm (1,400 m³/min), a fire of about 16 kW raises the air temperature by only 0.556 °C (1 °F). A differential heat detection system set at about 5.5 °C (10 °F) would respond only when the fire had grown to about 160 kW.[5] Bits of burning material in a duct, by contrast, are easily detected with spark detectors.[8] Lataille (2008) lists spark extinguishing systems, together with inerting and explosion suppression, as options where ignition sources are hard to control, and describes them as suitable for fibres and flyings.[10]
Components and operation
The typical system consists of three basic components, each listed by a nationally recognised testing laboratory as part of one system.[1] The first is a set of spark/ember detectors mounted on the duct. The second is a water spray extinguishing unit mounted downstream from the detectors. The third is a control panel that powers the detectors, receives their signals and provides power to actuate the extinguishing unit.[1]
The system relies on the extreme sensitivity and speed of response of the detectors. Sparks travel down the conveying duct often at speeds as high as 6000 ft/min (30 m/s).[1] When a detector senses the radiant emission of a spark, it signals the control unit, which energises the solenoid valve of the extinguishing unit. The unit then establishes a water spray pattern inside the duct that quenches the spark as it arrives at the nozzle.[1] Dungan (2008a) describes the same sequence with an example in which sawdust or textile fibre embers may be travelling past the detector at 328 ft/s (100 m/s). A subsequent detector further downstream often verifies extinguishment and, if necessary, repeats the spray burst at another point in the duct.[3]
Each spray is short. The control panel has a timer that limits the water discharge, usually to between 3 and 15 seconds, after which the extinguishing unit is de-energised and the system waits for the next spark.[4] The air movement is not shut down, and the whole dust collection system keeps running. The water discharged is normally limited to less than about 25 L (6.6 gal), a quantity that readily evaporates in the airflow.[4] The systems are listed as integrated systems for the inlet pipes that convey dust to the collector, and every duct that enters the collector must be monitored.[4]
Spark/ember detectors
Spark/ember detectors belong, with the Flame detector, to the radiant energy-sensing fire detectors. These sense the electromagnetic radiation that flames or glowing embers emit in the ultraviolet, visible and infrared parts of the spectrum.[11] The SFPE Handbook gives the bands as 0.1 to 0.35 µm for ultraviolet, 0.35 to 0.75 µm for visible light and 0.75 to 220 µm for infrared.[12] The radiant energy from an ember is mainly infrared and, to a lesser degree, visible. Embers generally do not emit significant ultraviolet energy until their temperature reaches about 1727 °C.[3] The detector's spectral response must therefore be matched to the emission of the particle to be detected.[11]
The detectors are mounted on a duct or conveyor so that they watch the fuel as it passes. They normally need a dark environment, so the part of a conveyor where they are installed usually has to be enclosed.[3] Common sources of nuisance alarms are incident light, electrostatic discharge in the fuel stream and electromagnetic interference.[3] The material between the burning particle and the sensor also matters. Humidity, smoke, dust and films on the optical surfaces absorb radiation, and lens clarity must be assured by electronic monitoring or inspection, possibly with an air purge of the lens.[13]
Design of such systems is usually performance based rather than prescriptive.[3] Schifiliti et al. (2002) list the factors that govern the choice of sensor. They include absorption by the atmosphere, nonfire radiation sources, the electromagnetic energy of the spark, ember or fire to be detected, and the distance to the sensor.[12] A radiation sensor is a line-of-sight device that must see the source and respond reliably within the required time, especially when it activates a fast extinguishing or suppression system.[12] Its sensitivity also falls as the source moves off the optical axis, and higher ambient temperatures can reduce it further.[14]
Detection distance and response time
Two simple relations govern the layout. The first is the inverse square law. All flame and spark/ember detectors respond according to this law, which defines the fire size versus distance curve of the detector.[11] For a source of given radiant power, the signal falls with the square of the distance:
If the distance from the detector to the source is doubled, the signal drops to (1/2)2 = 1/4 of its previous value.[11] Seen the other way round, an ember three times farther away must emit nine times more radiant power to give the same signal. The SFPE Handbook adds an extinction coefficient of the air to account for absorption between source and detector. Manufacturers use the relation to publish fire size versus distance curves for each detector.[14]
The second relation is the travel distance of the spark during the response of the system. Cholin (2008d) states that the distance between detector and extinguishing unit must be computed from the duct diameter, the conveying velocity and the response times of the detectors, extinguishing unit and control panel:[1]
| Symbol | Description | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| Radiant signal received by the detector at distances and | W | |
| Distance between the burning particle and the detector | m | |
| Distance a spark travels between detection and the establishment of the water spray | m | |
| Speed of the spark, close to the conveying air velocity | m/s | |
| Total response time of detector, control panel and extinguishing unit | s |
Worked example. The handbook gives no response times for spark extinguishing units. For scale, the definition of an ultra-high-speed water spray system in NFPA 15 is used here: water discharge within 100 milliseconds (ms) of detection, with about 10 ms achievable.[15] A spark moving at 30 m/s travels 30 × 0.100 = 3.0 m in 100 ms and 0.30 m in 10 ms. At the 100 m/s quoted by Dungan (2008a), the distances become 10 m and 1.0 m.[3] The water spray must therefore be established at a point that the spark reaches only after the whole response sequence has run.
The example also shows why a wrong velocity input matters. Failure to compute these factors properly makes it possible for the spark to pass the extinguishing unit before the water discharge has built up an effective concentration in the duct.[1] There is usually also a minimum distance between the extinguishing unit and the dust collector, set by the conveying velocity, the duct diameter and the water pressure.[1] The handbook gives an upper value of 30 m/s from Cholin (2008d) and an illustrative 100 m/s from Dungan (2008a). These differ by a factor of about three, so the travel distance can only be fixed once the actual conveying velocity of the duct is known.[1][3]
Applications
The main application is the protection of dust collectors in a Woodworking facility. A spark detection and extinguishing system on the inlet lines detects and quenches the sparks in the wood particulate stream before they enter the collector.[4] A second set of detectors on the return air duct actuates an abort gate that keeps smoke, flame and burning material out of the building. The same signal shuts off the automatic bag cleaning of the collector.[4] In some cases the second set of detectors actuates a water deluge system inside the collector.[4]
As described in the 2008 handbook, NFPA 664 required a listed spark detection system that activates an abort gate wherever cleaned conveying air was returned to the building.[6] This abort function was the minimum code-compliant protection for a woodworking dust collector, not the accepted best practice. Most plants add spark detection and extinguishment on the inlets to reduce downtime and protect the investment in the collector.[1] Design and installation of the spark detection were governed by NFPA 72. Because operating the abort gate is a remedial action for life safety and property, a listed protected premises fire alarm control panel, listed as a releasing device, was required.[8][1]
The systems are also used before storage. Material conveyed into silos, bunkers and bins is usually monitored by spark detection coupled with an intermittent water spray on the in-feed conveyor. In some plants the detectors instead operate diverter valves that send the flow to a safe location known as a fire dump.[2] Downstream of wood particle dryers, spark/ember detection and intermittent water spray limit the number of sparks entering the production space.[16] For dryers in general, Ostrowski (2008a) notes that high-speed infrared detectors with water spray might be needed to extinguish sparks or embers in the ducts of the dust-collecting system. Their purpose is to prevent propagation to bins or dust collectors.[17] Outside woodworking, Dungan (2008a) names textile plant ventilation as a typical use.[3]
Limits and misconceptions
The most important limit is the dust concentration in the duct. The systems are applicable only when the combustible dust concentration in the conveying duct is below the MEC, which for most wood particulates is about 30 to 60 g/m³.[4][9] Above the MEC a spark could ignite a deflagration in the duct, and the system would then be of little value for three reasons.[4] The flame front moves much faster than the conveying velocity on which the detector-to-nozzle distance is based, so it passes the nozzle before the spray is established. The water delivered has not been evaluated for quenching a deflagration flame front. Flame fronts in ducts also tend to accelerate until they become a detonation.[4]
Ducts in which a deflagration can occur must therefore be protected by deflagration venting under NFPA 68 or by explosion prevention systems under NFPA 69, as the 2008 handbook describes.[5] A common misconception is that spark detection completely protects a dust collection system. It does not; it reduces the probability that burning material enters the collector.[5] A properly protected collector also has deflagration vents or explosion prevention and protection systems. These deal with a deflagration whose flame front travels too fast for the abort gate, and a sprinkler system in the collector should also be considered.[5] Protection against flame travelling back along the ducts, called Explosion isolation, is a separate task.[8]
The layout of the detectors also has limits. A single set of detectors on the collector inlet is generally not recommended for actuating the abort damper on the outlet.[4] In many woodworking operations sparks are a regular occurrence, and a properly working system detects several sparks a day.[5] Each time the damper operates, the air movement must be stopped for a manual reset. The stop lets the dust on the filter bags fall into the bottom of the collector, and any burning material inside could then turn a fire into a deflagration.[5]
Inspection, testing and maintenance
Spark/ember detectors depend on the optical clarity of their lenses and windows and on a clear line of sight.[18] Inspection must check for new obstructions and for opaque material on the optical surfaces. Many materials are transparent to visible light but opaque in the ultraviolet or infrared, where the detectors work.[18] Window clarity monitoring is not a sensitivity measurement. Sensitivity is measured with a radiant emitter listed for the purpose, and NFPA 72 required this measurement for both flame detectors and spark/ember detectors.[18]
Cholin (2008b) reports loss of clarity of the optical surfaces as a common cause of deteriorating performance.[18] Dusty atmospheres are a known problem for optical detectors in general. In ultra-high-speed water spray applications, fogging or loading of the lens can slow the reaction of ultraviolet detectors.[19]
Related fast-acting systems
Spark extinguishing systems share their detection principle with other fast-acting systems. Ultra-high-speed water spray systems combine flame detection with very short water discharge times. Gagnon (2008) lists explosive dust collecting and conveying operations among the hazards for which the squib-actuated version is recommended.[19] Explosion suppression systems detect an incipient explosion inside an enclosure and discharge an agent before the pressure reaches the damage threshold. In dust applications they usually rely on pressure detectors rather than radiation sensors.[20] Both deal with a different hazard from the single sparks that a spark detection and extinguishing system is built to quench.[4]
See also
Notes
- ↑ 1.00 1.01 1.02 1.03 1.04 1.05 1.06 1.07 1.08 1.09 1.10 1.11 Cholin (2008d), p. 9-23.
- ↑ 2.0 2.1 Cholin (2008d), p. 9-6.
- ↑ 3.00 3.01 3.02 3.03 3.04 3.05 3.06 3.07 3.08 3.09 Dungan (2008a), p. 14-25.
- ↑ 4.00 4.01 4.02 4.03 4.04 4.05 4.06 4.07 4.08 4.09 4.10 4.11 Cholin (2008d), p. 9-24.
- ↑ 5.0 5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 5.6 Cholin (2008d), p. 9-25.
- ↑ 6.0 6.1 Cholin (2008d), p. 9-15.
- ↑ 7.0 7.1 Ural and Garzia (2008), p. 17-151.
- ↑ 8.0 8.1 8.2 8.3 Cholin (2008d), p. 9-22.
- ↑ 9.0 9.1 9.2 9.3 9.4 Cholin (2008d), p. 9-21.
- ↑ Lataille (2008), p. 8-13.
- ↑ 11.0 11.1 11.2 11.3 Dungan (2008a), p. 14-23.
- ↑ 12.0 12.1 12.2 Schifiliti et al. (2002), p. 4-30.
- ↑ Dungan (2008a), p. 14-24.
- ↑ 14.0 14.1 Schifiliti et al. (2002), p. 4-31.
- ↑ Gagnon (2008), p. 16-109.
- ↑ Cholin (2008d), p. 9-8.
- ↑ Ostrowski (2008a), p. 8-91.
- ↑ 18.0 18.1 18.2 18.3 Cholin (2008b), pp. 14-68–14-69.
- ↑ 19.0 19.1 Gagnon (2008), p. 16-118.
- ↑ Zalosh (2002), p. 3-417.
References
- Cholin, J. M. (2008b). Inspection, testing, and maintenance of fire alarm systems. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 14-53–14-78). National Fire Protection Association.
- Cholin, J. M. (2008d). Woodworking facilities and processes. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 9-3–9-25). National Fire Protection Association.
- Dungan, K. W. (2008a). Automatic fire detectors. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 14-15–14-28). National Fire Protection Association.
- Gagnon, R. M. (2008). Ultra-High-Speed water spray systems. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 16-109–16-133). National Fire Protection Association.
- Lataille, J. I. (2008). Air-Moving equipment. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 8-3–8-15). National Fire Protection Association.
- Ostrowski, R. (2008a). Industrial and commercial heat utilization equipment. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 8-71–8-92). National Fire Protection Association.
- Schifiliti, R. P., Meacham, B. J., & Custer, R. L. P. (2002). Design of detection systems. In P. J. DiNenno, D. Drysdale, C. L. Beyler, W. D. Walton, R. L. P. Custer, J. R. Hall Jr., & J. M. Watts Jr. (Eds.), SFPE handbook of fire protection engineering (3rd ed., pp. 4-1–4-43). National Fire Protection Association; Society of Fire Protection Engineers.
- Ural, E. A., & Garzia, H. W. (2008). Explosion prevention and protection. In A. E. Cote, C. C. Grant, J. R. Hall Jr., & R. E. Solomon (Eds.), Fire protection handbook (20th ed., pp. 17-141–17-165). National Fire Protection Association.
- Zalosh, R. (2002). Explosion protection. In P. J. DiNenno, D. Drysdale, C. L. Beyler, W. D. Walton, R. L. P. Custer, J. R. Hall Jr., & J. M. Watts Jr. (Eds.), SFPE handbook of fire protection engineering (3rd ed., pp. 3-402–3-421). National Fire Protection Association; Society of Fire Protection Engineers.